Great Writing - Home > Short S. > Number Crunching
READING ROOM
Great Writing - Home
Read and review others' work
Articles on writing
Advice from the community
COMMUNITY
Talk to others in the forums
Events and Competitions
GW News
ABOUT GREAT WRITING
All About Us
Contact Us
WORK AWAITING REVIEW
GW IS...
Great Writing creative writing community is designed to prompt ideas and provide inspiration and motivation within aspiring and amateur authors. Whatever your topic; from love poetry to Doctor Who or Harry Potter fan fiction, Great Writing's online writing group is where you can make new friends and improve your creative writing.
WHO'S ONLINE
We have 1110 guests online and 5 members online
Shorts
Number Crunching
By ellipinnock
13 October 2006
I nearly posted this into non-fiction. However, it is so subjective, any member of my family would probably tell this very differently so it remains here for the time being.

I have only seen my father cry on two occasions. The first I remember better than the second. I was eight years old and had been waiting for weeks with the greatest anticipation for the birth of my new sibling. I can still feel the pride I shared with my brother when we found a wardrobe full of baby clothes and realised that they were there for a purpose and not merely part of some arcane adult plan beyond our comprehension. Looking back it took us an incredibly long time to cotton on to the forthcoming event, I think we were unbelievably naïve about many things at that age. Needless to say, as an eight year old girl, the prospect of something to mother proved a fairly attractive one. For my brother also, the prospect of a potentially male companion was an exciting one- it did not enter his mind that he might end up with another sister. Eighteen months younger than I, he had long borne the brunt of my somewhat bossy nature and looked forward to a time in which football featured rather more strongly than imaginary horse-related play.

I don’t remember my mother going into hospital although clearly she must have done. I suppose we were looked after by a babysitter and played our usual game of trying to get away with as much as possible. I don’t remember any of this. I do remember waking up in the dark of a November morning, cold and dismal as November mornings tend to be. I remember lying in bed, dreading the moment when I would have to stir and rise into the chilly morning. Then it struck me, there might be News! There might be a baby somewhere in the house-this despite having had several patient explanations concerning the timescale for these things. I tumbled out of bed, hitting my head on the floor and a glint of yellow caught my eye as I lay there. A post-it note reading:


Elli,

You have a new baby brother.
His name is Sam.

Love,

Mum and Dad
 
It had a smiley face on the bottom. Remembering this, it is my mother’s writing that I see even though I know that to be impossible, she was still at the hospital. I ran, helter-skelter through the house to find my father and ask him all the questions buzzing around my head. My parents’ bedroom was still dark, an unusual occurrence to say the least. I pushed the door ajar and saw my father, lying on the bed, sobbing as though his heart was about to break. I think I ran away. I do not know. It was just too big for me to understand-why was he crying? Even later, when they explained to me what Down Syndrome was, I did not understand. I had a new baby brother-where was the need to be sad? He was beautiful. We were taken to see him in his incubator at hospital, so small and crinkled. I fell in love there and then, with no further ado. Even later still, I did not really understand. Visits to the hospital in the dead of night, an extended period of time in the children’s hospital in Birmingham…still I did not understand the need for sadness.

I understand now, I think. Now that I begin to think about having children of my own one day. Now that the spectre of DNA-testing rears its ugly head- just to make sure, you understand, just to make sure. I dread the results of that test. The chance of testing positive is small, the consequences are not. Imagine this:

Six pregnancies
3 miscarriages
2 normal babies
1 baby with Down Syndrome

One of the normal babies carries the genetic risk as well. Can I rationalise these numbers? No. Could I live with them? I may find out. I wonder sometimes, what kind of life will this baby brother of mine have? Will he be able to live on his own, hold down a job? What opportunities will there be for him? Living away from home is one of the hardest things I have ever had to do. I miss him every day and I worry about him and about my parents. They did not ask for a responsibility that has no alleviation. He is loved, that is for sure. One another thing is sure. I cannot say that I would not wish him any other way. 

Reviews
Moving...
Written by Snodlander (501 comments posted) 13th October 2006
...I get teary so easily :cry  
 
A nice piece. I cried when my kids were born, but for entirely different reasons. I wasn't expecting that reason, though. Effectively introduced, with no clue beforehand. I wonder what the second time he cried was? 
 
Can I suggest you look at the last couple of lines, though? 
 
The penultimate line has a typo. It should read 'one other thing' rather than 'another'. 
 
The double negative in the last line threw me. I had to read it a few times to understand it. It is saying that you may wish your brother did not have Down's. Is that what you wanted to say? If so, then the hesitant way it's put would suggest that it's not as sure as the preceding line suggests. I hesitate to suggest a clearer way of putting it, because this is obviously a very personal story. 
 
But apart from that little niggle, good job
Very touching
Written by bookworm (13 comments posted) 13th October 2006
Beautifully written, and as Snodlander has said, moving. I especially like the way you depict the fact that as a child you completely accepted the Downs Syndrome as unimportant- a child-like trait that we unfortunately lose as we get older and begin to grasp life's practical side. 
The ending was beautiful.
Hi EP
Written by BrianRobertNeal (1195 comments posted) 13th October 2006
The statistic quoted related to whom? 
 
With our youngest child who is tail end charlie there was a very risk becuase of my wife's age that there was a siginificant risk of "Downs Syndrome" 
 
We were offered the chance of a test, however the odds of injuring a perfectly normal infant were greater than the likelihood of it suffering from Downs Syndrome. 
 
Furthermore neither would have been a party tp a termination. 
 
He was free the condition. 
 
As a little boy was I was befriended by a middle aged woman at the church I went to. She had no children. 
 
I asked her how she go to Mothers Union, she said I had 13 children, ten were born dead and the other three surivived fow a few days only. I was only eight then, now I'm much older and cannot understand how she kept her faith. 
 
Your piece has certainly set off many chains of thought, 
 
Brian.
Hi Elli
Written by jean.day (2286 comments posted) 13th October 2006
What a moving story - and very well told. Thank you for sharing it.

Written by Gill21 (566 comments posted) 13th October 2006
I knew what was coming as i read the lovely poem you wrote some time ago, and i briefly told you how i agreed with many things you had said. I'm an only child and have always longed for a sibling, although it just wasn't to be. I think because of this, or maybe its just who i am, i get very attached to other people; my friends, my friends siblings, my friends and my mothers friends children. They are all my family. This being the only way i can even begin to relate, the people and children who are seen as 'different' are not and different in my eyes. They are just them and if they were any other way they wouldn't be them. However i've seen how it affects the parents, how it breaks their hearts....i could go on forever as you have also provoked a long chain of thoughts with me too, but i won't. It's a very personal subject, and as you said so subjective. I think you handled the different view points very well. 
Beautifully and simply written, yet very moving and heart warming. The note left by your mum was a lovely wee touch, made me smile!  
:)

Written by Fledermaus (3321 comments posted) 13th October 2006
They all said it above. Very touching, very well written...
Thanks...
Written by ellipinnock (1753 comments posted) 13th October 2006
To all for your kind comments. 
 
Snodlander- 
I'll change the typo :) I intended the double negative because it isn't a black and white issue for me, I do have a lot of uncertainty. Although I do love him and wish he didn't have Down's I also can't help but feel guilty for wishing that...if that makes any sense. 
 
Bookworm-  
I think that has been the hardest thing for me..realising so late the significance. It means it's something my parents have had to deal with alone for much of Sam's life and it does get more difficult to accept. 
 
BRN-  
The statistic refers to the probablities of various outcomes if you carry a particular genetic predisposition. I've pm'ed you about this 'cos it gets a bit sciency and hard to explain concisely. 
 
Jean and Fledermaus- 
Thanks for taking the time to comment. Sharing some of this stuff is both cathartic for me and, I hope, informative (I don't think that's the right word but I can't think of a better at the moment...) 
 
Gill- 
Thanks, I'm glad it moved you. Always appreciate your feedback :) 
 
Again, many thanks to all 
 
Elli

Written by Bottleblondesurfer (3369 comments posted) 13th October 2006
Never sure what to say about pieces like this; commenting on the content is redundant and commenting on the presentation mean spirited but I thought it well expressed with a quiet understatement that allowed the reader some space for their own emotions 
cheers 
BBS
Ditto
Written by CameronS (20 comments posted) 13th October 2006
I agree with BBS on this one. It's a very personal piece of writing. Sharing experiences like these can certainly be very helpful (and, informative) for others. Thank you. 
 
S.
Hydra..
Written by gerardconnolly (1186 comments posted) 13th October 2006
Hello Elli. 
 
As a piece of writing- and that is the only way I can judge it-- I found this a very emotional and touching post. Do NOT be assuaged by personal considerations. The reading public have no such instincts themselves. Brutal though it may sound it was a sound and competent piece of writing that courted sympathy/sentiment; but should never rely upon such alone. Was it fiction? Do you want it be fiction? Whatever. You must decide. 
 
A little in limbo. But nicely conceived nonetheless. 
 
Slan!
Very moving!
Written by LynB (435 comments posted) 13th October 2006
I can identify with this story to some extent, as I have a cousin who has Down's Syndrome. He is now 42 years old and not in the best of health, but he is a lovely, friendly person, and his obvious zest for life always warms my heart. 
 
A lovely heartfelt piece of writing.
Thanks
Written by ellipinnock (1753 comments posted) 14th October 2006
BBS+ CameronS- 
Thanks to both for your kind comments 
 
Gerard- 
Thanks for your honesty. It is entirely true (with the caveat that this is the best of my ability to be objective). Maybe I wish it wasn't and out of the confusion comes limbo I guess. However, I did not post this intending to court sympathy although I realise that I tread a narrow line. After all, for what do I deserve sympathy? Nothing in my book. (Reading this back, it sounds a little shirty, it is not intended to be!) :) 
 
LynB- 
Thanks, it always surprises me how many people I come across who have a relative with Downs give that the figures are something like 1 in 600 births. 
 
Thanks again to all 
 
Elli

Written by Phil (6738 comments posted) 14th October 2006
Very touching piece Elli. You captured the contradictions of emotions really well - particularly those of children compared to adults. 
 
All the best, 
 
Phil.

   Only registered users can rate and write comments.
   Please login or register.

Powered by AkoComment 2.0!

 Previous item   Next item