The opening paragraph for this was posted a few days ago as a tester. I have a pretty good idea where this is going now. It won't be novel length, but too long for here. If this part goes down alright, I'll continue in 'extended.'
The world, so Manny says, is a large and wonderful place; but standing here, it shrinks. Looking at the boarded and fenced house that stands on the corner of Wood Street and York Avenue makes everything that I've become focus down to the history held within a simple end terrace. Nothing special to most; it wouldn't even merit a second glance to passers by. Yet it has its own gravity. There's a certain magic here where the reality is thin and I have to try hard not to slip through into the past, or worse, step sideways and become a different me. Manny says there's no such thing as magic, but it's real enough. This is where I began, and in all likelihood, where I'll end.
~X~
Michael waits at the gate for his brother to arrive. Three-thirty sees two hundred or so children rush from the building and disappear into the neighbourhood in all directions. Some laughing and shouting, some in pairs and small groups, some making arrangements for meeting later after tea at the ‘rec.' All though, eagerly homeward bound after a day trapped inside a building constructed in Victorian times, surrounded by concrete and manned by discontented staff.
Michael sighs and guesses the time must be about twenty to four. He spots Charlie slump out of the junior entrance, head down and shuffling towards him. Late afternoon sun lights Charlie from the front showing scuffed shoes, too short trousers and a greying and stained untucked shirt.
‘'Bout time. Come on, we'll be late,' says Michael. ‘What's up?'
Charlie stops by his brother.
‘Nothing. Can we go to the park on the way home?'
‘No. Late already. Come on.'
Michael takes Charlie's bag, throws it over his shoulder with his own and walks off with Charlie following reluctantly behind him. Streets now quiet, swallow the boys into the miniature universes that exist unknown behind closed doors. They reach the corner and stop at the gate, watching the front door.
‘Quiet,' Michael says and gently pushes Charlie through towards the front door.
~X~
Why is it that while I'm talking to Manny, it all makes perfect sense, but when I leave, all those words seem hollow and far away? He tells me I should stay away from Wood Street, and while I'm with him, it all makes perfect sense. I know it does me no good. He tells me it's all in the past and I have to move on, start afresh. I know he's right, but nights alone in the flat, I can hear it calling me. More accurately, I can hear Mikey calling me back. Ever back to that fucking, dirty hell hole.
~X~
Charlie sits at the Formica table and watches Michael stir beans on the stove. This morning's breakfast pots still lay in the sink on top of last night's tea plates.
‘Toast Charlie. Put the toast on,' says Michael.
Charlie gets up and pulls out two white slices from an almost finished loaf of bread. He puts the toast under the grill, sits down and watches his brother again.
‘Is he coming home tonight?' he asks.
‘Prob'ly. Best get these dishes washed and put away after.'
Charlie looks at the sink impassively and back at his brother.
‘When's he back?'
‘Later Charlie, later.'
Michael takes the toast from the grill and serves the beans on top. They eat in silence.
~X~
Day times I'm fine. Traffic, TV, radio and inane chatter combine to all but drown out the pleading call that wakes me every night. Eight hours in the packing plant really helps. The noise in there screens all but the loudest calls - and those mainly come from the management via the loud speaker system. Manny's given me Nitrazepam to help me sleep at night but I can't live all the time in a dulled state. Every so often I miss a few days just to feel again. Those are the days the cry comes through loud, clear and strong and with regret I return to the drugs and a faded existence.
~X~
Charlie lies awake and listens. The soft, regular breathing from the bed to his right tells him Michael is asleep. He waits, and with a lurch deep in his stomach, he hears a key in the front door. Michael stirs.
‘That him?' he mumbles.
Charlie says nothing, only curls up tighter, shuts his eyes and hopes.
‘Just lie still.'
Footsteps, uneven, lurch up the stairs and the bedroom door opens to frame a large man leaning on the doorframe. He stands, stares, then eventually sighs and leaves. Another door clatters open and shut and bedsprings pop and strain then settle. Silence returns to the house. Silence, except for the muffled sobs of Charlie and the whispered comfortings of Michael.
|
Written by johniebg (538 comments posted) 6th December 2007 |
Mnnn. It is amazing how the very first words of a story are so important and almost always the most confusing; "The world, so Manny tells says" is the 'tells' meant to be there? This was too short for my mind - it sets up as you would maybe expect in a novel and armed with the knowledge it will be a long one we do not mind the short snatches but there is not enough for us to get into the story. The ending here sets some real atmosphere for the sobbing child just felt to cliche, more of the story might have grounded that moment. Apart from that the main criticism is that you missed some excellent opportunities to paint atmosphere in our minds. You tell us the children stream out of the school but don't paint the picture. You tell us the light falls on the boy in the corridor but don't craft it with detail. The shadow of the man at the end tells us rather than painting a picture by describing the broad outline of a male. The description of the sounds getting into bed and the popping springs is the sort of thing missing from those other moments. Finally, we hope that this is just not a straight account of child abuse, there would hopefully be some bigger story wound through the narrative. But this is so short, you don't build any story that we assume the worst. But this had genuine feel and as a reader I was ready to invest in the characters, it evoked a similar feel as the beginning of Anne Enright's 'The Gathering' and that won a booker prize, might be worth checking it out. Summary: Too short and lacking atmospheric craft which leads us frustration and to fear the worst, but some promise from the narrative perspective. |
HI Phil Written by jean.day (2279 comments posted) 6th December 2007 |
I like the way you are alternating between now and then, and always the unanswered questions to keep the read wanting to find out more. Having read Johnnie's crit, I do agree that you might have used a bit more description, but on the other hand, while you are writing your first draft, you should let if flow, and then later you can go back and put in more adjectives and phrases if you want to. I'm currently reading Thomas Mann's Death in Venice, and it is so full of beautiful description that I lose the plot. I have to read it over and over again to remember what I am supposed to be get involved in. So, I for one think there can sometimes be too much description. I liked the closeness of the two boys and you certainly have shown why the younger brother especially does not want to go home. Keep it coming. I would continue to post it here, if I were you, despite the fact that it is intended to be a story. You will get many more people reading it. When Bagheera first posted his chapters of the book which is now being considered for publication - something about Dreams - nobody read it. When I came upon it, he had posted the first 5 chapters and had not a single review. He was pleading with somebody to read it - and when I started it, I couldn't stop and read the first 5 chapters and then followed it faithfully throughout - but I was just about the only one. I can see the reasoning behind having books posted in extended - because it is easier to find the previous chapters if you come into it late, and important to have the flow. But the truth of the matter is that most people on this site don't want to be bogged down with reading a long piece that fits into a context. Witzel never put her booky bits in extended. Anyway, I very much enjoyed reading this and hope you will continue. |
Written by Fledermaus (3281 comments posted) 7th December 2007 |
Ah. So you're going through and fro in time, now that explains something, for I had to read it twice. I was confused as to the age of the main characters, but now I presume they are kids in one part and young adults in the other. Very interesting story, but not an easy read, perhaps because you left out so much. I do expect these holes to be filled later though... btw. What happened to Station Road (now that you name another piece after a street)? |
Written by woody44 (775 comments posted) 7th December 2007 |
A life ruined by abuse, a well-worn trail. I will be very interested Phil to see how you progress this. You have set the scene, now go for the juggular, lift the tale out of the ordinary to one that lingers long after the last sentence has been read. For that reason I will be following its progress with interest. Roger |
Written by Phil (6719 comments posted) 7th December 2007 |
Thanks for the considereed reviews. I can't really disagree. I think I've allowed style to overcome content. I wanted a pretty sparse style but I think I knew myself it didn't work too well. I'll have another go at starting this from the beginning. That first bloody line: I thought I'd edited it - and had here, but dragged it up off my hard drive where I hadn't. Sorted now. Some of the most useful reviews I've had. For that I'm very grateful. Glad it seems to have legs, but I do need to reconsider delivery. Phil |
phil Written by wt (137 comments posted) 7th December 2007 |
Hi Phil, I think I get a sense of its potential. Perhaps omit all the descriptive/scenery with the boys and incorporate/fuse their dialogue into the "present" ... this should preserve the atmosphere and indeed empower its effect while also keep the reader guessing as to the history/link Good Luck wt
|
Written by Bottleblondesurfer (3352 comments posted) 8th December 2007 |
Right, it seems you have committed yourself so just ignore my PM,it's a bit redundant. I thought the opening was a good one, though I'd query the word magic. It set up an expectation that had to be confounded [by me anyway] but apart from that it did what intros are supposed to do, create curiosity. I felt it was written in black and white, rather than colour.It had a 60s feel to it, or even 50s, so wondered how old the man was now. I didn't have a problem with the spareness of the descriptiion, firstly-I think it's your style and there were enough broad strokes to paint the picture and allow the reader to fill in; secondly it is seen through the eyes of a man imagining himself as the boy, and so you would only see what was important to him, what stood out in his memory. And memory is notoriously selective. I'd be wary of tarting it up too much. You might lose the focus. Yes I can only echo Woody, He is right on the money. Take it well away from the ordinary and cliched route.So far it's all open. cheers Jane |
Written by Lizzy (793 comments posted) 10th December 2007 |
I agree with Jane the sparsity of descriptions only adds to the horror of the 'abusive situation of the boys. i think that you have given us enough information so far and I for one would like to know more about what is happening. Who is Manny and why is Mikey 'calling him back'? Look forward to reading more of this Phil. Lizzy |
Pictures! PICTURES!!!I'LL GIVE YOU PICT Written by gerardconnolly (1186 comments posted) 11th December 2007 |
Phil, I did think this was very good. You have obviously thought about your characterisation. And the narration was running on well to fine to just might. Ignore the critics. OK. This still needs a lot of attention. Most notably where is it going? Take my word you need to have two or three chapters in front of you before you can think of ' the story '. That is to say that's when you, usually, run out of steam. If you have plotted to go to say five chapters and can continue running like this, then I think you have got something. Even if you haven't; let it lie fallow and get on with promoting those School Poems; or The Fabulous Phlem; or even Eugene. Stories have a habit of creeping up on you whilst you are polishing the sink. You need to have three/four running in your head at one time. Cross fertilization. Trouble is family have a habit of interrupting. ' Can we go the pictures now, Daddy?' Slan! |
Written by Josie (2785 comments posted) 6th January 2008 |
| Phil, I haven't read much of what the others have said because I don't want my review to be coloured by theirs. For me, it was exactly the right length of a chapter, and for me, you painted the picture exactly right. If you had put in too much detail you would have detracted from the main story. I would say that you have done a good job, and I liked your style of connecting the present with the past for this is exactly what happens in life. It's sad that we can never fully forget unhappy situations. It seems as if the wound never heals but lies dormant awaiting another pinch of salt to drop onto it. A happy childhood is what makes the balanced person of the future I believe. |
Only registered users can rate and write comments.
Please login or register.