More on Anne. My effort in all of Anne's stories is to stick to a child's POV, and think and say things, like a child would.
Am I doing that?
Mum is not in her room. She hasn’t been in her room for
ten days now - I have been counting. First I thought, she was sick, but at
night, when Papa goes into the bedroom, there is no sound. I haven’t heard mum
say, "Please John. Not tonight. My insides hurt." I haven’t heard Papa say,
“Shut the fuck up and open
your fucking legs.” When I
ask Papa, he says, "Your mum’s a slut. She must’ve run away with some asshole."
I say, "I want to go to mum,’ and he says, ‘Fuck
off."
I ask Jina what ‘fuck’
means? And she says her Papa uses it, when he’s mad. Then she thinks for a
while and says, "he also uses it when he’s happy." She doesn’t know, she says.
I ask her if her mum is at home. "Yes, she is." Jina is happy when she talks
about her mum and Papa. I tell her my mum isn’t home, and ask if she knows
where she is. Jina combs Polly’s hair and says I should look for my mum under
my bed, or behind doors. I do, but can’t find her.
Papa comes home with an aunty. Her name is Shiela aunty.
She looks much like Bonnie. She wears red lipstick and has brown hair. Shiela
auntie’s clothes have become short too, just like Bonnie’s, after I washed them
once. Papa says she is my new mum. I
tell my brother this, and he says he doesn’t care. I don’t like Sheila aunty. I
feel like crying.
I take out mum’s photo from under my bed and look at her.
That’s when I come to know that she’s playing hide and seek with me. I look for
her everywhere, even in the bathroom and in cupboards. But, I can’t find her. I
tell her she wins, but she doesn’t come out.
I hear Papa and Shiela aunty in the bedroom. Papa doesn’t
say ‘fuck’ to her. She says it to
him. "Fuck me like a man John." I
want to tell her he is a man, but I
don’t. Papa doesn’t like when I go to his room.
My mum looks nice without her sunglasses, without her
black and blue marks. She looks like me, only bigger. Shiela aunty comes in to
my room and snatches the photo from me. She calls my Papa. “John, look who’s
your daughter looking at?” Papa takes my mum’s photo from Shiela auntie’s hands
and spits on my mum. He then tears the photo into many pieces. They both leave.
Shiela aunty looks back and laughs at me. I collect the pieces and put them in
my school bag.
I got hurt in school today. A boy pushed me down and
sang, "Anne has no Mommy, Anne has no mommy." I tell him my mum will be back
soon. I come home, but my mum’s still not there. I open my school bag and take
out that bit of her photo, which has her eyes. She looks at me and says I love you. I say, ‘I love you too, mum.’
|
Written by mia_ms_kim (1019 comments posted) 30th June 2008 |
I kept up with all your Anne stories, but I didn't comment because the subject of child abuse is something I find difficult to comment on. Maybe it's because I'm a mother, the stories of children's suffering are difficult to take. I feel the child's pov works fine and she arouses my sympathy, especially as she derives comfort from the torn photo of her mother. But I wonder if the father's character is completely believable. He seems totally without any redeeming qualities. Mia |
Written by collo (3 comments posted) 1st July 2008 |
Man that's heartbreaking....but a wonderful read (your writing anyway ) Love the simplicity, you say you're trying to achieve a child's view/thoughts and you most definitely did that. There was something so emotive about the bluntness of her questioning. I do, however, agree slightly with Mia, the father perhaps is riding on a bit of a cliche, in that he is so remorseless, and that combined with the girlfriend is perhaps a little overdone. Although they do contribute to the child's complete isolation. Thought the bit about her mum looking nice without her sunglasses and her bruises was extremely poignant, the way the child simply addressed it as a normality of life. Very sad indeed. Overall a really nice read....well done xx |
Written by TwistedTales (548 comments posted) 1st July 2008 |
Thanks Mia and Collo, Mia - I see what you are getting at. I felt the need for the father to be so unattached to help the reader to see how lonely and isolated Anne really is. And also, this is just the beginning of the whole Anne story, i mean I have just written about four to five pieces on her. May be in the future sometime, the father and mother of the child will realize what they've done to their own daughter. I am not sure when or how. Thanks again for the kind words Mia and yes, this is a rather touchy subject, so I myself don't want to gross out people. But such things do happen and whether we talk or write about them or not, it will continue to happen. Collo - Thanks you so much for the encouraging words. It was my aim from the very beginning to keep the writing as innocent and as transparent as possible and leave most of it for the reader to imagine or fill in rather then me spelling it out for them. It's so very hard to get into any POV, especially a child's'. Thanks for the your comments. It really means a lot. Regards, TT
|
Written by Bottleblondesurfer (3362 comments posted) 1st July 2008 |
This is a notoriously difficult style to write in. Writing as a child would, means you walk a fine line between being honest to the child's style and avoiding being so simplistic that you don't engage the adult reader. It only takes one inappropriately adult phrase to break the spell, but I think you managed stay in character and provoke a strong empathy for the girl. I think you captured her POV very accurately and sensitively. I must agree that the father's character was so bad he almost slipped into caricature which would lessen the effect you wanted to achieve. But the girl was beautifully observed cheers jane |
Written by TwistedTales (548 comments posted) 1st July 2008 |
Thanks Jane - OK, help me here. What was the phrase you felt didn't maintain the flow and any suggestions how I could turn around her father's character? What I wanted to show was how her parents are isolating Anne, to the point where she thinks her doll is almost a living person. Thanks again Jane. Would really appreciate any comments/suggestions. Regards, TT |
Written by Bottleblondesurfer (3362 comments posted) 1st July 2008 |
I think you misunderstood me I was just commenting that it only took a wrong word to illustrate my point on how difficult it is to write in a kid's POV. Perhaps I should have gone on to say that I didn't find any here and so found her believable.It was my clumsy attempt at a compliment to your writing. I think you need to make more references to the doll and make her feelings on the doll more explicit. For example:- perhaps the doll gets trodden on and she bandages it and nurses it like it was a child.[showing rather than telling] The father seems to hate her; so either give us the motivation for it or have feel he just wants to ignore and forget about the girl as he is too caught up with his new women.That would also increase the girls feeling of isolation just a few thoughts that might spark off something with you jane |
Written by TwistedTales (548 comments posted) 1st July 2008 |
Oh OK. Thanks Jane. This is really helpful. I'll take all your suggestions on board and try to work them into the story. In fact I am sorry, I just read your review again and "get" it now. ...I really appreciate this Jane. Thank you very much. Regards, TT BTW - I am still waiting for that mail you were suppose to send me If you can't remember what I am talking about, chuck it .
|
Only registered users can rate and write comments.
Please login or register.