I worked for one of the larger charitable organisations once. Just an observation...
The little man is on the street and sitting in his chair
He sits there every Saturday, enduring hostile stares
A rug is wrapped around his knees to protect him from the cold
Begging pennies for the children, the disabled and the old.
He was given a gold medal for being a marvellous gent
But he doesn’t know what the cash pays for and how the cash is spent.
Despite the big certificate for all the effort made
One good look at the balance sheet might make his smile fade
Charity begins, of course, with coins thrown in a tin.
The volunteers, the public face, are just to take you in.
Covering scandal and corruption and a sort of legal theft;
Expenses paid out everywhere, till there’s very little left.
So shake hard on that charity tin and collect more for the needy.
Don’t mention the deception, because then it seems so seedy.
Then before the poor get their share, just buy a company car
And then, maybe, a designer suit and a large house with a bar.
When networking and pressing flesh, one must look at one’s best
Meeting rich and wealthy people as the voice of the oppressed.
A respectable front just covers up the evil rot inside;
It’s a sop to people’s conscience and there’s such a lot to hide
This is Charity, you see, and they can never get enough,
An excuse for all ‘professionals’ to get their noses in the trough.
They can pass the buck with the worst of them, sod responsibility!
Life’s a ball, they’ve got a job, as a leech on society.
|
Written by Josie (2780 comments posted) 2nd December 2007 | | When we buy things, for example, at the Charity Shops, can you tell me how much of the money we spend goes to charity? The exact percentage please. Perhaps we need an Oxfam representative to tell us. Perhaps sending the money direct to the people is the best thing. Our church sends a lorry to Romania every Christmas with boxes of things for the children, packed by ourselves, and they hand them personally to the children. We also send boxes of things to help those out on the streets of Britain - to St George's Crypt, Bradford. The poor and needy are right under our noses. | Written by Phil (6683 comments posted) 2nd December 2007 | Okay - right to bring up the concern - but if I want to spread a little of my Western fortune (only relative - I'm a mere teacher) how do I do it? Phil | Written by Phil (6683 comments posted) 2nd December 2007 | | BTW - Been supporting Oxfam's Gifts Unwrapped for a couple of years. How's that in your opinion? | We're giving but just who is getting? Written by jillrabbit (57 comments posted) 2nd December 2007 | So many questions… I can’t pretend to have answers to these questions. I also can’t say that I have the answers to, what I see are, inherent contradictions in the institutionalised charity sector. My poem was a personal response to what I experienced whilst managing a medium-sized, charitable organisation some years ago. It was primarly a commentary on the gulf that existed between those people who keep the money coming in and the bureaucrats who feed off these organisations. An observation on the endless conferences and weekend team-building jaunts. Not to mention the generous expense accounts and company cars. While I was involved in the charitable sector I saw this go from being a national phenomenon to a regional and then a local one. So many meetings, so many symposiums, so many new jobs created. If you were’t networking then you weren’t with the program and were, somehow, off message. I’ve seen individuals land a job and profess their steely determination to wage war on poverty. Nine months later, they had made a career move and were then professing the same steely determination to end animal cruelty NOW! Not that any of these individuals ever came within spitting distance of the “problem” they were determined to solve. At best, they had achieved something; even if it was only an enhanced salary and benefits package. At worst - and this was all too common - they jumped before they were pushed. I recall one real-life example of how many charities operate, which left me shaking my head. It concerns a very prominent and well known national charity, which champions the rights of people with cerebral palsy. I was involved with arranging a work placement for someone, with this condition, in one of their regional offices. The office was, and is, very well funded and should have made an ideal location for providing this type of opportunity. It resulted in a plethora of complaints from this organisation, which mainly centered on the inconvenience this created. The main complaint was that this office was not organised to deal with a disabled member of staff and had no disabled access! The regional director did not seem to understand the concept of irony! I got the distinct impression that they were uncomfortable with being in close proximity to a disabled person. Every time I see an advertisment for a charity asking for my help to end a problem, and end it now, I ask myself one question. Are these people really sincere in requesting me to help turn them into an unemployment statistic?
| Charity is Big Business Written by Henry (57 comments posted) 2nd December 2007 | Hi jillrabbit, interesting piece and interesting discussion... Right now, the German branch of UNICEF is under fire with allegations of embezzlement, or at least, fraudulent appropriation of funds. The authorities have commenced with investigations. Yesterday, also overhere in Germany, the Roman Catholic Church plus the Protestant Church have started with their annual X-mas campaigns – this year, they want to support the Indios in South America and underdevolped populations worldwide, respectively. Sounds formidable. I gather from the national press that citizens in this country generally are donating freely, year after year. And there are plenty of other organizations lined up for the dough. There is real money involved, overall. Your piece and subsequent notes describe the situation in a disturbing but credible manner. From your choice of words in your follow-up notes, I had the impression that you have even restrained yourself... Query: Do I believe that my donations, if any, reach their destinations in full (minus an acceptable percentage for running the show)? Answer: No. Alternatives: Follow Josie's advice. Have a look at your neighbours. Maybe there are some candidates across the street. Thanks for your work and for giving food for thoughts. Henry. | yup Written by wt (137 comments posted) 3rd December 2007 | Hi JillRabbit Your feelings are echoed by many working in the field Ngos are great in relief / crisis..nut not so sure about economic development ... Very political as well as you well know.. I think that the percentages of the funds (per dollar) that get to intended beneficiaries are very low (single digit in many cases) ..but this is supposedly being adress specially at the UN where 80% of their budgets go to employees. But we'll stay kind...
| Written by maipenrai (783 comments posted) 3rd December 2007 | Got to say that this is a very iinteresting thread, and I would love to know where wt gets his/her figures from? are these figures coming from donar nations or from volunyary contibutions from the public?? it would be good to make that clear, otherwise it sounds quite alarmist? but maybe that was the intention? in actual fact I know bugger all about UK Based National Charitys, I do know about INGO'S, Progs run by IGNO'S get their money from Donar Nations=UK, Dfid, US=USaid, from the EU etc, major progs do not in normal circumstaces use money donated by the public, the exception is in emergecy situtions where cash donated by the public is used wt, i would love to see what you base your single digit figures on. | Written by maipenrai (783 comments posted) 3rd December 2007 | | ? wt, you work or have worked for INGO's ? |
Only registered users can rate and write comments. Please login or register. Powered by AkoComment 2.0! |