|
Written by Canadian_Bacon (114 comments posted) 12th June 2008 |
Hm. Well if there IS a line, you probably overshot it by a mile. |
Written by Phil (6845 comments posted) 12th June 2008 |
Hmm. A topic that many avoid - for obvious reasons. In some ways, equally difficult to read and comment on. I suppose this shows the delusions a paedophile may have. I say 'may' - I don't know. We're often told that they see what they do as normal - but in modern society, with all the publicity - it may feel normal, but they must know it isn't accepted as so. That begs the question who the narrator is addressing - a fellow paedophile - or just Joe Public? It's simply written - and although there is a slightly uncomfortable feel throughout and one or two hints, the end comes as a chilling and sickening surprise. I guess I should have suspected more from your intro. Its simplicity and coldness lends it a little more stark horror. I'm not sure what to think about this. I don't think there are any taboo subjects to write about - and you gave a warning. I do think it's important how the subject is treated. I'm still considering that one. Brave for tackling it. I'd be interested in what response you hoped your piece would illicit. Feeling uncomfortable. I think because there are parts of this that glory in the whole thing. Told in the first person, there can be no balance. That's not a comment on you BTW, just the writing and the position it leaves the reader. We're so used to being given implicit (or even explicit) moral guidance. Here we have a highly passionate subject and a totally dispassionate telling. On balance - I think my reaction is that it is a good stab at something very difficult. That doesn't stop me doubting though. Proves the power of the whole issue. Phil |
Written by TwistedTales (548 comments posted) 12th June 2008 |
Michel Foucault once spoke about Sexual morality and the Law. He along with other French intellectuals had signed a petition addressed to the Parliament, defending the decriminalization of all consented relations between adults and minors below the age of fifteen (the age of consent in France at that time). He spoke about the emerging supervision of sexuality and the increasing social control on the behavior of an individual. Well, what he was trying to say, I guess was that until it is an actual rape (without consent), nobody should judge or categorize that person as a criminal. Coming to your story - It is chilling. We've had different takes on the same subject by different authors, including a recent one by Leo. I liked it. I didn't predict the end. So one goal achieved. There are certain things I would like to point out though - suns - sun's Karma Sutra - kamasutra conversion - conversation You mention about the scratches on the back twice - that put me off slightly. Regards, TT |
Written by Becca2010 (24 comments posted) 12th June 2008 |
| I had to read this twice! I loved how it was like reading two different stories. The first, a tragic lost love (before the end of course) then the second gives you a sickening feeling at the idea of anyone doing that to another person. Very interesting piece. |
Written by Nick (163 comments posted) 12th June 2008 |
Thanks for the comments. CB - You probably right - I did overshoot the line by a mile!! Phil - I saw a documentary last year where they interviewed this old man and he was talking about a lost love - I missed the start and didn't realise he was talking about a little girl. it freaked me out a little and I ended up writing this. Also I decided to post it for several reason. The first and main one was to see if people thought there was a line that you don't cross in writing and the second was to see if I could get from the reader the feeling I got when watching said documentary. TT - thanks for pointing out some of the spelling errors - there now fixed. Becca - Your comments was exactly what I was going for - first reading seems like a nice love story but second time through it is all very sickening. Thanks again folks. Nick |
Written by DaleGorder (46 comments posted) 13th June 2008 |
hahaha... I think you did a pretty decent job overall. I love the surprise ending! Very nice touch. When I read how you cut her throat I was beginning to feel a bit let down with what I thought may be a cliche ending. But then you snuck' up on me and saved the day! lol I think if I were to attempt an improvement. It would be to write the main body with even more innocence and love. That way your end will be even more intense. Over the top? Of course, but that's what makes writers stand out.  |
Written by woody44 (777 comments posted) 13th June 2008 |
Very difficult subject to write about, particularly if you are going for the overt rather than the implied approach. My worry is that if too much is written about this does one become desensitised to the actual act. Given the subject matter, probably not, but I still perhaps favour the implied approach. I suppose one could argue that nothing should be taboo when it comes to creative writing but with me the jury is still out on this one. Having said that, your story was very well told TT, despite what some would see as an uncomfortable read. A brave bit of writing, which I`m sure will invoke many other comments. happy writing Roger |
Written by woody44 (777 comments posted) 13th June 2008 |
Sorry Nick! Just been reading a piece by TT and I`m afraid it overlapped. As always I blame it on the menopause! Roger |
Written by Nick (163 comments posted) 14th June 2008 |
Dale/Roger - Thanks for the comments. I'm still not sure what i think of this short. I keep thinking about deleting it as I think I've gone to far but then it's interesting to hear others people's views on boundaries etc. I'm off to sunny Spain in a few hours, so I'll leave it up until I get back at least - see if I get anymore comments. Thanks again Nick |
Oh my... Written by ReflectingGod (29 comments posted) 14th September 2008 |
...I was like 'awww...Dr.Jekyll' Then... 'Ahhha Mister fucking Hyde!!!' That was such a change from one to the other that I am still over- whelmed by the last line. But if you read it for a second time, there is so many hints to what it truly was. You never cease to amaze me, Nick. |
Written by Nick (163 comments posted) 18th September 2008 |
RG - Thanks for the kind review, glad you liked it. Nick |
Only registered users can rate and write comments.
Please login or register.