READING ROOM
Great Writing - Home
Read and review others' work
Articles on writing
Advice from the community
COMMUNITY
Talk to others in the forums
Events and Competitions
GW News
ABOUT GREAT WRITING
All About Us
Contact Us
WORK AWAITING REVIEW
GW IS...
Great Writing creative writing community is designed to prompt ideas and provide inspiration and motivation within aspiring and amateur authors. Whatever your topic; from love poetry to Doctor Who or Harry Potter fan fiction, Great Writing's online writing group is where you can make new friends and improve your creative writing.
WHO'S ONLINE
We have 1367 guests online and 5 members online
Shorts
Thumbelina
By gutterkitty
08 July 2006
Written after a meeting at Brasenose college, Oxford.

   The girls spin around the quad like catherine wheels. I have never been a fan of children, but as the sunlight embraces the yellow stone of the college buildings, square around the carefully tended grass, I am aware that something beautiful is unfolding itself. Like a Thumbelina in jeans and t-shirt and trainers I am born in the centre of a new flower, and open unused eyes onto the scene.
   The pastor on the bench beside me waits for me to ask questions about Theology. He is not as old as I expected him to be. I am not sure why I leant so heavily on a cliché; he is young and friendly but distracted in a way I would not expect a teacher figure to be. Instead of asking me questions and filling the space with answers, he watches the two girls play and waits for me to speak in a manner which does not expect me to. I look at the parting to one side of his hair, the light playing off the strands that meet. He tells me that the girl in the white dress, Portia, was the child christened today. People speak and smile with different accents as they mill out of the church that stands strong against the left side of the quad. I watch the girls as they run across the edge of the grass, thinking that they are the only people allowed to set their feet upon it. They are too small, with their tiny white-stockinged feet, to crush the grass teeming from the earth. 
   His white collar has been pushed to one side. It says, I am off duty. Nevertheless a woman in pink with matching hat and an American accent thanks him and he smiles and nods. Without thinking, I turn and do the same. I ask some questions, attempting to retain conversation whilst still remaining aware of this moment, the way the bench and grass and old stone buildings seem to tingle beneath my skin. I know that I will write this down, that this moment will be framed by words and set on the wall inside my mind. A long gallery that stretches back to my first story when I was five. It was a page long, about a mother who lost her ducklings. I was so proud. Now I can see that it was simply a cliché, like the picture of an old, stiff man with greying hair and ironed trousers that I had held in my hands a few minutes before.
   The second girl circles the quad in a white dress kissed with red flowers. I see her black buckled shoes. Our conversation drifts in and out lazily like a wave. This man is busy. He has a wedding to perform this afternoon, and is answering my questions as a favour to my sister. I remember him. He was the pastor at her wedding. I recognized the embroidered robes that he held over one arm after the christening. He has round golden glasses. I see his buckled shoes.
   The sun begins to fade. I tell him, somewhat self-conciously, that I haven't any more questions to ask him. He nods. "That's good." I laugh. "But I want to study Theology. I thought the point was to ask questions." He says, yes, though he does not have any answers after eight years of study. I offer him an answer that has likely been used many a time before, wrapped in self-concious brown paper, tied with string: I say that answering questions is not the object of theology- the point is to keep asking them. He agrees, looks out across the quad. The stone is grey without the sun's touch. As he leads me back through the gardens, the courtyards, the staircases, I think to myself that I may never meet him again. I remember how sad it is to meet someone you know instinctively that you will like, but at the same time are aware that they will not be a part of your life. I roll the cliché around in my mind and discard it on the grass, rolling it away like a cricket ball. I can't hear the little girls' squeals any more.

Reviews
Hi GK
Written by BrianRobertNeal (1195 comments posted) 10th July 2006
To make it an easier read try, 
 
Spacing the paragraphs. 
 
And perhaps breaking the larger paragraphs into smaller chunks. 
 
(You can edit your work by going to "View my existing work-select the piece to be edited, edit it than save.) 
 
Your writing is very metaphsical. Your allusions are sometimes obscure: 
 
"wrapped in self-concious brown paper"  
 
I also wonder how many people know who and what Thumbelina was? H.C.Anderson is not not as widely read as he once was. 
 
You seesaw between reported and direct speech-something I do, but not as often as I use to. It is probably better to stick to one or the other. 
 
This piece and some of your poems seem to be attempts to bubble wrap very personal moments and preserve them for ever. 
 
This is not meant to be in any way perjorative, for you have so many valid things to say but I feel that at times you lock you reader out. You should try to make your writing more "accessible". 
 
A simple step would be to make it more "eye friendly", and easier to scan. 
 
thank you for your review, 
 
Brian 
 
Fabulous
Written by mishmish (389 comments posted) 31st July 2006
I thoroughly enjoyed reading this so much... 
 
The way your writing flows, it feels like I looking at a masterpiece unfold before me...I am very, very impressed. 
 
Your imagery, your descriptions are just wonderful. I especially liked the line: 
 
I know that I will write this down, that this moment will be framed by words and set on the wall inside my mind. A long gallery that stretches back to my first story when I was five.  
 
For some reason, I felt very connected to this piece. I'm a 'continual writer' as I think you are too, and I write down things that cross my life, either in poetry or story form. Sometimes it cathartic, sometimes it's just a great way to capture the moment in that 'gallery of the mind'.  
 
Thanks for a really lovely piece of first rate writing... 
 
best wishes 
 
mishmish 
 
Absorbed
Written by eloquentdukewilson (38 comments posted) 7th November 2006
Several descriptions that had to be chewed slowly to be truly digested - very, very good. This wasn't a read, but an experience which I was allowed, thanks to your style, to take at my own pace.
And . . .
Written by eloquentdukewilson (38 comments posted) 7th November 2006
What are catherine wheels?

Written by peeano1 (86 comments posted) 20th November 2006
I have to ask the same question as eloquentdukewilson. What are catherine wheels? As for the story, it flows very well and was very "moralrifical", if that's ever a word. Good job and keep on trying! :)

Written by gutterkitty (362 comments posted) 21st November 2006
Thanks eloquentdukewilson and peeano1. I'm glad you enjoyed it. Catherine wheels are a kind of firework which spin in circles on the ground when you set them off. I apologise for not clarifying- I grew up with them, and therefore presumed that everyone else had too! Now peeano you can answer my question: what does "moralrifical" mean?

   Only registered users can rate and write comments.
   Please login or register.

Powered by AkoComment 2.0!

 Previous item   Next item