Great Writing - Home > Poetry > Criticism of critics' critiques
READING ROOM
Great Writing - Home
Read and review others' work
Articles on writing
Advice from the community
COMMUNITY
Talk to others in the forums
Events and Competitions
GW News
ABOUT GREAT WRITING
All About Us
Contact Us
WORK AWAITING REVIEW
GW IS...
Great Writing creative writing community is designed to prompt ideas and provide inspiration and motivation within aspiring and amateur authors. Whatever your topic; from love poetry to Doctor Who or Harry Potter fan fiction, Great Writing's online writing group is where you can make new friends and improve your creative writing.
WHO'S ONLINE
We have 906 guests online and 2 members online
Poetry
Criticism of critics' critiques
By patterjack
05 May 2006
After teaching creative writing for some years I have personally given up writing critiques

To do any work real justice requires an in depth analysis , not a Hooray ...but or even a But .... hooray

This , I am sure you will understand, is meant as light verse


Beauty in language ,Empson emphasised
( and for this remark he's been strongly criticised )
depends on the depths of its ambiguity.
Now William was a man of perspicuity,
tracing a long and truly tortuous way
through all the things that poets want to say.
For unconsciously , the poet may reveal
more than intended, and therefore his appeal
may lie for some readers in what he should delete
were he to attempt to avoid the indiscreet .
For a critic to evaluate a poet's verse
may well result (and there is nothing worse !)
in a long involved discussion so compounded
as to leave the reader's confusion worse confounded .
Does the poet take the reader smoothly with him
On lines that clearly develop the proper rhythm

(See just above !) , Does he always have perfect rhyme ?
Does his metre follow strict metronomic time ?
But let's face it , let's get the question pat --
Critics need to ask What's meant by that ?
And there , in sweet reason or in rage ,
Those critics could fill up page upon page upon page upon page upon page
But like it or lump it -- it's there on the page for all
and as a result not easy to recall

And in the end , ( and I think that we all know it )
A poet is a poet is a poet

Reviews
Do it justice
Written by Bottleblondesurfer (3590 comments posted) 5th May 2006
I think to really do this justice I shall say absolutely nothing about it.  
BBS 
A critic is just a failed writer......but sadly so are most writers!
Criticism? No, praise
Written by Josie (2849 comments posted) 5th May 2006
Oooh! You were getting a bit carried away with the title - but you got up and going really well on the rhyme and rhythm - - - - well to start with. The answer to your question is: Yes the writer carries the reader with him on the lines of rhyme and rhythm, but when it goes wrong - oh dear! Look, I write for children, and they definitely know if something is going wrong. They have told me: We don't like "strange" poems, ha ha. When I asked them what means "strange" they said: Poems that don't rhyme. ha ha. Of course, they have only just been weaned away from Baa Baa Rainbow Sheep, have you any wool? I don't think a critic is a failed writer, but I don't like upsetting anyone with my criticisms. I'd rather not say anything than upset them.

Written by B.D. (82 comments posted) 1st June 2006
I love the rhythm!! After reading this, I understand what you meant earlier about not criticising work. No criticism. Great!

   Only registered users can rate and write comments.
   Please login or register.

Powered by AkoComment 2.0!

 Previous item   Next item