Great Writing - Home > Poetry > Is That You?
READING ROOM
Great Writing - Home
Read and review others' work
Articles on writing
Advice from the community
COMMUNITY
Talk to others in the forums
Events and Competitions
GW News
ABOUT GREAT WRITING
All About Us
Contact Us
WORK AWAITING REVIEW
GW IS...
Great Writing creative writing community is designed to prompt ideas and provide inspiration and motivation within aspiring and amateur authors. Whatever your topic; from love poetry to Doctor Who or Harry Potter fan fiction, Great Writing's online writing group is where you can make new friends and improve your creative writing.
WHO'S ONLINE
We have 1236 guests online and 1 member online
Poetry
Is That You?
By Sir_Nigel
20 June 2008
(this is about a lady who posted her poems and other writings on an internet site. But I was attracted firstly by the accompanying picture….)

I sometimes wonder wryly
if that’s someone else entirely
And you’re really sad and lonely,
devoid of friends and homely.
I picture a simple pudding face
gazing pensively into space
on a lonely, loveless night,
striving to get the verse right.


And it gives your life some meaning,
more so than compulsive cleaning
And taking time to compose and think
keeps you from an over-reliance on drink.
Although pouring out your soul
can take its toll,
many find it fulfilling.
Giving respite from say….a life of loitering in doorways, waylaying passing sailors and doing it in a dark alley for a shilling.
Not that I’m suggesting that’s you.
(Though there’s nothing wrong with that if you do)
I’m just saying people have lived through much worse
and still found the time to write verse.


Because somehow it’s difficult to reconcile
your writing with that self-possessed profile.

But if it’s not the case
that you chose a much prettier face.

And it’s absolutely true
that the picture of the slim and attractive young woman caught in a moment of quiet reflection looking wistfully into the middle distance and giving the impression that she has a rich and rewarding life and lovers, you posted
is really you.


And
you’re not
homely or lonely
or dumpy or lumpy.
(and certainly not Bashful or Dopey or Grumpy).
Writing poignant poetry
to hide your pain
because you think you’re plain 
and your life is like an abandoned cardboard box going soggy in the rain.


Then I’ll be happy that you’re really you
And not that picture of sorrow I drew -
pretending she’s somebody new.
For you look like a girl I once knew.
Though you still could be miserable it’s true -
you don’t have to be plump to be blue.
And there’s certainly more than a few
who are plain, fat and jovial too
and it’s tricky to tell who is who.


By these words you will probably construe
that I haven’t really thought this thing through.


Reviews

Written by lovelysarah1984 (81 comments posted) 20th June 2008
Lol. Sounds all too familiar although I think it is your name, Nigel, that brings this home to me. Back to the poem. It started out really well and I ws going to suggest that you change verse to verses etc but I think it's the layout of the poem that is the problem here. Maybe you want it set out like this but my advice would be to get rid og the double spacing between lines and put them into couplets of four lined stanzas. it would make it easier to read the longer lines. 
 
Hope this helps and you can tell me if you think I'm talking complete rubbish! 
 
sarahxxx

Written by Sir_Nigel (37 comments posted) 20th June 2008
Lovely Sarah, 
This site seems to have a mind of its own with regards to layout but after some fannying about the poem now looks like I want it to look. 
 
thank you
Abandoned?
Written by Katanga (1179 comments posted) 20th June 2008
I really like this, particularly the 'cardboard box' image! 
 
But is the word 'abandoned' necessary? Aren't boxes left in the rain almost by definition abandoned? 
 
I think it wold have more 'punch' and flow better rhythmically as: 
 
'Your life is like a cardboard box 
going soggy in the rain.' 
 
(or even 'gone soggy'?) 
 
Sorry to quibble - much enjoyed! 
 
As I remmeber enjoying your 'Starling' piece so much . . . 
 
Cheers! 
 
John 
 

Written by Sir_Nigel (37 comments posted) 20th June 2008
I think it has more punch with ‘abandoned’. Not all cardboard boxes left in the rain have been abandoned - some may still be serving a useful function yet simply mislaid. Or left outside in the mistaken belief that they are sturdier than they really are and the weather forecast is favourable in any case.  
 
thanks

Written by lovelysarah1984 (81 comments posted) 20th June 2008
That reads much better! I like this piece a lot Nigel and sorry about the typing errors in my reviews!

Written by Veronica_Milvus (603 comments posted) 20th June 2008
Lovely. I liked the anarchic format. Especially the line about doing it in a dark alley for a shilling. 
 
I wonder about all of us here on GW. Would we be more glamorous and alluring, or less, if we had our photos on display?

Written by Phil (6681 comments posted) 20th June 2008
Veronica - I don't think for a moment that I come across as glamorous, and a photo would confirm it. 
 
Enjoyed this - as I always do with your stuff. It may be a little rough around the edges (sorry) but it carries a humorous and bitter-sweet tone. 
 
Good stuff 
 
Phil

Written by mia_ms_kim (993 comments posted) 21st June 2008
What an interesting and entertaining muse. I found it funny, a little sad perhaps, and thought-provoking. The cyber era in which we live, I suppose, brings up such subject matters. I wonder if one can create a fictional persona and keep it up for too long on a writing site. 
 
I belong to romance writers' online group with many published writers in their midst. I got a shock when I found out what many of them looked like! Romance writers, I thought, would look 'romantic'. They didn't. A few turned out to be men using female names or gender-neutral pen names! 
 
Mia :eek

Written by Josie (2772 comments posted) 22nd June 2008
You can NEVER tell a book by its cover - that is what I found. It's the inner person that counts most in life, and if you look at someone and conjure up a picture of their life from that, you can be one hundred per cent sure you will be completely wrong. Many older people are more youthful than young people I have found quite often, but not always of course. They are certainly often happier.

Written by Sir_Nigel (37 comments posted) 23rd June 2008
Thanks for your comments. Special thanks to lovely Sarah who I know is really a 32 stone bloke who never leaves his trailer in Arkansas. Mia_ms_kim (he’s on Death Row and has Kill all Unbelievers tattooed across his back) Veronica_Milvus - a one-armed Latvian arms dealer’s moll on the run form the Russian mafia and currently holed up and going insane in an isolated farmhouse near Diss, Norfolk. Josie (Frank during the week). And Phil, who is Phil.

   Only registered users can rate and write comments.
   Please login or register.

Powered by AkoComment 2.0!

 Previous item   Next item