READING ROOM
Great Writing - Home
Read and review others' work
Articles on writing
Advice from the community
COMMUNITY
Talk to others in the forums
Events and Competitions
GW News
ABOUT GREAT WRITING
All About Us
Contact Us
WORK AWAITING REVIEW
GW IS...
Great Writing creative writing community is designed to prompt ideas and provide inspiration and motivation within aspiring and amateur authors. Whatever your topic; from love poetry to Doctor Who or Harry Potter fan fiction, Great Writing's online writing group is where you can make new friends and improve your creative writing.
WHO'S ONLINE
We have 1157 guests online and 11 members online
Non-Fiction
Eurocentrism
By Fledermaus
08 February 2008
A long, long time ago...

Our high-school history class had reached the "Age of Discovery". Being an annoying know-it-all, I raised my hand when the teacher began to tell us that the Portuguese and the Spanish were the ones who discovered the world.

" But sir, surely the Chinese and the Arabs made voyages of discovery before, had they not?"

His answer was a clear "no". He told me that the Chinese, Arabs, Indians etcetera had only travelled short distances and always stayed near the coast, while the great and glorious Europeans were the first to travel the oceans.

At the time I did not yet know the names of Zheng He and Ibn Battuta, and considered it wiser not to contradict him, for I couldn't bring forward any examples, but I still had my doubts.

Europe of the fifteenth century was a backward region. The mighty church of Rome, once the guardian of the Latin civilization, had turned into a corrupt and hollow organization. The plague wiped out entire cities and there were numerous conflicts between kings and noblemen. New weapons (copied from the Turks and Mongols) caused death and destruction and the standard of living was probably lower than in today's developing world.

Across the Mediterranean there was a more advanced world, with cities like Cairo and Baghdad, places of scholarship and relative religious and intellectual freedom. Muslim mathematicians had invented algebra, tried to count all stars in heaven and built mosques with golden domes.

Further east lay the wide lands of the Persians and the Indians, two ancient civilizations in two of the world's most fertile areas. They had suffered from Mongol invasions and civil wars and were divided into many kingdoms, but they had managed to maintain a wealth that would later amaze travellers like Vasco da Gama.

Beyond them lay the lands of the Khmer and Vietnamese, as well as the kingdom of Majapahit that stretched over a large part of the Indonesian archipelago.

And even further from Europe, there was the most powerful and advanced nation of its age. The Ming dynasty had not only restored the Great Wall and the Imperial Canal but also built the largest palace on earth. Moreover it employed one of the greatest voyagers of that age: Admiral Zheng He.

With ships that dwarfed any Western ship for centuries to come he travelled to Java, India and the Middle East, he visited Mecca and reached Mogadishu. He had seen all the lands mentioned above and some claim he may even have discovered Australia and that he was the inspiration for the legendary Sindbad the sailor.

Yet our history teacher had never heard of him. Perhaps because he had not bothered to discover Europe? 

Reviews

Written by Phil (6683 comments posted) 8th February 2008
You're probably quite right, Fledermaus. But it's probably also true that most nations teach history according to their own perspective. Enjoyed the read. To my shame (and European education) I'd never heard of Zheng He. 
 
Phil 

Written by Fledermaus (3248 comments posted) 8th February 2008
Hi Phil. 
I guess so indeed, but it's still strange that we don't hear about these people in Europe. Zheng He's fleet must have awed the people of the countries he visited, and he left his mark on Asia, as it's sometimes claimed that the first Chinese settlements in Malaysia and the spread of Islam to Indonesia are both the result of his voyages. 
 
Some people exaggerate it in the other direction though, as there seems to be an American writer who thinks Zheng He travelled nearly every sea there is, which seems a bit too much. The furthest he went was probably somewhere near to what's now Kenya. 
 
our narrow-mindedness
Written by mia_ms_kim (997 comments posted) 8th February 2008
I am originally from Asia, so I can appreciate what you are saying. However I've caught myself in similar state of narrow-mindedness over other cultures, even my own. I was shocked to pick up an ancient Korean book (a modern translation) by accident and read profound wisdom in it that I haven't heard in modern times. I was recently shocked by the deep wisdom of an Australian Aboriginal elder. I am privileged to live in a multicultural society, so I've experienced quite a few similar shocks over the years from people whom I least expected it from. Now I am learning that occupying any place other than the place of humility before all cultures, is a sheer folly. 
 
Mia 
 
ps. movable type printing press was invented in China and in Korea (metal version) long before Gutenberg.

Written by Abigail (24 comments posted) 9th February 2008
Unfortunately history is written by the victors. Much to our loss. 
 
Abigail
erm ........
Written by Bagheera (680 comments posted) 9th February 2008
:roll ......... I can remember being told that Scotland was discovered by the first Irishman who taught himself to swim ..... :grin :eek

Written by Fledermaus (3248 comments posted) 9th February 2008
Thanks Mia, Abigail and Bagheera. 
 
Mia, 
Yes, I only learned last month about the Korean influence on the printing press. The Chinese might have invented it, but the Koreans improved it so much that it became actually efficient. Never knew that before. 
 
Abigail, 
You're probably right. In this guy's case the victor was a new emperor that brought an end to all naval activities and moved the entire population 50km from the coast... 
 
Bagheera, 
Isn't that true then? 
 
 
 
 

   Only registered users can rate and write comments.
   Please login or register.

Powered by AkoComment 2.0!

 Previous item   Next item