The terrifying territory of 'free verse' - apart from the three-line blocks.
A totally true story - which is why, I think, it's too long and rambling.
Can anyone help me cut it to the quick, as it were?
Cheers, tears and beers. John X
Dust to Ashes
My Dad was always out-of-doors,
gardening in green gumboots.
He loved the rain.
"It makes things grow." he told me
when I was too young to know,
too green to question. I nodded wisely.
We stand at my father's graveside,
the funeral is ten days gone.
My mother shakes.
The vicar holds him in a small brown box
while the sextant digs a fourteen-inch-square hole.
The delay fills the air with embarrassment and birdsong.
"The soil's dry for this time of year."
my gardener brother says.
"Dry as bones." the vicar agrees.
My mother shakes again.
This time, with grief or giggles,
I cannot say. I squeeze her hand, limp, moist.
"Dust to dust." the vicar intones,
but you were more than dust.
'Damp to damp.' would be more apt.
"Ashes to ashes." the vicar drones on,
but you were more than ashes.
'Mud to mud.' would be better.
Why so dry in his rehearsed solemnity?
Is he afraid my father might get wet?
My Dad loved the rain.
|
Written by Phil (8698 comments posted) 31st May 2009 | Lovely bit of narrative. Not sure what you could cut to shorten/distil as the tale is yours and only you know the important parts. Only one thing sprang to mind: 'slime to slime' has other connotations besides rain sodden. Perhaps deliberate - but the rest of this seems full of fond memories and that small phrase turns it around. Phil | Nail on Head! Written by Katanga (4072 comments posted) 31st May 2009 | Thanks Phil - yes, that one was bugging me. My Dad wasn't a 'slime ball', so I've changed it. Still not happy with the 'damp' word . . . Ah, well . . . Cheers! John | cut to the quick Written by fellpony (2846 comments posted) 1st June 2009 | I would not normally re-write a piece but you asked for help so here's some suggestions. I don't think I've left anything out other than the gumboots, but making things grow tells of the gardening, so I thought it might still work? I've added one word and changed one in the last but one stanza. Dust to Ashes My Dad loved the rain. "It makes things grow," he told me when I was too green to question. We stand now at his graveside, the funeral ten days gone. The vicar holds him in a small brown box. My mother shakes. The sexton digs a fourteen-inch-square hole. "The soil's dry for this time of year," my gardener brother says. "Dry as bones," says the vicar and my mother shakes again, with grief or giggles, I cannot say. I squeeze her hand, limp, moist. "Dust to dust," intones the vicar, but you were more than dust. "Ashes to ashes," he drones, but you were more than ashes. Too dry, unfruitful, his solemn practised phrases. My Dad loved the rain.
| hi Katanga Written by silvershoes (458 comments posted) 1st June 2009 | I really liked this. I don't think it needs to much changing, and I liked the three-line structure (is that a tercet, she says, showing off wildly!) It gives it that some strucutre within the free verse. And I quite liked the damp to damp echoing the dust to dust.
| Written by PurplePyro7 (366 comments posted) 1st June 2009 | Personally I really liked it, it isn't too long. And I loved: The vicar holds him in a small brown box while the sextant digs a fourteen-inch-square hole. The delay fills the air with embarrassment and birdsong. "The soil's dry for this time of year." my gardener brother says. "Dry as bones." the vicar agrees. There's a heavy atmosphere about it, and the smalltalk adds to this. With regards to the 7th and 8th parts/blocks, I would cut the last lines and put them together, as Sue has demonstrated. I think that speaks louder than having those lines included, and it also makes the last three lines a lot more effective. A sad poem, but really well done PP7 | Many thanks! Written by Katanga (4072 comments posted) 1st June 2009 | to Phil, Sue, Emma and PP7 for your comments above. Especially to Sue, for a 'dead-quick' rewrite which gets rid of the dross. I am tempted to repost in haste - but I'm going to take some time out to ponder on this one . . . Thanks again to you all . . . John X | And Doh! Written by Katanga (4072 comments posted) 1st June 2009 | 'sextant' / 'sexton'?! How embarrassing! I must get my gear into arse! Humble John X | Written by wendycat (2180 comments posted) 2nd June 2009 | Hi John, This is really nicely done. You have let the narrative lead and in doing so have skilfully created a poem that is emotional without being over bearing. I've PM'd you with a couple of ideas. Enjoyed. Wendy X | Thanks, Wendy! Written by Katanga (4072 comments posted) 2nd June 2009 | New version coming later I hope! John X | Written by Bottleblondesurfer (5054 comments posted) 2nd June 2009 | Very nice indeed. With your prolific rate of production it is easy to miss the real gems when they come and this is a real little gem, Beautifully understated and full of real sentiment, but what lifts it for me the use of subtext. I don't know why poets ignore its use. It allows the reader to engage with the work on a personal level and makes it so much more than the some of its parts. If I have a quibble, it is 'Damp to damp'. It didn't say much to me. But don't change to much of it. You don't want to spoil it cheers jane | Written by grettle (59 comments posted) 21st February 2010 | | I think this wonderful. | Grettle! Written by Katanga (4072 comments posted) 21st February 2010 | Many thanks! Just out of interest, did you find this in the 'blue box' column on the left of the home page? I often wonder where reviews of older picees come from, that's all! This one has been edited since - I'll send you the final version, if you like? Cheers! John |
Only registered users can rate and write comments. Please login or register. Powered by AkoComment 2.0! |