Great Writing - Home > Short S. > Only with Faith and Guns
READING ROOM
Great Writing - Home
Read and review others' work
Articles on writing
Advice from the community
COMMUNITY
Talk to others in the forums
Events and Competitions
GW News
ABOUT GREAT WRITING
All About Us
Contact Us
WORK AWAITING REVIEW
GW IS...
Great Writing creative writing community is designed to prompt ideas and provide inspiration and motivation within aspiring and amateur authors. Whatever your topic; from love poetry to Doctor Who or Harry Potter fan fiction, Great Writing's online writing group is where you can make new friends and improve your creative writing.
WHO'S ONLINE
We have 1387 guests online and 6 members online
Shorts
Only with Faith and Guns
By Nick
31 July 2008
With this story, I've tried to take on-board the advice I've been given so far from the GW community.

Comments, as always, much appreciated

    Mike's hands are chained to a desk, he's sitting uncomfortably on a plastic chair, looking apprehensively at his captor.  The room's pure white, with bright lights running the length of the ceiling.  It's windowless and despite the brightness, depressing.  The only thing that's out of character with the room are his black steel handcuffs.  “Why have I been arrested?” Mike says with a little trepidation.  His captor just stares at him as he paces the room muttering to himself.  It sounds a little bit like a prayer or he could just be insane.  Mike starts to wonder what the hell he's done to be arrested and thrown in a room with this big, hulking brute of a man.  He maybe wearing a perfectly tailored suit but a smartly dressed Gorilla is still just a Gorilla.

    Finally, after what seems like hours, his captor speaks “Who is your God?”.  “What do you mean, my God, mmm I'm well..” stutters Mike.  “Who is your God?  The question is simple enough.  What religion are you?”.  “I'm well, mmm well I'm Jewish.”  Mike stutters, while the first drops of sweat form on his brow.  His captor stops pacing and looks up to the ceiling, nodding slightly as he does so.  He then moves his massive frame to within inches of Mike's face and slowly whispers “ah Jewish, the murderers of Christ, you're a heathen, an outcast, an infidel but most of all, you're my enemy.”.  The Gorilla moves back from Mike, pauses, then slams his massive palms onto the table.  He raises his voice to just slightly louder than a whisper “My God demands that I make others believe in Him.  I am here to persuade you to repent your sins and convert to the only true religion.”.  

    Mike looks startled and tries to move away from his captor but discovers his rigid white  chair is bolted to the floor.  He tries to stare back at this giant of a man, but can only  look at his sky blue eyes for milliseconds at a time.  Mike then concentrates on the man's small, flat nose and says with as much courage as he can muster “what if I don't, you know, convert to your religion.  I'm Jewish and proud.”.  He continues but with a bit more pride and authority “I'm not going to change my religion just because you asked me too.  I maybe handcuffed and at your mercy but this is 21st century Britain, this is a free country.  I can worship who I want.”.  

    With that his captor starts to roar in laughter and after a few seconds, looks up to the ceiling again and says “did you hear that, this little monkey thinks it's a free country and he can worship who he chooses.”.  He laughs again while staring right at Mike.  With a bit more menace in his voice he reverts to whispering “you think this is a free country.  This country has never been free.  Money controls everything and we've plenty of that.  Big business use to rule but now it's our time, religion has always been very profitable.”.

    Really struggling in his chair, Mike's almost in full panic mode now.  He's locked in a room, with some religious zealot, who has grand plans for world domination.  The Gorilla moves away from Mike, he adjusts his white collar and puts his hands in his pockets and continues his diatribe “we're here to stop the moral decline of this once great nation.  We will convert everyone to our faith or we'll send them to hell.  If you're not with us, then your against us.  God is tired of waiting for everyone to 'make their choice', he has decreed that only with faith and guns can mankind survive. You either get some faith or you can die.”.  With that he pulls a gun out of his pocket and slams it onto the desk.

    Mike jumps in his chair and with a look of fear, stares at the gun and starts muttering “you, you can't do this, I'm a British citizen, I pay my taxes, I'm free, I'm free, we worship the same God, religion doesn't matter, you can't do this, you can't do this.”.  He stops speaking when his captor picks up the gun and points it at his head “confess your sins and convert to Catholicism you dirty Jew bastard or I'll bury you.”.


    Mike starts to wrestle with his handcuffs but they won't budge.  He knows he's in trouble and there is no way out.  He starts to mutter a last prayer but his captor interrupts him “I will not have your filthy chants in my house.  You Jews are so blind, look at your history.  Nobody loves you, not even God.”.

    A tear runs down Mike's cheek like the first raindrop of the coming storm.  The Gorilla doesn't notice and continues “that's the difference between us, our God loves me but he never forgave you for killing his only son, mankind is against you and you can't even see it.  You just keep limping along like some booby prize in a cosmic contest.”.  By now Mike's tears are free flowing and he doesn't care.  “Don't take it personally, we have it out for all fake religions not just yours but I always feel most righteous when it's one of your kind, you know revenge for Christ and all that.  

    Knowing his time has come to an end, Mike takes a deep breathe, sits straight up in his chair while wiping away the tears and says “My God is your God but my religion is my own, you can never take that away from me.  I will never repent my faith.”.  With the outburst done, Mike sits back in his chair and waits for his fate..  

    The priest cocks his gun, looks to the ceiling, smiles, nods and with no compassion, stares back at Mike and says “May Hell burn hotter with you there”.

Reviews

Written by stevetroster (1601 comments posted) 31st July 2008
Hey Nick, can I be honest with you? 
 
You’ve got some punctuation issues (mainly around speech). You’ve got a cliché. You’ve got one of those meaningless (like) metaphors. You’ve got ‘got it out for’ as opposed to got it in for. You’ve got maybe instead of may be (twice) and you’ve got Mike wiping away tears even though his hands are chained to a desk. 
But, you’ve also got an imagination that takes you a mile away from the humdrum Soap Opera scribbles. 
Give it a read back through with a view to picking up on the spag, cutting out the superfluous and tweaking the high spots. 
 
All the best, 
Steve.

Written by Phil (7003 comments posted) 31st July 2008
A good idea for a short. Steve mentions a lot of technical points - all very valid. Sorting them will add to the quality. 
 
Overlooking the technical, I didn't engage with this. I felt it was over written. (Steve's superfluous perhaps) Often, simple and direct is much more effective than over wordy. You have to lave space for the reader to build the world you see and cut all unnecessary words. As examples - I'm not sure what the first five lines add the story. - This line: His captor just stares at him as he paces the room muttering to himself. Could be shortened to: His captor stares and paces the room, muttering. It's those little verbal (written) ticks like just that slow the whole piece down. 
 
Sorry - sounds very negative. You have a good idea. Mine is only an opinion too. 
 
Phil

Written by TwistedTales (548 comments posted) 31st July 2008
Nick the idea is good, as has been said before, but like some of your other pieces there are bits of overwriting, for example - "Mike starts to wonder what the hell he's done to be arrested and thrown in a room with this big, hulking brute of a man." - You could very well include this in the dialog, “Why have I been arrested?” Mike says with a little trepidation. "Why am I here?" This of course is a suggestion. And as far as the description of his captor, "He maybe wearing a perfectly tailored suit but a smartly dressed Gorilla is still just a Gorilla" - this information is enough for the reader to guess his size. So the earlier mention of "hulking brute of a man" could be removed.  
 
And yes, you're certainly far far away from the Humdrum Soap Opera Scribbles or Boring Stage Play scripts.  
 
Regards, 
TT

Written by Emmuttmax (203 comments posted) 31st July 2008
Nick, 
 
Although an interesting idea, the piece is overburden with logic problems and cliches. When you are writing dialog, it is much better to separate each characters comments into separate paragraphs; it makes it easier for the reader to follow.
Liked it
Written by Bottleblondesurfer (3590 comments posted) 1st August 2008
I have to say I actually thought this was quite good. It had a strong narrative flow and kept me wanting to read on, which  
doesn’t always happen with the stories here. You hook the reader and pull them along. 
Yes, it was tad overwritten and clichés should always be avoided [like the plague??].  
 
Like Phil I didn’t fully engage with it but for different reasons. There was so little context that I couldn’t orientate myself in the story and the main character never really came across, so it was difficult to build concern for him. His reactions were too anonymous, for me. 
 
“I maybe handcuffed and at your mercy but this is 21st century Britain, this is a free country. I can worship who I want.”.  
 
He comes across, with this, as more of a cipher to expound the theme of the story than a real character. It sounds a bit “Staged” I’d like to have seen more of the real Mike. 
And here :- 
 
"Mike starts to wonder what the hell he's done to be arrested and thrown in a room with this big, hulking brute of a man 
 
Starts to wonder!! - bit of bloody understatement given the circumstances. The man finds himself tied and trapped with a psychotic, religious zealot and he just starts to wonder. I don’t feel I got to know him  
All this sounds a bit picky but you did ask, and as I said you have a knack for well judged narrative and pacy story telling .The rest is fine tuning 
Cheers 
jane 
 
 
 

Written by Nick (163 comments posted) 2nd August 2008
Everyone - Thanks for taking the time to review. 
 
Steve - Yes please be honest - If I'm to improve as a writer the only way to do that is through good advice and crits. As for the 'tear wiping' oops - Maybe he's a contortionist or maybe I'm just stupid!! 
 
Phil/TT/Mike - thanks for the advice - I will take this onboard when doing a re-write. 
 
BBS - thanks for the pointers and the '21st century Britiain' bit - re-reading it I realise no-one would actually say that. 
 
Anyway thanks again for the reviews and encouragement. 
 
Nick 
 

   Only registered users can rate and write comments.
   Please login or register.

Powered by AkoComment 2.0!

 Previous item   Next item