The second piece in my conquest to tie up loose ends.
This is my first attempt at writing from the POV of a small child. I think my vocabulary is too big...I'm too smart to sound stupid :P
Why do hospitals smell funny? I wonder.
I have a seat all to myself between mom and dad, and my feet swing back and
forth. I don’t know why we’re here exactly, but it’s making mom upset. “Mom?” I
ask. She clears her throat before she speaks.
“Yes,
James?” Her voice is hushed, and wavers.
“Why
do hospitals smell funny?” Mom gives a half laugh and a half smile, and looks
down at her lap. For a moment she says nothing, then, “I don’t know, Sweetie. I
don’t know.” Mom only says she doesn’t know when really she’s not telling my
something. I want keep asking, but her eyes are wet again. Is it my fault? I
wonder, and frown. I want to make mom feel better, but I don’t know how.
Dad
touches my shoulder. “Hey, champ,” he says, “Here’s some money. Why don’t you
go get us some snacks from the machine over there? You remember how to use
those machines, right?” I nod because I do remember how to use those machines,
but I don’t take the money because I don’t want to go. The machine is across
the waiting room and there are a hundred strange people between there and here.
I look back up at dad for sympathy, but he gives me a cold look.
I
start walking to the machine. Glancing back, dad is leaning over my seat to
hold mom. She’s burying herself in his shoulder the way I bury myself in hers
when I cry. Why won’t mom or dad tell me why we’re in a hospital? I wonder.
We
were in the car going to meet grandma at a restaurant. Ahead of us there were
lots of flashing police lights. The car slowed down, and I asked why we were
slowing down. Dad said that everyone else wanted to get a glimpse of the
accident as they drove by. I wanted a glimpse too. There was a red pick-up
truck with the front smashed, and a gray car with the driver’s door crushed in.
Lots of people were standing around, and some were ambulance people taking care
of the people in the crash. Dad said to mom, “Shit, that’s not her car is it?” We
slowed down even more, and mom and dad were glued to the windows. Mom gasped
and cried, “Todd, look at the bumper sticker. It’s her. Oh my God, it’s her.”
The ambulance drove away, and we followed it to the hospital.
I
have to reach my highest to hit the buttons on the machine, but feel big when I
begin walking back to dad with three bags of chips. Dad is still leaned over my
seat. “Here, dad,” I say, holding out my food-filled arms to his back. He lets
go of mom to turn and face me, and I feel like an intruder.
“Thanks,
bud.” I climb back into my seat. Each of us has chips, but I notice that I’m
the only one eating. I stop eating. Mom and dad are quiet, and dad checks his
watch a lot. I watch the minutes tick by on the big, white wall clock. I wonder
when we’re going home, but mom and dad seem tense and I’m nervous to say
anything at all.
A
doctor walks in through a big door and asks for mom. Mom stands up and walks to
meet the doctor. Dad tells me to stay here for just a minute, then follows mom.
I can still hear the doctor talking from my seat, though. He uses lots of words
I don’t know. He says, “We did everything we could, but the accident was
faydal. I’m very sorry.” Mom cries again, and dad cries now too. What does ‘faydal’
mean? I wonder.
|
Written by KaydieKate (75 comments posted) 4th August 2008 |
This worked and it didn't. Children are not introspective creatures. Is it my fault? I wonder, and frown. I want to make mom feel better, but I don’t know how. I don't believe this would be the thought of a child. I think simple observations, and simple thoughts, would fix it. Also, you run into the age old "Show, don't tell" problem. But over all, I liked it. It was fairly convincing: it is easier to write from a child's persecutive using third person. We loose the simplicity when we grow, so it's extremely difficult to pull off a convincing first person. Cheers, Kate |
Written by KaydieKate (75 comments posted) 4th August 2008 |
| Oh, but I did love the repetition of the questions: one at the beginning, one at the end. Great way to tie up the story. |
Written by Phil (7001 comments posted) 4th August 2008 |
I don't agree that children are not reflective - far from it. Again, as a short scene, I thought this worked well. Phil |
Written by Bottleblondesurfer (3590 comments posted) 4th August 2008 |
I have to agree with Phil [ and by association your story] I think children are introspective.It's just a more solipsistic kind and I thought you caught it well. The tone was a bit erratic in places,some of the expressions were a bit sophisticated for a child, but, on the whole, it worked very well. cheers jane |
Written by briarcroft (38 comments posted) 4th August 2008 |
Kids always want to know if they have somehow caused the distress they see in those around them. It seemed very natural to include that here. It is always a challenge to write from a child's POV so trying to simplify the internal thoughts of the child would help, using simpler words and concepts. And this is always one's nightmare to come upon an accident involving a loved one. Emily |
Written by TwistedTales (548 comments posted) 4th August 2008 |
About children being reflective, really depends on their age. TYPO - "Mom only says she doesn’t know when really she’s not telling my something. I want keep asking, but her eyes are wet again." - 1) The kid wouldn't start with "Is it my fault so early into the story." 2) We were in the car going to meet grandma at a restaurant - why would they meet her at the restaurant, why not at her home? and the pick-up truck is kinda more sturdy and strong than normal cars. So if you want to keep this "idea" I think you should go for a more flimsy car like a mini-cooper or something. But for me the "restaurant" as a meeting point didn't work. I'd rather that you work the accident into the story some other way or just give the lady a heart attack or make her a victim of a break-in. Of course, this is only a suggestion. 3) I have to reach my highest to hit the buttons on the machine, but feel big when I begin walking back to dad with three bags of chips - this line is fantastic. 4) He lets go of mom to turn and face me, and I feel like an intruder - this should be phrased in a different way. The word "intruder" seems inappropriate for a kid to use, again age factor comes in. If he's much older than his thoughts of course will be much different. 5) I was nervous to ask - "scared" is a much better word. A kid wouldn't know what "nervous" means. That's my thinking. Hope this helps. TT |
Written by Fledermaus (3506 comments posted) 5th August 2008 |
Agree with most of the above, but enough has been said about that already. To me it was convincing, except that the kid did not grasp what was going on. Why didn't he wonder why they went to the hospital rather than to the restaurant? And hospitals smell funny indeed... Yet every section seems to smell differently. |
Written by manyworlds (2 comments posted) 29th August 2008 |
I can get through a child's POV when it is written at the adult level in the third person, and the dialogue reflects the childs age and perspective. You get the credit for exploring a character far from yourself in an emotional situation. Grief is expressed individually, and the more emotional understanding the child has, the more introspective questions come into play. If the child is not told anything, the the emotion is turned inward and plays out toward self questioning. I find this accurate. If the grandmother is driving in from out of town or another part of the city, it may be that the family usually meets at a certain restaurant on family occasions, so adding this background may foreshadow the break in the family to the reader, even if the child does not understand.
|
Only registered users can rate and write comments.
Please login or register.