Great Writing - Home > Poetry > BY HEART (my father)
READING ROOM
Great Writing - Home
Read and review others' work
Articles on writing
Advice from the community
COMMUNITY
Talk to others in the forums
Events and Competitions
GW News
ABOUT GREAT WRITING
All About Us
Contact Us
WORK AWAITING REVIEW
GW IS...
Great Writing creative writing community is designed to prompt ideas and provide inspiration and motivation within aspiring and amateur authors. Whatever your topic; from love poetry to Doctor Who or Harry Potter fan fiction, Great Writing's online writing group is where you can make new friends and improve your creative writing.
WHO'S ONLINE
We have 1756 guests online and 3 members online
Poetry
BY HEART (my father)
By Katanga
02 July 2008
My third attempt on the July topic 'MY HEART'.

The 'you' deliberately changes places, in case you should ask - but never mind.

'Enjambment' (?) rukes okay here, I think?

Sadly, the below is all true, so I'll say no more.

As ever, comments more than welcome!

Cheers!

John X


By Heart

 

I learned to live when I was young.

I guess that’s not surprising?

The sap of life welled up in me,

the fluid kept on rising.

 

But then I shared a sudden death

with you – where are you, Mother?

My father all is gone from us

and there will be no other

 

who cradles me in his strong arms,

who calls me by my name -

“Johnny, let’s hunt beetles!”

I will never hear again

 

down by the Ashdown Forest,

near our cottage that he built,

where I grew up with butterflies,

and now am racked with guilt.

 

And yes, we hunted beetles,

and yes, we found a few.

We put them in a matchbox 

to keep them safe for you.
 

Now I remember his last words -

they linger to the core

“Hello, my darling!” is all he said

and nothing, nothing more.

 

I carry these words, off by heart,

as if they’re something new.

Every evening I recite them,

and think, and think, of you.

 

There’s only me that writes this thing,

You, Father, are long gone,

but love wells up inside me here

on and on and on.

 

And so I come to question why,

when all is said and done,

why don’t we simply finish off

what we have just begun?

But I still have that matchbox,
I open it whenever
I think of my lost father
and when we were so together. 


Reviews

Written by Phil (7169 comments posted) 2nd July 2008
Touched, John. 
 
No comment on the verse - seems superfluous. 
 
By heart? - From the heart. 
 
Phil
Phil
Written by Katanga (1698 comments posted) 2nd July 2008
Touched too, by your comment. 
 
More would be superfluous . . . I understand. 
 
Clumsy meter in places? Oh, yes! But that's the point - if it works when read aloud, job done! 
 
Thank you so much, Phil! 
 
So much more to come . . . When we are gone? 
 
Tom Paxton? Yo! Ho! 
 
Cheers! 
 
John X

Written by Bottleblondesurfer (3713 comments posted) 2nd July 2008
As Phil said comment is really redundant. This somehow transcends structure and form [though it is there] and goes straight to the heart. 
He may be gone but with such vivid memories of him he can't be gone far. I could say more but perhaps not. This theme does seem to be provoking some powerful work. 
cheers 
jane 
Jane!
Written by Katanga (1698 comments posted) 2nd July 2008
I cannot thank you enough . . . 
 
He died 35 years ago . . . but there's been a few really good things on here about 'time' recently. 
 
The 'aubade' concept id so strong ( see Brett, Veronica, Josie, and even me). 
 
Well . . . 
 
Thanks Jane . . . . 
 
Bye for now 
 
John (Beardless Katanga!) X

Written by mia_ms_kim (1057 comments posted) 2nd July 2008
With the above reviewers. Deeply touched, especially by the beetle hunting and "hello, darling." 
 
I think at any age, our parents make children of us all. I was talking to my Dad who is in his 70's and ill (to get more material for my stories I'm ashamed to say), and at one point he began talking about his mother whom he lost at age 16. She looked after him when he was isolated by himself, dying with infectious disease. She nursed him to life, but she caught the infection and died. Such is the love of a parent. My Dad choked as he told me the story all over again. 
 
Your poem reminded me of my Dad's memory of his mother and his longing for her. I think when one loses a parent before he/she has been fully parented, there is that child inside always mourning that great loss. 
 
Mia :cry
Always Mia!
Written by Katanga (1698 comments posted) 2nd July 2008
You should put this thinking into your own poem . . . 
 
Yes, you understand me totally, and it chokes! 
 
Longings and losses are life's left-overs . . . 
 
Damned good subjects for poetry, but so what? 
 
If I could swap a real tragic experience for a poem on a website or even a piece of paper, I know which I would choose . . . 
 
Answers on a postcard please . . . 
 
Cheers! 
 
John X

Written by 1211kellie (177 comments posted) 2nd July 2008
Beautiful, but as a parent I found it quite emotionally painful.  
 
Kellie :)

Written by ainsel (68 comments posted) 3rd July 2008
Your heart is really in this one, isn't it? There are some beautiful details of memory that you have captured - "Hello, my darling!" nearly finished me, it brought my own father back so vividly.  
 
I'm not an expert in poetry, so it's hard for me to comment on the form - generally I prefer a less formal structure for things that are this close to the heart, but that's a personal preference. But the content is just such a natural outpouring of love and longing, that the form doesn't register on first reading, which is how it should be in my view. 
 
Your father must have been a lovely man.

Written by Talisker (1338 comments posted) 3rd July 2008
One of those rare occasions when the emotion is all that matters. 
 
I was moved like the others - painfully honest and full of longing.  
 
Oli

Written by NathanRoberts (277 comments posted) 3rd July 2008
Hi John, 
 
There were aspects of it that I enjoyed. It has an innocent quality, and some simple but effective imagery. I'm afraid I did find the metre clumsy which detracts from it, and I'm a bit mystified by your comment: 
 
'Clumsy meter in places? Oh, yes! But that's the point - if it works when read aloud, job done!' 
 
This seems a bit carefree/throwaway for such a deeply important memory. It's your memory, your poem, but I would have thought you'd want this to be the best you could possibly do. I'm only comparing it with my own experience - I struggled for over three weeks with a poem I wrote about my mother's death and I'm still deeply unsatisfied with the results. I've had to leave it to rest for a while, but it'll be bugging me until I feel it's right. 
 
Sorry, if it sounds like I'm berating you or preaching...just my honest reaction. 
Thank you, Rob!
Written by Katanga (1698 comments posted) 3rd July 2008
Hello again Rob! 
 
A sincere thank-you for your review above - no I don't feel you're berating me or preaching at all. It's an honest, well-considered, 'accurate' review! 
 
The comment that mystifies you? All I mean is that in reading aloud, one can 'cover up' metrical clumsinesses by stressing things differently to how they might appear on the page - one can make syllables either very short or very long, depending on the demands of the rhythm. 
 
I sometimes find 100% regular meter a bit over-polished, and when raw emotion comes in, some 'breaks' seem to add authenticity? Dunno! 
 
I rushed it - yes, a bad habit of mine. I see you bet at least one of your buttocks on the notion that if you posted your 'For Boys of as Certain Age' under 'Shorts', people would say it reads like poetry. Ha! 
 
I shall bet one of my own buttocks + half a testicle that I can improve my piece about my father! 
 
Cheers! And thanks again . . .  
 
John

   Only registered users can rate and write comments.
   Please login or register.

Powered by AkoComment 2.0!

 Previous item   Next item