READING ROOM
Great Writing - Home
Read and review others' work
Articles on writing
Advice from the community
COMMUNITY
Talk to others in the forums
Events and Competitions
GW News
ABOUT GREAT WRITING
All About Us
Contact Us
WORK AWAITING REVIEW
GW IS...
Great Writing creative writing community is designed to prompt ideas and provide inspiration and motivation within aspiring and amateur authors. Whatever your topic; from love poetry to Doctor Who or Harry Potter fan fiction, Great Writing's online writing group is where you can make new friends and improve your creative writing.
WHO'S ONLINE
We have 1651 guests online and 4 members online
Shorts
The red veil
By Fledermaus
18 September 2008
Politically incorrect? It's the character, not me.

 

A title... A title at last. Master of Arts, M.A... She had thought it'd feel differently, make her more important, as if in that very instant she'd become mature, wise, a sage... But there was no difference. She was still the same girl, trying to empty her mind of worries.

While her thesis was finished, had been handed in and rated, the next hurdle had already appeared on the horizon, for now it was time for her to cross the great river and to tear down the bridge behind her. Too long she had been a spoiled little girl. She could no longer flee and hide behind the folds of her mother's skirt. The world expected her to be a woman, even though she didn't feel like one.

Once upon a time there would not have been a choice; She wondered how it would have been many years ago... No-one ever told her the whole story, yet she had heard fragments and seen it portrayed in films.

She closed her eyes and saw herself in a mirror, her hair braided and decorated with ribbons and tassels. Long lashes cast their shadow over her dark eyes, the lids made heavy with make-up; Her cheeks red as if she was blushing.

The robes were made of red silk, embroidered with gold. They followed the curves of her body, but from her waist down they spread out in many folds, reaching to the ground.

She felt how her mother's hands brushed a few strands into place and then attached the headdress. She gave her a strange smile, as if she did not know whether to be happy or sad. Then there was only red... The veil had been lowered to hide her face. She was a present to her groom, neatly wrapped in silk.

They guided her to the door, through the corridors and halls and towards the sedan. How tiresome every step seemed, for her feet were those of a lady, tended like a bonsai tree. She realized that she would never see the house, nor the people that lived in it. Who else was there in this dream besides her mother?

She climbed into the strange vehicle and felt how it was lifted onto the strong shoulders of men belonging to another class. Would there be a procession? Would people wait in the streets to see her being carried to her husband's family? This was her wedding, yet she couldn't see it herself.

She opened her eyes and looked at the clouds. Back then she would be married off, traded for gold and cattle and spend the rest of her life between the walls of her husbands house.

But the present was the present; Her parents had invested a lot in her studies and her feet were size 7. She lived in a world were women could become president or astronaut and where daughters were as important as sons, a world where she could seek her own husband and live wherever she wanted...

Somehow she wondered though. Back in those days all that was expected of a woman was to bear a son. A husband was arranged and he would take care of her wellbeing. Her future would be secure and predictable. Yet nowadays to even dream of such things was ungrateful. Wave after wave of feminism had given her the liberties to work and to choose her own Mr. Right... The obligation to find a job and earn her own money, the threat of dying without a husband or a child in a world were empty materialism had replaced ceremony and romance...

 

Reviews

Written by Veronica_Milvus (751 comments posted) 18th September 2008
You see empty materialism. 
I see liberty. 
 
You see an obligation to find a job and earn her own money. 
I see independence from other people's whims. 
 
Sometimes people crave the pure and simple life. It might have been simple but it was rarely pure!

Written by Fledermaus (3490 comments posted) 18th September 2008
Hi Veronica, 
Of course I could have easily made this into a story pitying the bride (maybe even a concubine), but I deliberately chose to look at it from another side.

Written by Bottleblondesurfer (3568 comments posted) 19th September 2008
I thought this was well written and I applaud you for taking a different route to the expected one.Taking the reader to cliche and then neatly subverting it.. 
I didn't see this as politically incorrect but a sharp portrayal of someone caught between the demands of her culture and the awareness that education has given her. I think you got a bit partial at the end by describing materialism as empty and ascribing romance to the cultural demands. [very dubious claims]But on the whole it was a worthy effort at presenting those problems and the character was well rounded and sympathetic. 
cheers 
jane

Written by Fledermaus (3490 comments posted) 19th September 2008
Thanks Jane, 
Well of course her (modern) parents expect her to make a career, just as they would expect from a son, but she dreams of the life her grandmother must have had. At first I was thinking of an European girl, but then, the Chinese civilization of a hundred years ago was far more extreme... Bound feet (although not amongst all peoples), polygamy, concubines, arranged marriages. And somehow that veil is fascinating, for while intended to hide the bride away, it probably also prevents her from seeing anything. 
I do wonder if all modern women are so happy with the achievements of feminism, for while it's a good thing if people have rights it does seem many of them have become obligations.

Written by homeagain (6 comments posted) 19th September 2008
 
Interesting piece. 
I like how it is broken up into short paragraphs. Easy to read and assimilate. 
 
Her mother's uncertain feelings about the wedding and her daughter's future. 
I get a good sense of the preparation and anticipation. 
I like the presence of her mother in the writing. The chain of generations and history. Her own separation from her mother's skirt-folds as a woman in her own right. 
 
I also like the change in worlds... she is the graduate, then closes her eyes and becomes the bride, then looks up at the clouds and is the graduate again. 
The physical gestures punctuating the gap between the two worlds and separating the imagery. 
 
From a subject-matter pov that is the crux for me. Pushed into only the two extremes. Two separate worlds rather than both options belonging to the one same world. 
 
And also links with the separation between her inner feelings of girlhood and external expectations of womanhood.  
The first few lines.. I get an image of a young woman being literally turfed out into this big wide world quite suddenly with no gentle development into adulthood. 
 
The character does romanticise/idealise things a little at the end in thinking that marriage in the old-world would have assured her security and predictability (and romance). But is a realistic touch because we all do tend to view some things from the past through rose-tinted glasses rather than remembering why they had needed to change. 
 
The archetypal Greener Grass. Wanting whatever it is that we don't have, that others have, or which we no longer have.  
Transition into adulthood. And the urge to find a new care-giver to rescue us from this unfamiliar responsibility and new phase in our lives.  
The accusations of ingratitude if someone declines something offered to them. The offer is tainted with the fulfilment of someone else's dreams and expectations. Projections and vicarious living. 
(Themes in the story that are beyond gender. It is multi-layered.) 
 
Well written. Interesting. 
I might not necessarily agree with the pov of the main character, but it raises questions and issues to think about. 
 

Written by Fledermaus (3490 comments posted) 19th September 2008
Thanks homeagain, 
For your lengthy review. Of course it is HER point of view (even though I think it won't harm to question things and play the devil's advocate every now and then). Of course her view is overly romantic, but on the other hand I also wonder if the way in which it's nowadays portrayed in films and books is actually realistic. It seems one trips over self-confident female characters unhappy with their arranged marriage, yet I personally doubt if back then many people would have considered other possibilities. Most likely marriage was as natural as being born and dying.

Written by Lizzy (828 comments posted) 21st September 2008
Well written and draws the reader in. Gives the reader a lot to think about. 
Interesting that arranged marriages are not things of the past, still happening today here in Britain. We also hear of 'honour' killings where girls are murdered because they refuse to marry or because they fall in love with someone of a different religion or society. 
 
Maybe you could write a story about a modern day arranged marriage. 
Lizzy

Written by Fledermaus (3490 comments posted) 21st September 2008
Thanks Lizzy. 
Maybe I could, though I don't know enough about the societies that do such things nowadays.
HI Ron
Written by jean.day (2366 comments posted) 22nd September 2008
When I read this, I thought of my nephew's wife - a Vietnamese woman, with her PhD, but then marrying in her beautiful red and gold gown in a very traditional ceremony. Luckily her marriage was not an arranged one, and they seem to be very happy. I don't think her shoes are size 7 - most Orientals, even without restraint, would probably not be more than a 4 or 5.

Written by Fledermaus (3490 comments posted) 22nd September 2008
Thanks Jean, 
I had to look up the UK shoe sizes. Indeed most asian girls have small feet, but then, I guess size 6 or 7 is quite normal for a woman, is it? 
All of my family members married Western style, so I have never been to an Asian wedding in real life. Basically my knowledge of them is the same as the main characters: Stories and films...

   Only registered users can rate and write comments.
   Please login or register.

Powered by AkoComment 2.0!

 Previous item   Next item