READING ROOM
Great Writing - Home
Read and review others' work
Articles on writing
Advice from the community
COMMUNITY
Talk to others in the forums
Events and Competitions
GW News
ABOUT GREAT WRITING
All About Us
Contact Us
WORK AWAITING REVIEW
GW IS...
Great Writing creative writing community is designed to prompt ideas and provide inspiration and motivation within aspiring and amateur authors. Whatever your topic; from love poetry to Doctor Who or Harry Potter fan fiction, Great Writing's online writing group is where you can make new friends and improve your creative writing.
WHO'S ONLINE
We have 3118 guests online and 5 members online
Non-Fiction
Surrender
By gutterkitty
04 August 2007

A bit less abstract than my usual stuff, I think (which isn't saying much!). Couldn't think of a better title; suggestions and critique welcome.


I am tired of honesty.
Its brown paper packaging
and string that unfolds at the slightest touch.
Impossible to ignore,
it lends the lowest actions
a likeable bareness,
offers the giver a vulnerability
that slips beneath the skin,
nuzzles the ear. Honesty seduces,
passes from lip to lip in reconciliation,
an aphrodisiac. We are all human,
all warm skin and sweat.
To reject the gift of the truth
is cruel and cold. And so we yield,
glow warmer with benevolence
as we welcome back the sinner.

But oh, how I long for lies
when the click-rattle of your keys at night
means only confession.
A brown paper parcel between us
on the silence of the table.
Honesty is quiet, it makes my head ache,
makes me wish for sweet chords of deception,
for presents wrapped in gold paper,
tied elaborately with lies.
Spontaneous bunches of flowers
hiding what is best left unsaid.
To know that my surrender
was in ignorance, that it smelled of roses
instead of beer.

Reviews

Written by Phil (6713 comments posted) 4th August 2007
Less abstract suits me!  
 
I liked this, yet I found myself disagreeing with it on a personal level - not a crit - just a reaction. Each to their own in different situations I guess. Successful anyway, in that it illicited that response in me. 
 
Interesting - the first third of the first stanza had me thinking about politicians and evangelical preachers confessing their misdemeanours and then expecting to be welcomed back into the fold with open arms - only to do it again. 
 
You're right, honesty isn't a straight forward thing. 
 
Your work always makes me think. Not a bad thing at all. 
 
Enjoyed. 
 
Phil.
nice piece
Written by fellpony (1608 comments posted) 5th August 2007
beautifully written and persuasive. The speaker (I think she's female) is also deceiving herself in her wish for lies from her cheating partner. With Phil on this one. I too mistrust her wish for lies; I think that - now - she'd spot them every time, no matter how pretty the gold paper. Then, of course, you're into "Suspicion" country.  
 
I thought this a very good work.
Indeed
Written by patterjack (1193 comments posted) 5th August 2007
I find it difficult to separate out the content of this work from its expression and then to make a comment on that here. Were I to do so , I would , I fear , become a preaching moralist which is something I have tried to avoid all my life . 
 
But-- as Phil has said , it is a poem to make one think , presenting a duality that causes this reader to juggle argument with argument . 
 
Therefore to me it is effective in its overall dual structure . 
 
I am not so sure of the line by line expression , but were I to suggest changes , that would firstly be presumptuous , and then the couple that I would first off make could likely turn the work into something more prosy , and that would not be a good thing at all ! 
 
Hence it remains a satisfying piece, with some disturbing elements for me  
 
patterjack 
 
Effective
Written by Talisker (1326 comments posted) 5th August 2007
The words that Brian chose to use "duality" and "disturbing" - hit the nail. 
 
I am less reluctant than Phil and Sue to accept the possibility of a woman (in this case) preferring gilded lies to rusty truth. I'm sure that it is a common scenario - the refusing to accept reality - the compromising - the pragmatism.  
 
In my recent ditty "Poetry" - I suggested that poetry which "distorts" has a place - I think that this does, it smudges and blurs and forces us to attempt refocussing - as such it is challenging to preconceptions - which raises it above the ordinary for me. 
 
Oli
agree
Written by fellpony (1608 comments posted) 5th August 2007
with Talisker - I think the duality of the poem is not only a wish for lies from the partner but a wish to give/accept lies herself, at least on the top level. Having experienced this at second hand (daughter + partner) I agree people do deceive themselves. That's in here too. Yes, it's good work.

Written by madeupname (18 comments posted) 5th August 2007
I think...Sometimes the truth is a nasty pill and a hard thing to swallow from the point of the receiver. However it is a necessary medicine for healing. Lies are a very danderous poisonous no matter how sweet they taste.

   Only registered users can rate and write comments.
   Please login or register.

Powered by AkoComment 2.0!

 Previous item