This my first attempt at an 'adult' short story.
I could waffle on about the whys and the wherefores . . .
But I won't!
Comments really appreciated!
Cheers!
John X
aka Katanga aka Tolstoy
Love’s Reckoning
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Dunkirk
France
May 10 1940
My Dearest Heart,
Thank you, thank you, thank you for your lovely long letter. I keep it in the top left pocket of my battle jacket – I take it out and read it again and again, whenever we get some minutes’ peace from the ghastly day-and-night shelling.
But I don’t want you to think about that.
I’m not so good at writing, as you know and I hope you understand, so this will be shorter.
I can’t tell you exactly where I am – the censor, Jim (a good chap) wouldn’t allow it. Just that I wish I was with you, in our little orchard back home.
Strangely, my Darling, I'm glad that you're not with me - it's a hell-hole!
By the way, how are the russet apples doing? Remember how we picked up all the windfalls before I left? The cider was terrible! Oh, Edi . . .
The boys have been great – do you know, they ask me about you and how you are, when I know they have their own sweethearts to worry about.
Mind you, theirs can’t be anything like you, because you’re an Angel - and don’t forget it!
Harris, bless him, says we’re going to push south tomorrow, if tomorrow ever comes . . .
To be honest, Edi, I’ve had enough of this winter – I know it’s spring now, and birds are supposed to be singing, but it’s beginning to affect everyone’s spirits . . .
I must stop now, my Darling – it’s my turn for first-watch duties and I don’t want to let the lads down.
Just a final thought, my Love, and I know you might think I’m being silly . . .
Remember the song we danced to once, in the officers’ mess in Cholesbury?
“Don’t sit under the apple tree with anyone else but me, anyone else but me, anyone else but me.”
Please don’t, Edi! I worry about you and us, that’s all.
So much endless love,
Yours for always and forever,
Ted
XXX oxo
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Edith held Edward’s letter up to the light, a 40-watt naked bulb.
She could still see light through the creases . . .
Did it need any more repairs? It was a little yellower, and more brittle – even the sellotape was beginning to yellow and peel.
She switched on the television to catch the end of the news, not that she cared much.
And tonight’s summary – an eighteen-year-old girl has gone missing after a reported bombing in Iraq, in which her fiancé is said to have been amongst the casualties.
Edith picked up her stick and gripped it, preparing for the journey to bed and to some sort of sleep.
Anyone with information regarding her disappearance on Friday May 11th is asked to contact their local police station immediately. For a full update, please tune in tomorrow at 5.00 a.m..
Goodnight from me and all of us here on the news team for London South-East.
Edith was half-way across the living room, dancing with Ted in a poppy field in France, trampling on the flowers in Love’s careless abandon.
She kissed his letter for the ten thousandth time.
“Goodnight, my Love.”
“Goodnight!” she said to the flickering screen, not wishing to appear rude.
|
Written by Phil (6645 comments posted) 30th May 2008 |
Hi John. There's always something poignant about stuff like this - there's a whole familiar history to tap into that gives the piece immediate relevance - even for someone of my tender years (41) I suppose younger generations have less awareness of WWII - but ours was a generation whose parents and grandparents lived through it. I liked this. It's gentle and tender. I think in places you've pushed the boat a little too far. I can see why you want to contrast then and now (via the news) but I'm not sure this needs anything quite so obvious. It's a gentle piece and perhaps the themes should be gentle (and gently put) with it. The beginning of the second part worked really well - I was looking at the letter along with her. And there you had a little more subtlety/gentleness. Clear Ted didn't make it back from France - but you didn't tell us. That suited the feel of the piece really well. I liked this very much. It captures a time and two characters well. It also explores emotions very well. The 'don't sit under the apple tree,' was a super touch. I reckon there's more here if you're willing to work it. Wait what others say. I may be off the mark. Touched - and not in a carpet chewing way! Phil |
Hot off the mark! Written by Katanga (1163 comments posted) 30th May 2008 |
Cripes Phil! Thank you so much! No sooner had I blown my nose to rid myself of sentimentalism (?), than you come on the blower with a stonking review . . . I am tearfully returning to the poetry section, where I feel I humbly belong, but if I get any more reviews as thoughtful and as positive as yours, I shall resume the novel I'm half-way through about my penis . . . 'nuff said for now! Cheers! Katie Jay X |
Written by Phil (6645 comments posted) 30th May 2008 |
| Big one is it? |
Short . . . Written by Katanga (1163 comments posted) 30th May 2008 |
. . . and sadly, thin. But I'm hoping to beef him up! Had we but space and time, my love . . . Ho! Well, you know! K T J |
Written by Lizzy (783 comments posted) 31st May 2008 |
Hi John This was a nice simple tale with lots of depth. I agree with Phil about the comparison with Iraq, it works on its own without that. I liked the way it began with the letter and the way it returned to it, old and frail like Edi. It does stand on its own but could easily be extended into a longer piece Lizzy
|
Written by Nick (134 comments posted) 31st May 2008 |
Hi John,
|
Written by Nick (134 comments posted) 31st May 2008 |
Mmmm - A slip of the fingers there - sorry. Anyway - I liked the story a lot. Would be interested to read more about the woman's life after the death of her loved one. Did she live a full life with someone else after but always with memories of him. or did she live the rest of her life alone? good stuff. Nick |
Written by Bottleblondesurfer (3298 comments posted) 31st May 2008 |
I thougth this was very senitively written.. It was marked as much by what was left out as what was written, leaving the reader to fill in the blanks That sort of judgement can't be learnt and I think you have it. I liked the understed way you wrote about the old lady. It was touching. I did feel the stuff about Iraq was a bit of an unecessary intrusion. I think I know what you wanted to say but it wasn't needed. We got the message. Instead a little more backstory would have been perfect cheers jane |
Written by Brett (731 comments posted) 31st May 2008 |
I think you've found your forte, Tolstoy. I found this very moving, easy to read, and leaving the reader wanting to know the characters more. Cheers |
Written by NathanRoberts (277 comments posted) 2nd June 2008 |
Hi John, I don't usually venture over to these parts (a haiku is my idea of short), but I enjoyed this wander down someone's memory lane. I felt the tone was well handled especially in the letter and some simple but effective observation (period detail, the yellowing paper). I understand other reviewers' comments on the news interludes, but it seems to need something at that point, a contrast with Edward's language and contemporary tone, maybe? It depends what you want the subtext to be. As it stands, is it a case of 'life moves on, things change and yet nothing changes...war, suffering, loss'? The final line 'not wishing to appear rude' is good, and makes me feel the subtext could be the change in manners, language, morality which could be subtly developed within the second section. Oh, and what's come over you? a novel?...your muse is obviously on the rise, you must have balls to tackle that subject, are you aiming for a hard or softback release.....and so on. Cheers, Rob.
|
Written by woody44 (774 comments posted) 3rd June 2008 |
I loved the feel of this story, although I thought the sentiments expressed and the landscape descriptions veered more towards the trenches and WW1. I loved the description of the yellowing, creased letter, an excellent example of `showing not telling`. As you revealed more about Edith, I got the impression that she had remained loyal to Ted`s memory and had stayed a widow. The TV news shows us that nothing has changed with regards to man`s inhumanity to man. I`m sure the piece could be extended but as a snapshot in time it stands as a nicely written piece of flash fiction. Well done Roger |
Thanks All! Written by Katanga (1163 comments posted) 3rd June 2008 |
Thank you Phil, Lizzy, Nick, Jane, Brett, Rob and Woody for your very thoughtful and encouraing reviews above. I agree with those of you who fell that the Iraq news bulletin is an unnecessarily clumsy, obvious intrusion. I wanted to have Edith say goodnight to the newsreader and wasn't sure how to link it up. I'll try and think of a more subtle news item! Anyway, you have all motivated me greatly to try more prose. I'm having a real struggle with a novel of which I've only completed 15,000 words. A mammoth, but enjoyable, task lies ahead and you have given me more faith and determination to continue to the eventual end. Cheers! John X |
Only registered users can rate and write comments.
Please login or register.