Great Writing - Home > Short S. > Mistaken Identity
READING ROOM
Great Writing - Home
Read and review others' work
Articles on writing
Advice from the community
COMMUNITY
Talk to others in the forums
Events and Competitions
GW News
ABOUT GREAT WRITING
All About Us
Contact Us
WORK AWAITING REVIEW
GW IS...
Great Writing creative writing community is designed to prompt ideas and provide inspiration and motivation within aspiring and amateur authors. Whatever your topic; from love poetry to Doctor Who or Harry Potter fan fiction, Great Writing's online writing group is where you can make new friends and improve your creative writing.
WHO'S ONLINE
We have 1271 guests online and 5 members online
Shorts
Mistaken Identity
By jean.day
22 June 2008
Another assignment for my U3A creative writing group. I used real adverts (somewhat modified) so if any of you is the real author of one of them, I apologize.


Stockport Times, Love 2 Love column - Friday, June 13

ALWAYS AND FOREVER

Batchelor, M, 45, 6’1”, n/s, non-drinker, into music, walking, archeology, reading, computing, Seeks soulmate with GSOH -40-58. Cheshire Box 342.

Man: I am so lonely these days. If only I had somebody to talk to, and spend time with. Sort of a last resort to try the personal columns. I put down that I was 45, which is actually older than I am, but I am hoping for perhaps a mature woman - someone without children to tie her down - maybe a rich divorcee.

Stockport Times, Love 2 Love column - Friday, June 13

GOT AWARENESS?

South Mancs lady, 50, medium build, intelligent, travelled, likes current affairs, writing, country and seaside. Seeks tall, intelligent gentleman with GSOH Box 432.

Woman: This is a very daring thing I am doing, but why not have a bit of fun while I can? So I cheated a bit on my age. Everyone says I look 10 years younger. Nobody ever needs to find out. I had a good look through the paper, found my advert and checked out the men. There was only one possible. Always and Forever sounds a bit intense. He says he is 45 so I take that to mean probably that he is 50 or not far off. Just the right sort of age for me. Old enough to not want to be out clubbing every night. I just might try a note to him and see what happens.


Stockport Times, Love 2 Love column, Box 342.

Dear Always and Forever,

You sound just the sort of man I would love to meet. Perhaps you could tell me a bit more about yourself. I don’t want to get involved with someone without giving it a great deal of thought, so perhaps we could just correspond for awhile to see if we are compatible. Let me know what you think.

Got Awareness, Box 432.

Man: I looks like I have had a response to my ad! Wow, that was good. I saw someone in the paper last night that just might suit - but was a bit put off by how brainy she sounds. But it’s worth looking into it. (He opens the mail.) What? It looks like this is from that very same person who I singled out from last night’s paper. How about that for karma! She picks me and I had just decided to pick her. It’s worth a letter or two.

Stockport Times, Love 2 Love column Box 432


Dear Got Awareness,

I was really pleased to get your note, and I must tell you that I had already decided to write to you based on your advert before I opened it. Isn’t that something? I know what you mean about wanting to take things slowly, but if we are really suited, why waste time? Why don’t you meet me at Piccadilly Gardens, by the big wheel, next Saturday at 7. I’ll be wearing a red shirt and carrying a black briefcase. We can go to the pub on the corner for a drink (I’ll have tea.). Let me know what you think.

Rolf

Woman: Here’s a letter from that Stockport Personal Column. I’m almost scared to open it. (Opens and reads it.) I’m beginning to regret I ever started on this. Rolf, what sort of name is that? He sounds like a dog - not that I expect it is his real name. Oh, he is in such a hurry. I wanted to spend more time sussing the situation out before I committed myself. He probably thinks I am a lot younger and slimmer than I am. So if he’s 10 years older, and I pretend to be 10 years younger, we should be about right. I guess.

Stockport Times, Love 2 Love column, Box 342

Dear Rolf,

You seem in such a hurry, but as it happens, I need to be in Manchester on Saturday anyway, so I will agree. I will be wearing a green outfit, and will have a red poppy pin on my lapel. If I have had a good day, my arms will be full of carrier bags.

Sadie

Saturday night, June 21, 7 p.m. Piccadilly Gardens.

Man: Maybe this is a mistake. I look such an idiot standing around in this red shirt which I had to buy specially. What ever possessed me to say that without looking through my wardrobe? And there are loads of women wearing green. What does an outfit mean? I look at every woman that comes near - and have had a few weird looks back, I must say. I’ll give it another half an hour, and then go home. There’s a woman over there that is the spitting image of my mother except she isn’t wearing glasses. I’ll give it another half an hour and if nobody shows I may as well go home.

Woman: I have felt a real fool, looking all over for an older man in a red shirt. All I can see is that gangly boy over there in burgundy. He looks young enough to be my son but I can’t really see very clearly without my glasses. I will wait another half hour, but then I am going home.

Piccadilly Station - 8 p.m.

Man: Hi, Mum. I didn’t know you were going into town today. You seem to have been successful at the shops. I expect it was all on sale, so you can tell dad how much money you “saved” as usual.

Woman: Hi John. Don’t you look smart in that shirt! I didn’t know you even had one like that. What have you been doing in town?

Man: Oh, just hanging around, you know. I got a few new DVD’s. You might like this one (he takes it out of his bag and shows it to her).

Woman: Sorry, not my sort of thing at all. Have you got any plans for tomorrow’s lunch? Why don’t you come over for a good home cooked meal.

Man: Yeah, well, why not. Doesn’t look like there’s anything else much going on this weekend.

Reviews

Written by Lizzy (783 comments posted) 22nd June 2008
A good one Jean. I didn't really expect the end even when he said she looked like his mother. 
I think ads in papers are much better, and more 'romantic' than those on the net! 
Enjoyed this and it made me smile. 
Lizzy
I did guess
Written by fellpony (1580 comments posted) 22nd June 2008
that she'd be his mother :) I think the emphasis you laid on ages gave it away. However, the thought processes behind all the subterfuge felt very credible! 
 
One blip: If Mum's advertising in the lonely hearts column why does John say "you can tell dad how much money you “saved”"? Doesn't he know about his parents' relationship or lack of it?
Thanks Lizzy and Sue
Written by jean.day (2257 comments posted) 22nd June 2008
It wasn't a blip Sue. That's why John doesn't suspect that it could be his mother - because he assumes all is well with his parents - and that his mother couldn't possibly be writing to a lonely hearts club.  
 
I really meant it to show how different one's view of one's family members is compared to what one's view of a potential partner is.  
 
I doubt that very men would make their age older in order to try to encourage older women to respond - but in the case of my parents - and also with my son's relationship - the woman was 10 years older than the man.

Written by Phil (6645 comments posted) 22nd June 2008
Entertaining little piece in itself. It does has scope for farce - which you avoided - possibly not you. 
 
I reckon this is the sort of thing Jane would be advocating a full script for. As she's not around at the moment, I'll do it. You're half way there already. 
 
Phil 
Thanks Phil
Written by jean.day (2257 comments posted) 22nd June 2008
I didn't think of it as farce or even funny. I meant it to be kind of sad. And I don't think I want to extend it either, but if you think Jane would have liked it, that says a lot.

Written by TwistedTales (544 comments posted) 23rd June 2008
I thought this was well done Jean. One lil thing though...  
 
"There’s a woman over there that is the spitting image of my mother except she isn’t wearing glasses. I’ll give it another half an hour and if nobody shows I may as well go home" - I agree that the woman can't make out who is the bloke because she isn't wearing her glasses, but the guy should be able to, whether his mom is with or without glasses. Its his mom after all. I think may be if you just make them come across each other accidentally, and not actually spell it out for the reader that they were both waiting at the same place...you could mention his pink shirt and something of her's (purse etc) in the passing and let the reader guessing.  
 
 
Regards, 
TT
Thanks TT
Written by jean.day (2257 comments posted) 24th June 2008
I can see your point and I may well change the story before I hand it in. I did make it too obvious that they were related before I needed to.  
 
I do think not wearing glasses makes an enormous difference in how people look - especially if you have always seen them in glasses. 
 
And especially if the woman were in a context that the son was not expecting her to be in - he might not recognise her straight away. I think I will change the story for the woman to recognise the son first - as she would have put her glasses back on at the train station, and then for the son to have a double take when he realises that the woman he saw just might have been his mother after all.

Written by Bottleblondesurfer (3298 comments posted) 30th June 2008
Just come across this while scrolling down.  
I thought it was a great twist on a old subject. I had to look up GSOH 
I thought it meant Grey Showing on Hair.I know better now. 
I like the mix of internal dialogue and letter communication. You could easily have gone the whole way and scripted it. I think it would have given you more scope,especially as you have a great knack for encapsulating character in a few words of dialogue.  
I suppose TT has a point but it is amazing how blind we can be if we see someone out of context. It was a testament to you writing that I was more than happy to suspend my disbelief 
cheers 
jane
Thanks Jane
Written by jean.day (2257 comments posted) 3rd July 2008
I had to think awhile before I got it too - Good Sense of Humour.

Written by Alexis.G (14 comments posted) 6th July 2008
I found myself chuckling heartily at the end. 
Very well done!
Thanks Alexis
Written by jean.day (2257 comments posted) 7th July 2008
I am glad you liked it.

Written by woody44 (774 comments posted) 7th July 2008
Gave me a nice wry smile to brighten up my Monday morning Jean. Now, where did I put that red shirt... 
 
Roger
Thanks Woody
Written by jean.day (2257 comments posted) 7th July 2008
It is always nice to have a review from you.

   Only registered users can rate and write comments.
   Please login or register.

Powered by AkoComment 2.0!

Next item