|
By John_O
|
|
18 March 2008 |
One of the consequences of entering a writing competition....
No cats were harmed in the writing of this article.
Schrödinger’s Prize
In the field of quantum mechanics there is a famous thought experiment
that illustrates the very curious concept that the act of observation
actually changes the status of the item under observation.
Schrödinger’s cat is a hypothetical feline that is secured inside a
hypothetical box with just enough hypothetical poison to kill 50% of
any hypothetical cats exposed to it. So while the lid is closed we do
not know if our hypothetical moggy is alive or dead, it can be in both
states simultaneously, alive and dead. The act of opening the box and
looking inside decides the fate of the cat i.e. our observation changes
its status.
I have had something of the same paradox for the outcome of a short
story writing competition I entered. Two weeks ago the long shortlist,
as they called it, was published and my story was one of those that had
made it through to the finals. Today, St Patrick’s Day, they were due
to publish the list of winning entries; thus before I looked up the
website my entry could have made it into the final few or it could have
remained just on the long list. Until I looked it existed in both these
states, afterwards it would forever be just in the long list.
So I didn’t get any further but to get on the long list in the face of
a field of international entries does encourage me in my continuing
efforts and I am very gratified that my story was liked enough to make
the first cut. If you would like to judge it for yourself then nip
across to the Short Story section and read Old Dog Barking, and to
those of you suffering from Schrödinger’s Prize syndrome, good luck,
open the box!
|
Written by Fledermaus (3281 comments posted) 18th March 2008 | | What a brilliant thought! I had heard about this, but no-one ever managed to explain it and here you do it in a few lines. Of course I can only look at it as an outsider, not being a physicist, but I think it's a great concept. | Written by Phil (6713 comments posted) 18th March 2008 | Congratulations on the long listing. Still a measure of success. An interesting way to tell us too. Phil | On hypothetical cats Written by John_O (140 comments posted) 19th March 2008 | Hi FM and Phil we meet again on another page ! I must explain that I am not a physicist, though I am a working scientist, but I have had a long fascination with quantum mechanics and cosmology even if I don't have the maths to actually work on them. I do pride myself on being able to put across scientific concepts simply and I am gratified that I have achieved this for you. It struck me that my suituation vis a vis the result of the writing contest was very much like Schrodingers cat, by looking I changed the thing I was looking at; if I hadn't looked then I could have blissfully assumed that I had progressed whilst worrying that I hadn't progressed - Oh the Heisenberg of it ! Thank you Phil, it was certainly good news to me and spurs me on to try for another competiton. A bientot mes amis John_O | Written by Bottleblondesurfer (3351 comments posted) 19th March 2008 | I'm a bit phobic where anything scientific is concerned and so was quite surprised that I was half way throught this before I realised I was having a scientific theory explained to me, by then I was hooked. I liked your description and decided the same thing applies to lottery tickets. I sometimes buy one and then daren't check the numbers because until I do I could still have won. In that not knowing state I am a possible winner. Does that fit in with your concept?.....doesn't matter It got me thinking anyway. I may go and read the story, It's not science I hope! cheers Jane | Written by AmeliaWonderland (22 comments posted) 24th March 2008 | "Thus before I looked up the website my entry could have made it into the final few or it could have remained on the long list." Good philosophical observation! You see, if you really take the analogy at face value, then both your entry and you are the cat. Your story was both a winning entry and not a winning entry until the judge "opened the box" (that is, read your submission), and decided your fate. But, jokes aside, well done on making it into the long list!
| Tricky blighters scientists Written by John_O (140 comments posted) 25th March 2008 | Hi BBS and A (once more) its one of those wierd things, why do we write what we write? I wanted to put something about the Old Dog Barking on the site but just saying 'I got to the longlist' seemed such a bald and even boring way to do it. Then I reflected upon the two weeks between the first and second announcement and up it popped, the analogy with Schrodingers Cat. I must confess I also rather like showing that we of the scientific fraternity aren't all stereotypical white coat wearing unemotional blokes - you should see us at conferences, the passion is intense (so is the alcohol consumption). Yes the lottery ticket is the same, until you look up the numbers you are both winner and loser - at least in the quantum world! Old Dog is about as far from science or science fiction as you can get; it is an attempt to portray one man's quest to find his family, even just their dead bones, and thus find some form of peace. But there is a twist in the tale just to keep the tears at bay! Enjoy John_O |
Only registered users can rate and write comments. Please login or register. Powered by AkoComment 2.0! |