Great Writing - Home > Poetry > What We Hold
READING ROOM
Great Writing - Home
Read and review others' work
Articles on writing
Advice from the community
COMMUNITY
Talk to others in the forums
Events and Competitions
GW News
ABOUT GREAT WRITING
All About Us
Contact Us
WORK AWAITING REVIEW
GW IS...
Great Writing creative writing community is designed to prompt ideas and provide inspiration and motivation within aspiring and amateur authors. Whatever your topic; from love poetry to Doctor Who or Harry Potter fan fiction, Great Writing's online writing group is where you can make new friends and improve your creative writing.
WHO'S ONLINE
We have 1474 guests online and 5 members online
Poetry
What We Hold
By Amelia
06 December 2007
 This poem was hard for me to write, and it needs revision. I wanted the style to be spare and simple; a clear statement of facts. However, I do think it needs revision to sound less awkward and more poetic. I'm a prose writer, so the freedom of poetry is difficult for me to become used to. Any suggestions are welcome.

My grandmother was wealthy for two years of her life.
Two years, though all she ever wanted
was to live in comfort.
She was born into the Great Depression
and told stories of her family
sharing a single can of Spam for dinner.
She married my grandfather, a restless man
who fixed the phone lines and worked too hard
just to keep his family fed.
He was unfaithful; she was furious.
My grandmother held on to everything
and in her dim attic, my mom and I discovered
box after box of old newspaper clippings,
cards, photos, letters of apology from the man
who cheated her second husband out of all his money.

My grandmother was dying,
and every night my mom came home
from visiting her at hospice
I would sit on my bed upstairs
as I listened to her in the kitchen
unpacking boxes,
raw from her own divorce,
holding in the tears,
her strangled sobs covered by her hands
and I wanted more than anything
to go downstairs and tell her she could cry
let it go
that she didn’t have to hold on
but instead I stared at my hands,
fingers twisting and curling like dying things
and pretended I couldn’t hear.

At my grandmother’s wake,
my aunts looked over the messy scribblings
that she had written to the nurses
in her last weeks
when she could no longer speak
and when my aunt Linny turned over a page
and I glanced at where, in shaky scrawl
the words “kill me” had been scratched,
my aunt quietly crumpled up the page
and held it in her hand.

Reviews

Written by audrie (451 comments posted) 6th December 2007
I don't think you need to alter anything, Amelia, you tell the story as it is. Very sad, very painful but that is life! 
 
Very few poets these days seem to think rhyme is in any way important, and their writings are more like lines of prose, so I shouldn't worry about it. But that is just my opinion. 
 
Of course, I am not qualified to judge and I'm sure you will get advice from the far more expert readers than I am.
Hello Amelia
Written by Josie (2785 comments posted) 6th December 2007
Amelia, you will get all different opinions. I think your story would be so much better if you had made it as a story for the short story section. I write both prose and poetry, and for me, there is a huge difference, and a big difference in language. I, personally, do not like to see prose broken into little lines of varying lengths and classed as poetry, as prose has a special place in the world of writing, equally as good as poetry but completely different. I'd like to see this in the short story section myself.
Hi
Written by maipenrai (783 comments posted) 6th December 2007
Amelia, this is a powerful, good write. 
Thank You for sharing this with us. 
Bernie
Good work!
Written by jillrabbit (57 comments posted) 6th December 2007
I think this is a moving poem. It works well as it is. My only suggestion, and others might disagree, is that the 'and's at the beginning of a few of the lines are nt needed. Try reading it without them; what do you think? 
 
Regards 
 
JillR
Rhythm
Written by seaJane (23 comments posted) 6th December 2007
I really like the effect and power of this but agree that if it is going to be a poem you could think about revising it. 
 
One of the things that make it more like prose for me is that the words are a clear statement of facts, as you wanted (and I agree that having extra ones for the sake of being poetic is no go), but they do no more than that - raise no recurring images to push beyond fact, which is where I think the best poetry goes. 
 
I think the recurrent images of hands and paper are important in this way, and they are something you could build on. 
 
But whatever I think - that is just such a strong episode. Wow. 

Written by fellpony (1608 comments posted) 6th December 2007
I agree with you Amelia - it could stand some revision in order to work better as a poem. It's not at all bad, mind you! It's lucid and tells a comprehensible story.  
 
I can see that you are more skilled in prose, and in one way I agree with Josie that it would work just as well as a prose piece. However, here's a suggestion of how you might tackle the first six lines: 
 
My grandmother was wealthy  
for two years, only two, 
when all her life she'd yearned  
to live in comfort. 
Born into the Great Depression 
she told stories of her family 
dining on one can of Spam ...
Thanks everyone
Written by Amelia (30 comments posted) 6th December 2007
Wow, thanks everyone who left comments!  
 
Audrie- I'm glad you liked the piece 
 
Josie- I definitely see where you're coming from. I consider myself first and foremost a writer of prose, so poetry is definitely an adjustment. However, I think this particular piece would sound strange the way it is but without any line breaks. I like the fact that each stanza is broken up, because they each deal with a different character and a different situation; almost like little scenes. Thank you so much for reading and thinking about my writing- that means the world to me. 
 
maipenrai- powerful is what I was aiming for, as I guess any writer is. Thank you for the compliment, and thanks for reading. 
 
jillrabbit- I think reading too much Ray Bradbury has had this affect on me- when I'm writing creatively I use lots of conjunctions to get a stream of consciousness feel. Definitely something I should watch out for. Thank you!
I liked this
Written by patterjack (1194 comments posted) 6th December 2007
But... 
 
the freedom of poetry is difficult for me to become used to 
 
Don't ever let the maunderings of some stream of consciousness poets give you the idea that writing poetry is more free than writing prose !!!!  
 
True , you could tighten this -- but then why ? it is good as it is , carries its message and its emotion in its narrative way , and the intricacy of characterisation in the last few lines is excellently done . 
 
Good prose , and very close to good poetry as well 
 
patterjack 
 
 
 

   Only registered users can rate and write comments.
   Please login or register.

Powered by AkoComment 2.0!

 Previous item   Next item