Great Writing - Home > Stories > Saying goodbye
Shorts
Saying goodbye
By red-sauce
15 April 2009
Im not sure that this allows the depth of character that I was after, whether you actually feel anything for them, I think it is a bit too distant. I was wondering what others felt

She is small in his arms. Looking across him, a black cord is tangled in the black spirals of hair that dusts his chest. Breathing in his scent so that she can keep it with her after he has gone. He will go he always does. His eyelashes are low, he scans her from above smiling is silent satisfaction. She is dreading the sigh he will shortly exhale. It is coming, she knows that, but she tries to push it to the back of her mind. Taking in every sense of this moment her hands brush down his naked skin feeling every imperfection that makes him who he is.

The heady smell of them fills the room, it feels hot against their bodies. She wants to shake it off and feel light again. To smooth away the wrinkles that adorn the relationship so that it is pure. It can't be done though. Even hidden in their own private bubble the real world continues to push against the sides threatening to burst it.

He moves to look at her properly. Bringing his hand to brush a stray hair away from her face so that he can gaze into her eyes without distraction. It feels like an invisible bolt connects them through the look that they give each other. So much that they want to say without any real need to say it. Eyes give away so much, the love, passion and happiness is tinged with the guilt and longing that being together brings. Their emotions always seem so acute just before they part. Everything that is bottled up normally bubbles to the surface yet neither wants to break the spell and bring themselves back to earth.

It has to be broken, he shifts slightly to look at his watch causing her to squeeze her eyes shut. Kissing her forehead he moves away from her causing cold air to rush against her chest raising goosebumps against her flesh. She watches him move towards his clothes, a routine that she had become used to. She pulls the covers over her head to block it out and he sighs deeply turning away from her. It seems like only moments ago that he had knocked on the door. Time has its own rules when they are together.

When she lifts her head out of the covers he is slotting his cuff links through his shirt. He shoots her a look full of remorse and slowly strides back to the bed. The mattress sinks under his weight causing her body to roll towards him. He apologizes, makes his promises, she listens and it feels better. They had both been thinking the same, the fact that soon he would be in someone else's arms always made saying goodbye that much harder. She knew that he would have to get her scent off him, that he would have to shake himself back into everyday life, a life that didn't include her. She would have to close her mind to it all. The idea would always be worse than the reality. They would see each other soon, both would count the moments until they did.

She got out of bed and dragged her dress over her head. She always tried to do this as quickly as she could. It was almost as though putting clothes on signified the bursting of the bubble and stepping back into who they were. He looked almost alien in his suit, gone was the vulnerability of a few moments before. They left the room together, holding hands to to door.

The goodbye was quick, no kisses in case they were seen. Tears burned at her eyes as she walked away from him, unable to look back and see the pain on his face. It wouldn't be long till they had to do it all again.

Reviews

Written by Mr_E_Writer (466 comments posted) 15th April 2009
Hi, sauce. 
 
It is always difficult, with this type of story, to feel empathy for “them” when there is another (or others) who are possibly/probably more deserving of our empathy and sympathy. 
 
The writing was okay but you need to look at some of your punctuation and grammar. 
 
A couple of examples: So much that they want to say without any real need to say it. 
This is a bit of a non-sentence without “There is”. 
There is so much that they want to say.... 
 
“She is small in his arms. Looking across him, a black cord is tangled in the black spirals of hair that dusts his chest. Breathing in his scent so that she can keep it with her after he has gone. He will go he always does." 
 
Here, the “ Breathing in his scent...” is, again, a non-sentence. 
Black cord and black spirals grate in their repetition. 
The plurals “Spirals” and “Dusts” also grate. 
 
Alternative punctuation: She is small in his arms. Looking across him. A black cord tangled in the spirals of hair that dust his chest as she breathes in his scent; that she might keep it with her when he is no longer there. He will go, he always does.  
 
However, it's only one blokes opinion. Others may diagree. 
Regards. 
Eric.

Written by red-sauce (38 comments posted) 15th April 2009
Thank you. I changed the punctuation in this because someone has commented that i often use a repetitive structure. I was trying really hard to do something different. I thought that the quick 'non-sentences' would improve the pace but I agree I may well have gone too far with it.

Written by Bottleblondesurfer (5077 comments posted) 15th April 2009
Firstly I would echo Eric's point about empathy. 
 
I can't really fault the style of the writing. It was vivid and economical. It was also well paced, keeping the reader engaged, but I must admit I did find it a bit 'distant' and despite the situation it was a bit emotionally flat. For me the problem was the use of 3rd person:- 
"She watches.." 
"She pulls..." 
"He shifts.." 
It was all 'tell' and no 'show' You were telling us how she was feeling rather than showing us and making us feel it to. It was being related to us in an oddly measured way. 
I'm not saying the emotion wasn't there, it just didn't jump off the page. 
Consequently the depth of character was not fully realised. Character is revealed in dialogue and action and as this was being related to us you lost one of those devices. 
I hope I don't sound negative. It was a beautifully lyrical bit of writing. I was just trying to address your concerns 
cheers 
jane

Written by red-sauce (38 comments posted) 15th April 2009
I agree, with you thank you. I did feel it was distant and wasn't really sure about how to change that. I dont often write in third person, which I think caused me some problems, I think using the comments I have had on other submissions along with this I havent got the balance quite right yet. Ta 
 
(you didnt sound negative at all, it was really helpful)

Written by Snodlander (531 comments posted) 15th April 2009
I agree with Eric. Additionally, you tend to miss out commas. An example would be -  
Kissing her forehead he moves away from her causing cold air to rush against her chest raising goosebumps against her flesh. 
 
Grammar apart, this is more of a vignette than a plotted story, so it's difficult to judge character anyway. The old adage, 'show not tell' means it's generally much better to describe character through dialogue and action. There are a couple of places where you tell us what she is feeling and thinking, rather than allowing the reader to make up his own mind. 
 
That said, you've done a good job of tryng to get under the skin of the other woman. I'm not sure I would be that good at that, my puritan morals interfering with my empathy. 
 
I wonder if he feels the same? It's very much her viewpoint, and her interpretation of what he's feeling. You could give the whole thing a twist by having him say or do something that subtly betrays his true feelings (looking at his watch during a kiss, boasting to a friend in a text message) (Look, give me a break, I'm shooting from the hip here) 
 
Hope that helps

Written by red-sauce (38 comments posted) 15th April 2009
I guess that was the point, trying to show the 'other womans' perspective. I also can see what you are saying about betraying his true feelings but I dont think I would have his true feelings as being that he didnt want to be with her. 
 
Yeah, in other writing I have felt that I use commas too much so I guess that I was trying not to meaning I missed them when they were required.

Written by tjgibbons (20 comments posted) 18th April 2009
I don't have a lot to say about this, mainly because I read it for enjoyment than to comment on it. 
I don't think the characters are particularly (sp) distant, it shows how they are really only joined physically I think, so it works well for that aspect of the story. 
 
Really enjoyed it, and I really sympathise with her. 
 
-Tris

   Only registered users can rate and write comments.
   Please login or register.

Powered by AkoComment 2.0!

 Previous item   Next item