|
Cool Written by steve666 (50 comments posted) 27th April 2006 |
Short, sweet, complete. Great work. |
Thanks Steve Written by BrianRobertNeal (1195 comments posted) 27th April 2006 |
Now my youngest is 21 I can relax. But the thought of losing a child is the one thing I could have never have survived. Though I wrote it, the piece still makes very emotional. Brian. |
i'm a little dense, but... Written by robokent (84 comments posted) 28th April 2006 |
...after a couple of reads, I got the piece. Wow, very well done. I liked the little nuances you pulled off in the short work: the comment about the nativity play being replaced by the 'winter fun show', for example. Re-reading it, I see how the octopus is really any parent, who maybe never has enough arms to hug his/her child with, always wanting to keep that child tightly within their folds... great imagery... |
Emotional Written by Bottleblondesurfer (3590 comments posted) 28th April 2006 |
I must say no parent could read this without getting a little lump in the throat. You say so much in so few words. Just wanted to say I loved it BBS |
Thanks Rob+BBS Written by BrianRobertNeal (1195 comments posted) 28th April 2006 |
When it is "heart on sleeve stuff". it is really great to get it across to others. So thank you both for your kind words, Brian. |
Loved it Written by misscontrary (17 comments posted) 28th April 2006 |
A totally unexpected twist at the end which made me catch my breath. Very effective. Simply told but with a punch more powerful because of it. Superb Mary xx |
Thanks Mary Written by BrianRobertNeal (1195 comments posted) 28th April 2006 |
Footnote. Xmas 2004, I bought the Octopus as a "Stocking present" for my wife. She agreed with me that the facial expression reminded her of our youngest son, who's now 21. I took a digital photgraph and printed out. I put the photograph on the Octopus, the story seemed to come from nowhere. Thanks for your time and comment, I'll kep an eye out for your next posting. Brian. |
Sour puss? Written by gerardconnolly (1186 comments posted) 30th April 2006 |
Sorry to have taken so long to get round to this after you specifically asked me. I suppose it was a short story and I certainly enjoyed reading it as it was, as always, very competantly written. Also I had no trouble getting it first time as some of your other readers did. I find single short pieces are ideal for that one off emotional appeal and I thought you did that exceptionally well. Given an emphatically positive response, not to mention that of others I am left wondering why it did not really pull up any trees in my garden. I suspect this is because it was not perhaps not meant to. Also I felt it may have lacked a context which left me wondering what it was for beyond a good piece of writing. Not that there is anything amiss with that as a goal. Indeed there are rather too many for whom that in itself would be a blessing to be welcomed. Maybe I have come to look for more in your writing than you sometimes intend. Which probably says more about me than it does this piece and therefore a signal to sign off. Again well done. Eight out of tentickles using present government target guidelines. [ Key Stage Two] Slainte! |
Ta GC Written by BrianRobertNeal (1195 comments posted) 30th April 2006 |
At least you can be bothered to read and comment, for which I am grateful. Brian.
|
through the wringer.. Written by woody44 (777 comments posted) 30th April 2006 |
Quite an emotional piece Brian, which did not descend into something maudling or crass. My wife and I are fairly recent grandparents and whenever I look at Luke his innocence makes my heart sing. To try and put oneself in the position of a parent who has lost a child is, I think, impossible. Well done... happy writing... |
Thanks Woody Written by BrianRobertNeal (1195 comments posted) 30th April 2006 |
When my eldest was in the Construction Industry I was in constant fear for his well being. I wrote a story called "After the Fall" in which I tried to come to terms with the possibility of him suffering a fatal injury. I am an obsessive parent and have written several "emotional" pieces focussed on children, their hopes and dreams. I'll keep an eye out for your next piece so I can say a proper thank you. Brian |
Written by jean.day (2387 comments posted) 30th April 2006 |
| I liked this very much. The emotional bits were subtle and much more effective for being like that. You know I have come to change my image of you over the last few months since you have come back on the site. I remember you saying before that you needed to put more of yourself into your wriiting - and I think maybe you are doing that now. |
Hello Jean Written by BrianRobertNeal (1195 comments posted) 30th April 2006 |
Thanks for your time and comments. You've certainly stopped me "in my tracks". BBS commented that she could not believe that the same person wrote Mea Morphic and Am Drams. I think I have a wider range of styles than most. At one time I'd use the Alter Ego-Cynic Sid, to try to keep the serious side of me away from the silly. I'm always trying out new (for me that is.) approaches to writing. Brian. |
Non parent but still liked Written by alastair79 (47 comments posted) 2nd May 2006 |
As a non-parent this probably didn't have the same impact on me as some of the other people, but it is still a fantastically well crafted short and is one of the best things I have read on here so far. Alastair. |
Thanks Alistair. Written by BrianRobertNeal (1195 comments posted) 2nd May 2006 |
Would you believe that this story was slated on another web-site. This is a "heart on sleeve story" and it is a delight to be able to touch others and get a positive response. Brian. |
Only registered users can rate and write comments.
Please login or register.