Great Writing - Home > Stories > Friendship Lies
Shorts
Friendship Lies
By Clifftown
27 February 2009

The theme for this story was "female friendship", but it ended up being quite dark and including other themes, as stories do - and now I don't quite know what to make of it myself!

If you manage to finish it I'd be interested to know what stuck out for you. Thanks in advance for reading.

Nina


“Kyra Collins is dark and disingenuous”

Freya Jones stared at her computer screen for a few moments before adding a smiley to the end of her status update, to take the edge off it.  She was just having a laugh, using clever words and all that.  Her green eyes glinted in the screen’s reflected glow.

She glanced at the corner of Kyra’s Profile page, which boasted the fact that she had ’52 friends’.   Not a patch on the other losers she’d encountered on Facebook, including the other nerdy ones she’d been to school with.  It seemed you weren’t anybody unless you had at least a hundred friends to your name, although whether or not you’d actually seen any of them in the flesh seemed superfluous to requirements.  If you had a good-looking profile photo and didn’t count bestiality and Star Trek conventions among your ‘Activities and Interests’, you could be anybody’s friend here.  Comforting, yet ultimately meaningless at the same time.

The thought in mind,  Freya was surprised and irritated by the need she felt to justify to no-one in particular Kyra’s comparatively unsocial amount of friends, the current number being all Freya could be bothered to trawl through the site to collect during the past few hours in which she had been a member.   It was an effective ruse, sending her intended “friends” the same identical message – “Hi!  I’m Kyra Collins, couldn’t help noticing we’ve got the same initials…wanna be my friend? :-)”   She’d been instantly accepted by all of them, no questions asked.

In spite of herself, Freya had enjoyed indulging Kyra by setting up a full, glitzy Profile page for her, complete with a stunning picture of her out on the town with some similarly attractive friends, all sporting wide smiles and clutching bright, fizzing cocktails as though they hadn’t a care in the world (picture courtesy of Cosmopolitan).  “Kyra Collins, Age 21, Mature student and part-time model, Engaged”.  Even given Facebook’s depressingly low friendship acceptance criteria, who wouldn’t want her as their friend?  In Kyra’s frothy world, life was just an endless cloud of fuzzy pink candy floss.

Freya’s eyes darted down to the digital clock in the corner of her computer screen, blinking with surprise as she acknowledged the time in the real world.   Nearly 3am.  Not bad for a student, but she hadn’t even had any alcohol to show for it – not to mention an early lecture that she hadn’t done any preparation for whatsoever.  A slight pang of disappointment in her usual lack of effort neutralised itself in a haze of sudden tiredness as Freya prepared for bed, consoling herself that what she’d been doing all night was ultimately better for her future than Chemical Science. 

…………

“Over here!”  Kate had saved her a seat in the crowded canteen.  Bless her.  Freya shuffled over to the table with her breakfast tray, still sluggish and exhausted from the night before.  Her mind hadn’t been able to switch off and she’d only managed about an hour’s sleep, if that.  The sound of excited student chatter rang loudly in her ears as she sat down.

“You don’t normally drink coffee,” Kate observed with a teasing smile.  “Am I right in thinking you’ve changed the habit of a lifetime and actually done some studying last night?”

Freya looked across the table at her best friend.  Kate Carmichael was, as always, a shiningly perfect beacon of exactly what a nineteen year old girl should look like, if you were a Hollywood director looking to make yet another fluffy “chick flick” about university life.  The predictable teenage flaws hadn’t made their mark on Kate, who was permanently clear-skinned and tall with a lithe, graceful figure.  She was also in possession of a luxuriant mane of long chestnut hair that was as yet untouched by peroxide or semi-permanent tint, unlike Freya’s own unruly mop of bleached blonde frizz. 

It didn’t seem fair somehow, Freya thought on a more regular basis than was perhaps healthy, that people who were unconditionally loved should have the added benefit of being naturally beautiful.  Not having beauty made one so much harder to love. 

“Study, me?”  Freya feigned innocence.  “Come on now, you know I don’t need to study like you mere mortals.  I’ve got everything up here already.”  She tapped her head with her finger and flashed a tired grin.

“God, I’m jealous,” said Kate.  “I have to study for ages and still nothing sticks.  You’re so lucky,” she enthused as Freya stirred three packets of sugar into her mug of black sludgy coffee.  She felt about as lucky as a Lottery winner whose dog had eaten their ticket.

“So what were you doing all night to be so tired, then?”  Kate continued, a grin playing around her full, glossy lips.  “It wouldn’t be a certain Mr. Wright keeping you awake, now would it?”

Freya bristled at the mention of his name.  She wasn’t quite sure how to react to mentions of Sean yet, particularly from Kate.  It was all so new and uncertain, and she felt an instinctive desire to protect it.  Whatever it was.  She stared into her coffee, as if expecting to find the perfect answer there.

“No...I was just on the computer for a while, that’s all.  You of all people know how distracting the internet can be.”

Kate groaned.  “You know, I wish I’d never heard of Facebook, it’s taking up so much of my time.  I was up until midnight on Friday talking to my friends.  Friday as well – I must be mad!”  She shook her head, hair swishing softly around her shoulders as Freya raised an eyebrow at her.

“I know…I know…you’re the clever and sensible one who won’t go anywhere near anything like that.  But you know me; I’m just a mere mortal who can’t resist.”  She fluttered her eyelashes to exaggerate the comment.

“I could get offended here, you know.  I’ll start thinking you prefer the company of your virtual friends to mine!”

Kate continued as though Freya hadn’t spoken.  “I do enjoy it though, chatting online.  People are so lovely.  Like, someone asked me to be their friend yesterday just because we had the same initials.  Isn’t that nice?  I mean, normally you wouldn’t know if someone had the same initials as you unless you asked them first, and who’d do that?  You’d just look like a complete idiot.”  Kate looked over at Freya, who was trying to suppress a smile, and punched her playfully.  “Alright, so I’m making it sound a bit mad.  But just because you’re above all that kind of stuff doesn’t mean it isn’t fun sometimes!”

She cleared her throat mock-importantly.  “Anyway, young lady – we were discussing a certain member of the male community, weren’t we.  How’s it going?”  She leaned across the table, eager to hear the latest.

Freya looked directly into Kate’s eyes for just a moment, hoping her friend would sense what she was thinking.  Best friends were supposed to have that kind of connection, weren’t they? 

“Really well, actually,” There was a hint of surprised defiance in Freya’s voice.  “I know it’s early days, but we’re getting on great so far.  I’ll just have to wait and see how it goes, I suppose…” She stopped, her cheeks flushing pink with self-consciousness.  Kate was looking at her in amused wonder.

“You’re such an enigma, Freya Jones.  In the years I’ve known you, I’ve told you all about every relationship I’ve had,  because you’re my best friend and the only one I can really talk to.  Now when you get a boyfriend for the first time, all you give me are a couple of tired old clichés you’d most probably hear around a boardroom table.”  She shook her head again, adopting a dramatically serious tone.  “Sometimes I really don’t feel like I know you very well at all.”

Freya bit back the urge to correct Kate over her supposed use of MI5-style secrecy, when in reality anyone who was willing to listen had received the exactly the same information as Freya had.  Kate was a naturally open and chatty person; it was those qualities that had drawn Freya to her since they’d met in a school drama production at the tender, awkward age of fifteen – Kate naturally as lead actress, Freya working on props behind the scenes.  Here was this girl who was so incredibly lively and pretty, who attracted everyone around her; so different from Freya that she could have been beamed down from another galaxy.  Freya always found it hard to believe that Kate could ever truly have wanted to be her friend. 

She shrugged her shoulders apologetically and took a swig of her coffee.   The strong sweetness hit her tastebuds and gave her a momentary kick.

“Don’t worry.  You will,” she said sincerely.

…………


Freya let out an exhausted sigh as she closed the door to her attic room.  It had been a long day, including a test which she’d aced as usual.   As convenient as she found her academic ease, she was frequently angry with herself for not making more of an effort with her studies. She wished she had a genuine interest in Chemical Science instead of studying it just because it had always seemed to come naturally to her, and of course because Dad had wanted her to.  Freya always did what her Dad wanted her to do.

She flopped down onto her bed in the darkness, half-tempted to go to sleep and forget the whole thing. Perhaps it would all just go away if she did nothing, and the downy quilt felt so soft and welcoming.  But she wouldn’t be able to rest – not properly – until she knew.  She sat up and switched on the dainty porcelain lamp next to her bed, bathing the tiny room in a haze of diaphanous light and casting eerily distorted shadows over its pristine, rose-patterned walls.  She was the only student she knew of who didn’t care for posters.

She’d sent Sean a text cancelling their date tonight, under the pretext that she was shattered. After all it wasn’t exactly a lie, and Sean would understand. 

Sean.  He’d asked her out three weeks ago and she’d accepted immediately because…well, it was the first time anyone had asked her out full stop and it hadn’t really occurred to her to say no.  Despite what she’d said to Kate that morning, so far they hadn’t seemed to have too much in common.  He was already starting to act as though he didn’t have much interest in her and Freya felt as though his proximity to her drained his vivacity away, for which she felt constant guilt.

She switched on the computer.  Waiting for her was an e-mail from Dad, a neat one-liner asking how she was.  Formality dripped from the screen; he could just as easily have been writing to a disliked work colleague as his only daughter.   Since he’d discovered the bounty of e-mail, she’d hardly spoken to Dad at all these days.  Too much information from her side would overwhelm him; she typed back a bland, nondescript reply before logging onto Kyra’s Facebook account.

Kate was online too.  She’d just changed her status, which now read “Kate is spending too much time on Facebook LOL”.

Freya felt herself moving into the anodyne comfort of Kyra’s fluffy world as she typed out an instant “chat message”.

“Hi matey!  Thanx 4 accepting my friend request, so what u up 2?”

She drummed her fingers on the wooden desk, awaiting Kate’s response.  If this went to plan, she’d find out all she needed to know this evening.  Then she would know exactly what she had to do. 

Kate’s reply pinged back almost instantly, “Lovely 2 hear from u!  I’m fine thanx, will b going out later for a few drinks, really lkng 4ward to it!”

Freya couldn’t help a wry smile as she read this; it was typical of Kate not to ask how she was. 

“U enjoy it!  Can b a drag sometimes with all that studying!” 

“2 right!  LOL!”

“I’m just spendin time with my luvly fiancé tonite – gettin married soon and I can’t wait!”

They chatted for two solid hours, Kyra enthralling Kate with tales of her modelling jobs and her upcoming wedding to her “luvly fiancé Ryan”.  Ryan was a model too, naturally, and he’d proposed to Kyra during a romantic weekend away in Rome (Paris was too clichéd).  Kyra herself came from a large, loving family with two younger sisters and an older brother, together with a Mum who also doubled up as a best friend and a Dad who owned a successful construction company, but who always had ample time for his idyllic family.  She was doing media studies at a different university and when she graduated she intended to work in television; there was no doubt she’d walk straight into a top job, with her looks and obvious talent.  It all came so naturally.  Freya could almost tangibly feel Kyra’s brightness, her happiness and lack of responsibility.  She was Kate’s equal, with the whole world willingly resting at her feet.

“So who u drinkin with 2nite then?  Hot date?”

“U could say that.   Layin low for a bit as he’s already got a girlf, but we’re crazy bout each other and will tell all soon”

“Sounds well romantic!  Wots his name?”

Kate’s reply came back instantly.

“(blush) It’s Sean”

There it was; cold hard proof that the text messages she’d accidentally seen on his phone two nights ago had not been a mistake.  Freya felt Kyra’s presence drifting slowly away from her, as if she’d been made of sand.

She’d known.  She’d always known.  But knowledge couldn’t stop her hands from trembling ever so slightly as she moved away from the computer, instinctively towards the white painted cabinet beside her bed. 

She could see the rest of her life playing out clearly before her in her mind, full of loneliness and warped comparison, and she knew it would always be the same.   There would always be a Kate or a Kyra in the background, or more appropriately in the foreground.  Someone beautiful, someone bright and beguiling who could talk to anyone and whom everybody wanted to be around.  Somebody who was genuinely loved and who knew how to love people back.  Freya would never, ever be able to compete with any of that, and in any case she wasn’t up to the task.  She couldn’t blame anybody but herself; after all who on Earth would want to spend any time with her when they could be with someone like Kate instead? 

Mechanically Freya opened the bedside cabinet.  They were hidden at the back, all those pills she’d been saving up for what had felt like centuries as she’d gradually hid them away, week after week, knowing the day would come; the day they would finally be put to use.  The bottle of vodka she’d hidden under her bed had come courtesy of her landlady’s drinks cabinet.  She’ll be the one to find me… the briefly rueful thought struck Freya… although that lush will most likely be more upset at the vodka disappearing.

She laid the pills out into neat, methodical lines on the top of the cabinet.  There must have been about eighty altogether, maybe a hundred.  She wasn’t counting, as long as there were enough. 

Everything prepared and in place, Freya felt a strange sense of calm.  Soon she would be forever released from the constant worry, the constant loneliness; she was going to a place where they wouldn’t be able touch her ever again.    She could hardly wait to taste that first sweet sip of the vanilla vodka.  Vanilla.   How appropriate.  Bland, boring; any other flavour preferable.

Freya updated Kyra’s Facebook status one last time.

“Kyra Collins is signing off.”

Then she switched off the computer.

Reviews
Hi Nina
Written by jean.day (2908 comments posted) 28th February 2009
Nice to see you back on the site.  
 
This was a rather sad story - and hopefully not one likely to be true. It took me awhile to get into it - not being a Facebook devotee. But once I got the drift - I became quite engrosed in the story.  
 
Freya (I was at a Signlanguage for Babies class with my grandson this last week and there were 2 baby Freyas in the group) who was smart, plain and shy - was somehow trying through manipulating her friend, Kate - who had no idea that her "friend Kyra" was really her friend Freya, to find out information regarding a date that she had (first one ever) which she then stupidly broke because she felt unequal to it. And in having her friend confirm that she was meeting a Sian (no doubt in her mind that it was the same one) she is so depressed she tries to commit suicide. 
 
Do I have it about right? 
 
The bit about the one line email from her father -who never really talked to her anymore - no doubt added to her feeling herself ready to quit life. 
 
It is so sad that there maybe really are people out there who feel like that.  
 
It was well written, of course, as all your work is.

Written by Leigh (410 comments posted) 4th March 2009
Hi Nina 
 
Great story as always. Very modern of course, being centred around Facebook. The reference to counting how many friends one has, and not knowing half of them in 'eral life,' really rang true! 
 
As Jean says, a very sad tale. There is a nicely sinister undercurrent running all the way through. You really made me detest the smug, 'pefect' Kate and feel so sorry for Freya. The cold, formal e-mail from her dad (does she have a mum?) was just heartbreaking. 
 
As soon as Kate mentions her hot date with somebody else's guy, I knew it would be Sean and felt a real "Oh now, poor Freya!" sense of impending doom. 
 
Leigh

Written by Phil (8763 comments posted) 7th March 2009
Even though I don't use any of the social networking sites, this drew me in. Well told, well written. I'd have liked a little more motivation for the suicide as that seemed a little weak to me - but never having been close to a suicide, I don't really know. 
 
Phil
Thank you
Written by Clifftown (701 comments posted) 15th March 2009
Jean, Leigh and Phil, for your comments. Jean, yes you had it about right!  
 
Much appreciated.
incredible writing ...
Written by johniebg (611 comments posted) 20th March 2009
What stuck: 
 
The writing is just wonderful, a great flow and easy to read. It easy to say but very difficult to do. Really easy to read and very visual. It kept me going through the few bits that didn't stick. 
 
The interactions between Freya and men were succinct and spot on. You knew her and the boyfriend straight away. Her and her dad, immediately. Great stuff. 
 
Fraya's character (apart from the end) was brilliant. The swat. I got a feel for her in every way other than physicality. I have only read it once so far. 
 
Above all the writing was jaw dropping good. 
 
So ... what did not stick. I really struggled in the first few paragraphs. I guess you wanted it to be a reveal that she had created the false identity but the way you have it really threw me because I was sitting there thinking why is she updating someone elses profile. You did not ease into the illusion. 
 
I personally don't think you need that reveal and could have made it clear (as you later did) that she had made up the profile at the beginning becasue the reader would immediately be thinking 'why?' which is the point of the story. My opinion. 
 
Her relationship with Kate was blurry to the point of being confusing. Interesting as you nailed her relationships with men so well. I can guess why but do not know. The best description of their relationship was at the end so do not know whether you tied yourself in knots avoiding saying what you did at the end through the rest of the story. It just did not work for me. 
 
The end: your have given us the Call Girl which I think was about a granny that did sex chat and was brilliant, you gave us the sex change woman/man that was so brilliant. Loads of other writing but ... 
 
It dawned on me as the end got closer that you were going the suicide route - it was awful. I was thinking this is Clifftown the girl will not commit suicide, she will do something else. She will take revenge, she will turn our percepton this will be suicide inside out and upside down. But you did not. 
 
At the end of the day you never gave us anything else that would cause her to commit suicide (if that was not what she did I missed it). The human brain likes life and will generally do everything it can to prevent your death. So suicide is in some way a mental breakdown and that takes a lot. So it would make more sense that this super intelligent human would consider suicide (as I think most of us have at some point if we are honest) and then imediately plot on some very cunning way of either changing herself and or getting back. Although getting back does not work because she did not really seem to care much for sean anyway. So changing herself, but then the ideal of into what becomes interesting. 
 
Hope I have not gone into too much detail, although I probably have. Only though because this was great, great writing let down (for me) by an unsubstantiated cliched end. 

Written by Fledermaus (4146 comments posted) 20th March 2009
Brilliant idea for a story and well worked out. Of course Freya wasn't right in the head anyhow and if it wasn't for this reason, she might have killed herself for another. 
I think it's absolutely great idea and I wonder if it does happen very often in reality. A friend of mine actually tried to play a similar game with me right here on GW, but she didn't keep it up and gave herself away. The endless possibilities of the internet...
JBG and Fledermaus...
Written by Clifftown (701 comments posted) 20th March 2009
...thank you very much for your comments. Much appreciated. Fledermaus - hope you and your friend are still friends! 
 
JBG - you've really made some interesting observations for which I thank you! The profile at the beginning wasn't supposed to be a reveal, as a reader it was intended for you to know straight from the off that Freya/Kyra were the same person. I've just read the first few paragraphs with that in mind and I must admit I can see how it could be confusing - thanks for pointing that out. 
 
Your observations about the ending were also interesting, especially your comment about the human brain liking life and that a super intelligent person may not ultimately go through with a suicide. From my own perspective (and this is just me!) a super intelligent person would be more likely to go through with a suicide because they would be more likely to realise how futile life can ultimately be. The most intelligent people I've ever known have also been some of the most depressive. But I thought your perspective a very interesting one, and I can definitely see how the ending can be viewed as cliched. Ironically I tried to end the story in the most non-cliched way I could think of! 
 
Thanks so much again for your comments.  
 
:)

Written by johniebg (611 comments posted) 20th March 2009
Very interesting. What makes people intelligent in an IQ sense and enables them to study effortlessly. Is an ability to process information. People like freya can store huge amounts of information very fast and accurately which often scores them high in IQ tests. This is usually down to their brains visual and object processing capacity over and above average brains.  
 
Their ability to process this information can impact their personalities because so much of their brain is given over to these functions. I read Einstein was such a character. It can often be that high IQ personalities sit either end of the spectrum: either super bubbly or introverted. However - what drives someone to suicide is usually driven by entirely different processes. It is very very seldom a whim. The brain just will not let you because everything you are is a resul of the brain. 
 
I hoped the story would end with her standing there and looking at the pills, knocking back a few vodka's and then picking each and every pill up and then writing a list about how she was going to change her life. I feel sure she writes lots of lists. And not so much change what she is because that cannot be, but who she is, is up for grabs still. 
 
I then also had an image I cannot get out of my head of Kate sitting on a park bench thirty something reviewing how life has knocked the edges off her (three kids) and finally having met her closest approximation of Prince Charming, which is of course a compromise. Because There being a moments reflection after seeing a blond smudge over by the swings recollects Freya. She cannot remember Seans name just that she had to have him. And that she often wondered what happened to Freya. And that she wishes she had a chance to apologise because she had envied freya a little (that came across in your story and maybe why she needed sean). 
 
Which is when we find out Freya used that moment to catapult her life onto what she is. She moved the next day with the pills flushed, with a hangover, doubled up on study wherever she ended up. And went on to live her own life. No better or worse than kate's but her own life. And a littlewiser. And she is in the park watching kate as she is sometimes prone to do when she is in because she attaches some symbolic significance to Kate and what happened. But the sad point at the end is not that one of them died, it is that they would get on now and have a lot to talk about. But never will. 
 
Anyway, that occured to me on the train on the way home. That it did is testament to the characters you created. Especially in Freya's relationship with the father. That created a whole back story with just a few words. 
 
As for the cliche - teen gets depressed after best friend steals boyfriend and contemplates suicide?  
 
 
 

   Only registered users can rate and write comments.
   Please login or register.

Powered by AkoComment 2.0!

 Previous item   Next item