|
| READING ROOM | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|
|
| COMMUNITY | |||
|---|---|---|---|
|
| ABOUT GREAT WRITING | ||
|---|---|---|
|
| WORK AWAITING REVIEW |
|---|
|
| GW IS... |
|---|
|
Great Writing creative writing community is designed to prompt ideas
and provide inspiration and motivation within aspiring and amateur
authors. Whatever your topic; from love poetry to Doctor Who or Harry
Potter fan fiction, Great Writing's online writing group is where you
can make new friends and improve your creative writing. |
| WHO'S ONLINE |
|---|
| We have 906 guests online and 2 members online |
| print friendly version | |
| Criticism of critics' critiques | |
| By patterjack | ||||||||
| 05 May 2006 | ||||||||
|
After teaching creative writing for some years I have personally given up writing critiques To do any work real justice requires an in depth analysis , not a Hooray ...but or even a But .... hooray This , I am sure you will understand, is meant as light verse Beauty in language ,Empson emphasised ( and for this remark he's been strongly criticised ) depends on the depths of its ambiguity. Now William was a man of perspicuity, tracing a long and truly tortuous way through all the things that poets want to say. For unconsciously , the poet may reveal more than intended, and therefore his appeal may lie for some readers in what he should delete were he to attempt to avoid the indiscreet . For a critic to evaluate a poet's verse may well result (and there is nothing worse !) in a long involved discussion so compounded as to leave the reader's confusion worse confounded . Does the poet take the reader smoothly with him On lines that clearly develop the proper rhythm (See just above !) , Does he always have perfect rhyme ? Does his metre follow strict metronomic time ? But let's face it , let's get the question pat -- Critics need to ask What's meant by that ? And there , in sweet reason or in rage , Those critics could fill up page upon page upon page upon page upon page But like it or lump it -- it's there on the page for all and as a result not easy to recall
And in the end , ( and I think that we all know it )
Only registered users can rate and write comments. Powered by AkoComment 2.0! |
||||||||
|
|
Next item
|
|---|