READING ROOM
Great Writing - Home
Read and review others' work
Articles on writing
Advice from the community
COMMUNITY
Talk to others in the forums
Events and Competitions
GW News
ABOUT GREAT WRITING
All About Us
Contact Us
WORK AWAITING REVIEW
GW IS...
Great Writing creative writing community is designed to prompt ideas and provide inspiration and motivation within aspiring and amateur authors. Whatever your topic; from love poetry to Doctor Who or Harry Potter fan fiction, Great Writing's online writing group is where you can make new friends and improve your creative writing.
WHO'S ONLINE
We have 1544 guests online and 4 members online
Shorts
Nocturne
By ainsel
22 April 2008
I've made a small amendment in the light of Fellpony's review.

Playing Chopin; too early in the evening, perhaps.  Ros always thought that Chopin was rather a candlelight-and-moonlight composer, and the piece was a Nocturne.  But it got dark early at this time of year, so she could pretend.  

It was one of the works in three parts, almost palindromic in fact.  The first section was andante cantabile; not really gentle, Chopin never was, but with an underlying serenity of mood. The middle section, dark and passionate, was repeated before returning to the original theme, which now seemed a little more wistful, but sweeter for the storm that preceded it.  It was comforting, when Ros was feeling enclosed.

She was in that frame of mind in which the hesitations and wrong notes didn't seem to matter.  In her imagination the piece sounded just as it was meant to, and as it might have if she had been able to keep going to lessons.  But she had to be strict with herself.  Details, individual phrases, single notes even, finger by finger; that was what made a performance work.

Eric was in the shed, working on a motor; inboard or outboard, Ros had no idea.  She could hear a distant thud-thud-thud; she knew that rhythm, though she couldn't have named the piece of music.  Eric had a limited range of CDs out there, which he played in strict rotation, but only the bass carried into the house.  He would sometimes spend half the night out there, if he had an unfinished job.  It wasn't often, not as often as Ros would have liked.  He rarely finished a repair job on schedule, but he didn't pick up much work either.

Tonight, Ros thought, it was probably just an excuse.  They were arguing more now than they ever had.  For once Ros had refused, when Eric had decided they would sell the house and move into the old caravan behind his work shed.  She had given up almost everything else so that extra money could be fed to the business, which like a greedy and undisciplined infant swallowed every morsel and gave nothing back.  Eric's ambition was not paired with the competence needed to create the boat-building empire of his dreams. But the house, small and ill-maintained as it was,  belonged to Ros, and couldn't be sold until he had worn her down.

So Eric was in the shed, supposed to be working on a motor.  In fact, Ros suspected, he would be studying boating magazines, trying to absorb the principles of design, drinking light beer and munching those strange wasabi-flavoured fried peas that were supposed to be safe for peanut allergies.

Ros went back to the middle section, playing fortissimo to try to drown out other noises, and concentrating on her fingering.  The bass notes were a little more out of tune than usual, probably responding to the change in the season.  If all went well, perhaps she could finally get the instrument tuned.  In the meantime she must focus on the gymnastics, on the correct sequence of finger to key, and let the disharmonies drift past, till she got past the difficult part.

He will get rid of the piano.  The thought hung in the air like smoke from a fire, not yet close but threatening.  It had not been said, but there was no room for it at the new place.  Probably it would not be sold - too old and worn out - but would just be abandoned.  She couldn't allow that, but there was no point in discussing it with Eric.  When this new idea had come to her, she had rejected it, but it had lingered.  And it was such an easy solution, if only she did everything exactly right.

She had drifted into the final section, almost without realising it.  It was quiet outside now; the thud of the bass had stopped.  Presently, when enough time had passed to become anxious, she would go out to check on him.  She must ensure that the tin of wasabi peas contained no more peanuts, and she would put the epinephrine syringe back into the drawer where he kept it.  The details made the performance.  For now, everything was as it should be; she had reached the restful part, and it was night at last.

Reviews
Developing of mood
Written by patterjack (1194 comments posted) 22nd April 2008
The way the mood develops throughout this piece is excellent as is the implicit characterisation . Some good contrasts there and a consistency of theme. 
 
Ending -- very neat and understated . 
 
patterjack 
 

Written by mia_ms_kim (1019 comments posted) 22nd April 2008
This piece feels very scary because of the profound understatement. I can almost see the woman’s silent desperation and resolution in the piano piece she concentrates on. Her playing the piano seems a kind of escape, perhaps a way to drown out the sound of the real discord in her life, and later as readers understand, a way for her to fill the time and fill the silence as she waits.  
 
“Nocturne” seems to be the prelude as well as the summation of what is taking place even as she plays it. 
 
Somehow I totally understand the woman, and why she does what she does. Strangely I don’t question her, why didn’t she just leave him? Wasn’t there another way? Somehow through the piano piece and the sparse outline of their relationship that question is answered. There was no other way for her. However, it is chilling for the methodical precision with which she executes her plan – the trained precision with which she knows to play the piano piece. 
 
Very effective. I wonder if this can be turned into a drama script? 
 
Mia :)

Written by fellpony (1616 comments posted) 23rd April 2008
There were some parts where I had to read several times to catch the implications. The idea of "the new place" came as a bit of a jolt, for instance; because Ros had already refused to sell up the present house. However, those were more than compensated by the calm, calculating smoothness of the past paragraph, which was very satisfying.
Many thanks
Written by ainsel (48 comments posted) 23rd April 2008
patterjack - for your encouragement, as always. 
 
Mia - your comments are also very encouraging. It's always a bit of a joy to have sparked an emotional response :) I had a sense of why she didn't find another way out, but I didn't feel that the story would be improved by a lot of exposition, so your acceptance of this is greatly appreciated!  
 
Fellpony - I see what you mean. A bit of a rewrite there seems in order; my gut feeling is that, one way or another, Eric would wear Ros down and she would give in and sell. I should probably have made that clear in the text. Many thanks for bringing it to my attention - I'll give some thought to possible amendments.
Nice
Written by MyCatIsMyIdol (3 comments posted) 23rd April 2008
You get a real sense of the characters from this and as Mia said, you can understand why she did it . The ending is very effective and I like how it ties in with the previous paragraphs. :grin  
MyCatIsMyIdol
Written by ainsel (48 comments posted) 24th April 2008
...may I call you Cat? it's shorter to type. 
 
Thank you for your review - very much appreciated.

Written by TwistedTales (548 comments posted) 24th April 2008
I found your piece similar to Andrew Lynch's stories - similar in mood and buildup. You sort of linger on the verge of action, before giving it to the reader. I love the way the Piano piece was used as a background to what the protagonist was about to do.  
I don't know but i missed the hint - when you said, the wasabi nuts are good for peanut allergies, I should've caught it, but I was so into what was going to happen, it seemed like a more minor detail. One can almost sense the piece playing with all its passion and gusto, while all along the woman is planning her move.  
 
All in all - A satisfying read indeed 
 
Regards, 
TT
TwistedTales
Written by ainsel (48 comments posted) 25th April 2008
I'm not familiar with Andrew Lynch, but I will look into his work. I did hold back a bit on the wasabi peas - I wanted the information there but didn't want to labour the point. I'm glad it worked. Thanks for the feedback.

Written by Josie (2785 comments posted) 29th May 2008
I'm way down on the list of the many excellent reviews that you have received Ainsel. You have done very well indeed, drawing in the facts about the situation bit by bit whilst the music plays. Bit by bit we see not only that the characters are drifting apart, but the inner loneliness felt by the pianist. It is so sad when this happens. I find it hard also to understand why someone has to take another person's life when all they need is to go their own way in life. It is such a dreadful thing to take someone's life, especially someone whom you have loved. Other than my few remarks, I go along with all that has been said before. Well done, and well written.

   Only registered users can rate and write comments.
   Please login or register.

Powered by AkoComment 2.0!

 Previous item   Next item