Great Writing - Home > Non-Fiction > National Singles Day
READING ROOM
Great Writing - Home
Read and review others' work
Articles on writing
Advice from the community
COMMUNITY
Talk to others in the forums
Events and Competitions
GW News
ABOUT GREAT WRITING
All About Us
Contact Us
WORK AWAITING REVIEW
GW IS...
Great Writing creative writing community is designed to prompt ideas and provide inspiration and motivation within aspiring and amateur authors. Whatever your topic; from love poetry to Doctor Who or Harry Potter fan fiction, Great Writing's online writing group is where you can make new friends and improve your creative writing.
WHO'S ONLINE
We have 1634 guests online and 9 members online
Non-Fiction
National Singles Day
By johniebg
02 May 2008
It has been a while. But had to drag myself away from the great work of my lifetime that nobody will read, for this.

Historically I have struggled - at grammar that is. Until 2006. But then I decided nobody was going to publish a book written by somebody that didn't know their plurals from possessives, so I studied.

Fortunately as I began my study endeavors I was sitting next to the prophet during work hours. The prophet being a fountain of all knowledge. Nobody knows quite how he came by this knowledge because he seems to spend all his time sat at a desk - either at work or in the pub. But history has repeatedly shown he does have a grasp on many aspects of life and importantly for this conversation - grammar.

As such the foundations for my current understanding of grammar were laid one slow afternoon at work during the later months of 2006. During which the prophet kindly detailed the occasions when apostrophes should be applied to the written word. I subsequently went on to read several books on the subject as well.

It should also be noted at this point that I do not ordinarily watch weeknight TV. But the good lady priddeesh has a love for all things trash, especially when she has a OU essay deadline looming. Which is partly how I came to be watching the apprentice last night. There are a whole bunch of other complicated reasons which I will not bore you with.

The episode I watched was number six of the current season, in which the two teams were tasked with coming up with an idea for a new greetings card in an already saturated market. The reason I am writing this blog is because one of the teams came upon the idea of a 'national singles day'. And therein lay the problem.

During the task the team spent almost four hours trying to work out whether there should be an apostrophe in or around or after the word: singles. Which has subsequently sparked a fairly interesting debate, in fairly small circles. To the point that in the subsequent show hosted by Adrian Chiles 'The apprentice: You're fired.' They had the head of buying for Clinton Cards state that the apostrophe must go before the closing 's' I.e. single's

So here we come to the crux of this post - the application of my sum knowledge regarding the need for an apostrophe: you don't need one. Here is why:

Singles is plural. It is not possessive. It is talking about a collection of single people: plural. You could argue that the statement is possessive because it is referring to a day for singles and therefore possessed by them. But that is stretching the point to levels of stupidity for my mind. One which now seems to be debated by several Universities renowned for their standing in the field of English language. Who do not seem to agree with each other. Even the Editorial staff at the 'Times' struggled!

For me the rule of thumb is: if the path is not obvious and you have conflicting rules keep it simple. Here I don't see any fine line. It's a bunch of single people. It's a bloody plural.

I wonder whether I will hear from the prophet.

PS What a plonker Kevin was. And how shocking to see the white alpha males gang up on the last Asian girl: Sara Dhada, with no substantive evidence for their arguements. They didn't even work with her on that task. She will go because she doesn't stand up for herself but I think not before Lee and Alex, hopefully.

Reviews

Written by Phil (6393 comments posted) 2nd May 2008
Good to see you back, Johnie. Afraid I disagree, though. Yes, a plural, but also possessive - hence: Singles' Day. I reckon Bagheera's the one to adjudicate. There are probably odd rules that govern proper nouns. 
 
Phil

Written by johniebg (538 comments posted) 4th May 2008
I think the problem with the line is that you can read it in several ways; 
 
'A singles day' in which there would be debate on whether to place the apostrophe before or after the possesive 's'. This is the debate causing most of the issues it appears. 
 
'A day celebrating singles' in which there would be no apostrophe. 
 
The later was how I read the line but that is probably based entirely on the fact it is the path of least resistance.
Grammar
Written by patterjack (1067 comments posted) 4th May 2008
Under the later grammatical interpretations , you perhaps might prefer to think that singles is used as a qualifier that is as ( an adjective ) . 
 
Then , since singular / plural agreement is more approprriate to inflected languages rather than to English ........ 
 
Saves some troublesome headscratching  
 
patterjack

Written by Fledermaus (3159 comments posted) 4th May 2008
Haha, such a long piece about that subject. You're correct I think. At first I was thinking it should be "national singles' day", but indeed that'd be wrong, since it would also be "national pizza day" or "national teddy-bear day".

Written by fellpony (1507 comments posted) 5th May 2008
I tend to agree with Johnnie - if you wrote "National Doubles Day" (eg for tennisophiles) it would be clear as crystal that no apostrophe was needed.
Hi Johnnie
Written by jean.day (2196 comments posted) 7th May 2008
I'm pleased to see you writing again - and as usual, it was fun to read. I like the idea of keeping things simple and Patterjack's calling it an adjective seems to fit the bill. 
 
Good luck with your "great work of your lifetime."

Written by Bottleblondesurfer (3138 comments posted) 8th May 2008
Interesting argument. I can' t bring myself to watch that programme but the point the arose from it is worth the discussion. Perhaps you should write a grammar book in the same quirky style. I have three for reference and they make for very dull reading, useful but deadly dull. I think your approach to the subject would get people thinking. 
cheers 
jane
P.S
Written by Bottleblondesurfer (3138 comments posted) 8th May 2008
With reference to your " great work of your lifetime" I can understand your reluctance to finish it.
Great minds think alike!
Written by Clifftown (619 comments posted) 1st June 2008
As it were. I watched that episode and was practically screaming at the screen "you don't need an apostrophe for God's sake!" And I was amazed at how many people seemed to struggle with the whole thing. 
 
(As for 'The Apprentice', I just hope to God it isn't Alex - what a snake...)

   Only registered users can rate and write comments.
   Please login or register.

Powered by AkoComment 2.0!

 Previous item   Next item