READING ROOM
Great Writing - Home
Read and review others' work
Articles on writing
Advice from the community
COMMUNITY
Talk to others in the forums
Events and Competitions
GW News
ABOUT GREAT WRITING
All About Us
Contact Us
WORK AWAITING REVIEW
GW IS...
Great Writing creative writing community is designed to prompt ideas and provide inspiration and motivation within aspiring and amateur authors. Whatever your topic; from love poetry to Doctor Who or Harry Potter fan fiction, Great Writing's online writing group is where you can make new friends and improve your creative writing.
WHO'S ONLINE
We have 1206 guests online and 5 members online
Poetry
Suicide
By mr_soul
09 April 2008
There is another world, there is a better world. Well, there must be..........

P.S. Only a "poem", not anything else incase anyone was wondering, its not a suicide note or anything lol. Just to make that clear lol.

Look down and what do you see? Black and death and murky sea

Of what was and what is me,

And what they know is all in between.

I reach out like a desperate fool, humiliated and seldom seen

I lived my life like an extra’s movie scene, and in vice

Was my only refuge.

Advice was cursed and often crooked by people wicked,

And paranoid they spoke of me but I know their truth

And it does not belong to me.

Flags carried to mark a torch of burning desire not met with reality

How can they say I have no rights?

Love is not owned by mass but they have made it so,

And in dying they have made their mark of destroying

All that is and all that could be of me.

Amongst grass and smokes and alcohol

That failed to break or prevent my fall and contrived to spoil

The times that should have served my pain.

The rain and thunder, lightening striking, makes me wonder

About life’s trials as all the while my soul does break

And follows my heart down the river.

My spine does shiver as my mind quivers at older memories

Unlocked in past and present games that blame some unknown face

The place that holds every tear and every sigh

In every dream I shall lie down and die

So goodbye, goodbye, goodbye……

Reviews

Written by Phil (6683 comments posted) 9th April 2008
I think you need to reconsider this one a little. For me, it rambles and has no focus. There are some odd constructions - and the habit of putting 'does' in front of a verb makes for awkward reading - eg/ does break, does shiver. I think suicide is a very hard thing to write about without falling into the usual traps of glamorising it with teenage angst that gives it a slightly heroic glow. I'm glad you seem to have avoided that at least. Suicide is just a tragic waste. 
 
Phil

Written by Phil (6683 comments posted) 9th April 2008
Sorry, meant to add: do you read your work loud? I ask because the rhythms here are very disjointed. With a few minor alterations it could flow better: 
 
Look down and what do you see?  
Black and death and murky sea 
Of what once was and what is me, 
And what they know that's in between.  
 
Far from perfect - but a little more cadence. Feel free to tell me I'm talking rot -I'm no poet (just enjoy it) and me giving poetic advice is like Stan Collymore giving marriage counselling. Perhaps a poet will give you some better advice. 
 
Keep writing 
 
Phil

Written by mr_soul (126 comments posted) 9th April 2008
Thanks Phil. And don't put yourself down, you are probably one of the best reviewers on this site. You are always honest and encouraging, which are both important, and your advice is invaluable. You've always given your time to me and nomatter how critical you've been, I've always respected and appreciated your reviews. I can't imagine GW without you. 
On to this "poem" it was actually inspired by REM's "E-bow the letter", with a touch of The Smiths at the end lol. The structure (or lack of it) was deliberate to a certain extent, I was trying to convey the mindset of someone who was suicidal. Whether I achieved that or not is a different matter. 
I try to read aloud my work but I admit I don't always. I admit when you say something aloud, you get a whole new perspective of the poem. So this might seem a bit disjointed and rambling. I'll try and improve it, see what I can do with it. 
Thanks Phil

Written by Merioneth (79 comments posted) 18th April 2008
Suicide is a difficult subject to tackle in poetry and in prose. There is a fine line between powerful and effective emotional sentiment and, well, whining. The good news and the bad news is that I don't think you've achieved either here. Reformatting the poem might help a bit. I liked Phil's suggestion. It's still your words, just written in a way that flows a bit more. 
 
There is a very moving song about suicide at the end of The Mountain Goat's album Get Lonely. John Darnielle is a singer/songwriter of the highest calibur and he is the main reason I'm getting into poetry. The song is called "In Corrolla" and you can find the lyrics here
 
Admittedly the lyrics are a heck of a lot more moving when you hear them actually sung. I highly reccommend the whole album to anyone who loves poetry.

   Only registered users can rate and write comments.
   Please login or register.

Powered by AkoComment 2.0!

 Previous item   Next item