Great Writing - Home > Short S. > A Fairytale of New York
READING ROOM
Great Writing - Home
Read and review others' work
Articles on writing
Advice from the community
COMMUNITY
Talk to others in the forums
Events and Competitions
GW News
ABOUT GREAT WRITING
All About Us
Contact Us
WORK AWAITING REVIEW
GW IS...
Great Writing creative writing community is designed to prompt ideas and provide inspiration and motivation within aspiring and amateur authors. Whatever your topic; from love poetry to Doctor Who or Harry Potter fan fiction, Great Writing's online writing group is where you can make new friends and improve your creative writing.
WHO'S ONLINE
We have 1766 guests online and 4 members online
Shorts
A Fairytale of New York
By Bottleblondesurfer
16 August 2006
I thought I’d pinch Leo’s trick of writing a story round a song title. I’ve gone a step further and incorporated song lyrics into it, I hope it works. I had an ending worked out but the character changed it


 
From his window George Kinsella could see absolutely nothing, until he opened both eyes. It had become a little superstitious ritual with him. He watched the retreating back of the postman. There was no reason why to day should be different but he was a victim of hope. He sighed and looked up to see a cold grey autumn sky with no warmth or welcome in it. He needed to get back to his happy place.  George heard the door open and turned to see a large lemon yellow raincoat: that held no warmth or welcome in it either. His wife was talking to him but he was slipping back into his happy place
                       //We stepped hand in hand down Broadway
                      like the first men on The moon//
“George, Will you stop humming that damn song and listen to me. Put your jacket on or we’ll be late for church”. He took the jacket from her. “I hoped I’d heard the last of that song when I threw out the CD”
 
It didn’t matter that Kitty had thrown it out; he knew it by heart. It was the last thing that Helen had given him before she left. When Helen told her parents she was going to New York it was not well received.
“No daughter of mine is going to that Godless heathen place”
“Mum, it’s not that bad. Look, I’m not asking permission. You’re not talking me out of this one”
“Father Howley said no good will come of it…. George, you say something”
 But he didn’t, what was the point? In fact since Helen had gone he said less and less.
It was two years since she had left. Despite the acrimonious parting she had promised to write and George refused to give up hope.
 
“You blame me for her going, I know you do” Kitty often said.
“No I don’t, of course I don’t” He did blame her, though, but not just her; her and God or at least his representative Fr Howley who saw sin and depravity everywhere. He despaired of the influence the man had over Kitty.
George closed the window and struggled with the jacket. He was in no hurry to get to church. He seemed to spend all his time there now.
                // We tipped our hats to Mr Cohen
                Dear old Times Square’s favourite bard//
A loud voice crashed into his happy place.
 “And before you ask there was no post”, Kitty shouted from outside the room.
 
 He loved that song with all its references to New York. It seemed such an exotic and romantic place, especially as his beloved Helen was there. It felt like a link with her. He could understand her wanting to leave. He sometimes wondered why he stayed but when love goes it’s your insecurities that bind you together. He really missed his daughter. She was the only person he had unconditionally loved. If he had spoiled her as Kitty and Fr Howley claimed he could not bring himself to regret it.
 
 Kitty came storming back into the room. He was convinced she could read his mind.
“Do you think I don’t miss her too? You think it’s just you.”
“ Hang on, did I say anything?”
 “You always used to side with her. I had to do the discipline while you two just joked and whispered……  “
“We should go and visit her” He said it more to stop the familiar rant than with any hope.
“How can I go with my feet, you know well”
“They get you to church everyday”
“It’s a terrible place. We’d be mugged or killed”
“Eleven million people manage to survive it”
“And anyway we don’t even know where she lives”
“There’s that contact address. I could write again”
“Oh, there’s no point, they  won't know”
“Well we could ask…..…How do you know that?”
“You know her always flitting about…….
George stopped listening. He knew is wife, with an awful realisation he said,
“She’s written, she’s bloody written she has hasn’t she?”.
 Kitty realised she had made a mistake but was full of righteous indignation.
“Those letters weren’t fit to be read, full of filth and depravity. Fr Howley agreed…
“The bloody priest has seen them and I haven’t. How many for God’s sake?”
“And the language!, And the goings on in that terrible Godless place. Fr Howley said I should burn them”.
 “Who were they written to? Tell me that” George cut in.
“You would not believe the wickedness. You don’t know the half of it.”
“I had a right to see them. She’s not a bad girl”
“You were always too lax with her, spoiled her. She should have written to me. A girl should be close to her mother”
“So if she had written to you, you wouldn’t have burned them?”
“Don’t you get clever with me” Kitty shouted
 
 George turned away. He knew these arguments were pointless. He might have the moral high ground but she had the church and female logic. He needed to be alone in his happy place more than ever. He walked towards the door.
 “Where are you going, we’ll be late for church?”
“I’m going to the shed instead. I just need to think” He walked out of the room.
“You imagine I don’t know what you get up to in there, thinking indeed!”
He slammed the door.
“You’ll go straight to hell, George Kinsella”
“I hope they’ve got a sign or I won’t know the difference”, he shouted with more defiance that he felt.

 
 
He heard the front door slam as he slumped down on the bench. This was his territory.  In the dark of the shed he allowed himself to grieve. The letter burning was the last straw for him. Helen had kept contact but Kitty had got in the way. That’s how she always got her way. He was so tired of her getting in the way.

 
Despite her bluster Kitty had felt some remorse. She had decided to allow him some time to himself, always the best way.  She’d had a long chat with Fr Howley after church and spent the evening with her good friend Mary Driscoll. She now felt vindicated and decided she may as well tell him everything. He’d see it her way after he knew the truth.
 
 She was irritated to see he was still in the shed after all this time. She didn’t like going in there. It was so male and ungodly; an annexe of hell in her holy garden. But this couldn’t wait; “Now you come out of there, you hear. I’ve things you need to hear. It’s important”
                       //And we raised a glass in Central Park
                       And a dozen more besides//
 George was oblivious; lost  in his own world. He felt at peace.
The shed door burst open and Kitty’s head appeared in the doorway.
A loud booming voice crashed into his happy place.
 
“Will all passengers for flight KLG 132 to New York please make your way to gate 7”. George jumped up, stretched and picked up his holdall. He’d never owned a suitcase.  It had caused a problem at check-in as to whether it was luggage or flight baggage. He made his way to gate 7, feeing a childish excitement.  He was going to see all those famous, wonderful places and he would find Helen, somehow. He was sure of that because he wouldn’t stop looking till he did.
       //And the black bird broke the silence and he whistled it so sweet.

        And in Brendan Behan’s footsteps we skipped down 42nd street.//
He was going to see what his happy place was really like.

 
 

Reviews
A Fairytale of New York
Written by Buchan (42 comments posted) 16th August 2006
A very unique story. I liked the song titles, very new and different(Just my opinion,not a fact) I liked the whole story. Well I feel like George making my way to Gate 7. 
So many feelings of hope and love and romance and of course just life. Well written I enjoyed the read. Thank You.
Hi BBS.
Written by BrianRobertNeal (1195 comments posted) 16th August 2006
So here "HE" is, as promised/threatened? 
 
Try moving  
 
//And we raised a glass in Central Park 
And a dozen more besides// 
 
so that it sits between 
 
...... A loud booming voice crashed into his happy place 
 
//And we raised a glass in Central Park 
And a dozen more besides// 
 
“Will all passengers for flight KLG 132 ...... 
 
To me it seems to read better and makes more impact-just a thought. 
 
A thoroughly good read, 
 
Brian 
 
 
 
 
 
Guys 'n Dolls.
Written by gerardconnolly (1186 comments posted) 16th August 2006
Hello Jane.  
 
Thanks for your message. I assure you this is honesty as instinctively as it comes and I would not insult you with anything less. 
 
Super piece! Change nothing! Nothing! But then I would say that as this is the kind of verbal medley I just love to read. Seriously. Absolutely super. I really do hear the dancing feet outside Minty's. It's easy to slap a song as the title. But how clever to intertwine the song/s and text. It's my kind of thing par excellence.I have to say for me this is your best piece I have read. I endorse all Buchan has quite rightly said. Like Frank Fitzgerald the poet in prose is the most enticing of all writers. This is a little gem of a piece of creative originality. Certainly my favourite on this site for quite some time.  
 
Forget any flaws. Immaterial. I can get a smell of the Big Apple from Damon Runyon onwards. Hey, listen! OK! You are not about to win the Pullizer Prize. But' who cares! Truthfully this would have found a berth in the old ' New Yorker ' -Shorts -before they changed the format. Like the wine buff I''m getting a wiff of Frank Fitzgerald; P J Kavanagh: John O'Hara..etc. Again, your best piece by an Irish mile.  
 
So very well done!  
 
Slan!
Thumbs Up.
Written by givitsum (651 comments posted) 16th August 2006
Reiterating is bring, but there's nothing else to say here BB. Not only is this the best you've posted, but it's also completely different, so an added pat on the arse there. 
 
Well done. 
 
GIVITSUM
Queen of New York
Written by Leo (573 comments posted) 17th August 2006
Mrs B, 
 
This so different to your other work. It is a beautifully realised piece that truly does the concept justice. Your dialogue was superb and was used to create very vivid characters. Magical writing. 
 
best regards 
 
leo
shocked and stunned
Written by Bottleblondesurfer (3362 comments posted) 17th August 2006
Thank you for your comments, guys, It's hard to get perspective when you try something new  
I've PM'd you Brian.And I must admit to being overwhelmed, gerard, at your lyrical review,you caught the spirit of it; and a pat on the arse from G, it doesn't really get any better,the Barnsley equivalent of the nobel prize And Leo thanks for letting me poach your concept and glad you liked the dialogue I put some work into that 
cheers 
Jane
There is no more needing to be added ...
Written by patterjack (1194 comments posted) 17th August 2006
...so I won't risk fulsomeness  
 
patterjack
Give the girl a Big Apple...
Written by woody44 (775 comments posted) 17th August 2006
A lovely evocotive piece MrsB. You have really captured the father`s mood here, I can almost feel the poor man tingling with anticipation mixed with trepidation as he steps onto that plane. Excellent. 
 
Happy writing 
woody
Very apt.
Written by gerardconnolly (1186 comments posted) 17th August 2006
Patterjack gets my vote for the ' Measured Response of the Month '. We should all take a leaf out of his book once in a while. 
 
Handsomely done, Brian.
A wonderful flight!
Written by mishmish (389 comments posted) 23rd August 2006
Just got back from travelling and read this...what a really superb piece of writing, I absolutely loved the lyrics mixed in, it really worked well... 
 
A lovely story and one that was easily visualised, I can almost see george huddled up in the departure lounge, remembering the conversations with his wife, and then realising he's got to leave...Really great stuff Jane!!! 
 
With best wishes 
 
mish x
What happens next....
Written by ellipinnock (1753 comments posted) 25th August 2006
that's the thing. I liked this, found I really identified with George. trouble is now I'm driving myself half crazy wondering whether he finds his daughter or not!
HI BBS
Written by jean.day (2283 comments posted) 29th August 2006
When I read this, which I thoroughy enjoyed, it sure brought back memories. Me saying, "I've been accepted in New York" and my Mom saying, "You can't go." And me saying back, "I'm grown up and I will do what I want." But it was a wonderful year I spent there and my parents did accept it in the end. Although Father whatsit was right to worry. On my first evening there I was propositioned by a doctor with a pregnant wife (I worked at a hospital) - and he spent ages telling me how wonderful he thought Lolita was.  
 
Anyway, you have had so many wonderful reviews already on this one that I can't think of anything original to add. But it is very good.

Written by Witzl (1585 comments posted) 28th November 2006
Another 'Work Awaiting Review' find. I echo all the other words of praise, but must add that even in New York, superb capital of sin that it is, poor George will find plenty of women like Kitty and men like Fr Howley.  
 
My mother, who also did a year's stint in New York in her own youth, understood its allure and sent me off with her blessing a hand-me- down coat. My very first day there I met a man with no tongue and another fellow who eagerly offered to show me -- well, never mind, but Kitty would have felt herself well vindicated.  
 
Have you carried on with this story, and if so, what is it called? I am anxious to know how Helen is doing . . .

Written by Kathy (220 comments posted) 4th March 2007
Hi Jane 
 
Came across this and I really LOVED it!!! I love they way that you write and I really like your humour.  
 
So many great observations: 
 
"When love goes it's your insecurities that bind you together" 
 
"How can I go with my feet..." 
 
"I hope they've got a sign or I won't know the difference" 
 
Brilliant.  
 
I don't recognise the song, what is it? 
 
Sorry for my ignorance, but have you already been published? 
Have you continued the story further and would you consider working more songs into it? 
 
I promise to read more of your work, I don't seem to have very much time but I will try to do it soon. 
 
Many thanks, 
Kathy

   Only registered users can rate and write comments.
   Please login or register.

Powered by AkoComment 2.0!

 Previous item   Next item