Great Writing - Home > Non-Fiction > The state we're in.
READING ROOM
Great Writing - Home
Read and review others' work
Articles on writing
Advice from the community
COMMUNITY
Talk to others in the forums
Events and Competitions
GW News
ABOUT GREAT WRITING
All About Us
Contact Us
WORK AWAITING REVIEW
GW IS...
Great Writing creative writing community is designed to prompt ideas and provide inspiration and motivation within aspiring and amateur authors. Whatever your topic; from love poetry to Doctor Who or Harry Potter fan fiction, Great Writing's online writing group is where you can make new friends and improve your creative writing.
WHO'S ONLINE
We have 982 guests online and 3 members online
Non-Fiction
The state we're in.
By Phil
21 November 2006
I'm a teacher. I actually enjoy my job. While the kids I teach are not perfect, they're a good bunch - on the whole. Some days I get despondent.

So, on the first day of a new job one of my pupils says to me, "What's your name?"

 'I've told you already - it's Mr Carmichael.'

 'No, your first name, I mean.'

 I'm tempted to answer 'mister' but that would just give credence to his familiarity.  I don't mind the child knowing my given name, but the fact that he felt comfortable in asking illustrates the lack of distance in the pupil-teacher relationship.  Yes, I know I'm not supposed to be some remote automaton (although there are times when I feel the government would have it so) but in the context of school, he is my pupil and I am his teacher.

 On another day, a child calls out for the forth time.  At this point, instead of ignoring him, I'm forced to stop and remind him that if we are all to learn, he must wait his turn and respect the right of others to speak.  I say this much more calmly than I feel but hope to avoid confrontation in the middle of a lesson.  This does not elicit the desired response and after a couple of minutes I'm forced to ask the child to leave the room.

 On yet another day, another child (although it could easily have been the first or second) decides she doesn't like the look of her allotted task and so decides not to complete it.  For entertainment, she pokes, prods and generally irritates the other children around her.  They too become distracted and I have to stop work with my focus group to straighten things out.

 These examples are not of emotionally disturbed or particularly challenging children.  What I'm talking about, unless I'm completely loosing it, is a fairly large minority of children who are familiar to all teachers; children who choose not to accept reasonable limits to their behaviour for the benefit of all.

 My father, who tells many a happy tale of being beaten in school, says discipline was never a problem in his day.  In his opinion, back in the Glasgow of the forties, everyone felt uplifted by a swift crack on the backside with a length of cane.  He also believes that National Service, hanging and the birch should be restored, so perhaps we'll pass on.

 In contrast to my father's education, when I was at primary school, a cement bound thirties affair in the middle of a large council estate, my peers and I were never struck by a teacher.  I'm just old enough for this to have been legal, but it never actually happened - and as far as I can remember insistent, constant disruption from some children was just not an issue.

 So what has changed?  It's easy to blame the parents.  I am one, I should know.  Nostalgia tells me that it used to be, 'What teacher says goes.'  You'll have heard this one before, but it bears repeating.  A child goes home and his father asks if he's had a good day at school.  The child replies that no, he hasn't, he'd got into trouble.  The result?  A crack round the back of the head.  Now I don't advocate parents assaulting their children in this manner (although there are times when I'm sorely tempted) but the moral of the story is clear.  Parents, at least apocryphally, would support any discipline metered out by the school.

 There have been many times at parents' evenings or special meetings after or before school that I've had to meet with parents bemoaning the fact that their child came home upset.  The first time this happened, I was surprised to discover that the cause of the parent's ire was not the fact that they thought I'd had harsh words or punished their child, but that they didn't see anything very wrong in what their child had done.  This in a school where home-school links and communication were strong.  The lack of support from a section of parents is worrying.  It is quite impossible for children in this situation to accept responsibility for their actions when the people that have the greatest influence over them act as apologists.

 Of course, there are many shining examples of parenthood.  (You need look no further than me!)  I've always tried to support the school and its activities, except when requests arrive for help at the summer fete, something to be avoided at all costs.  Parents should and are encouraged to share in the school's aims and ethos.  Unfortunately, the very parents you want to reach out to the most are the hardest to get onboard.

 A lot of this talk about parenting is by the by, likewise, theories about television, computer games and resultant attention spans.  Although the problem teacher's face is replicated outside of schools, it is our job to tackle it within.  We have a responsibility for children when they attend school and so we must shoulder some of the blame.  Are we too relaxed, too strict, too demanding, too laid back?  In short, have we helped to create a generation of children who will not conform to what society would demand?  Well yes, in part we are responsible.  We have allowed ourselves to accept systems that we knew were flawed in the first place.  While I'm all in favour of a National Curriculum, efforts to raise standards, inclusion, even monitoring of standards through OfSED, all these changes and drives have fundamentally changed teachers’ role and focus.

 I fill in more documents, set and pursue more learning targets, accept and review more performance targets, revise more government schemes of work, attend more courses, plan in evermore pointless detail – etc, ad infinitum - than I ever thought was possible.  I believe in an holistic, child centred education for all, it's even in my standard application letter.  This was my focus when I first entered teaching.  This was my focus, but I have to confess, of late, I have become a little distracted.  I don't actually have time to tackle the things I know really need doing.  How can I balance an over bureaucratic system with what I know to be right?

 Often I don't.  I do what I have to do.  I do what is demanded and any time I have left, if I've got the energy, I tighten my focus on what I believe. I used to love chatting with children, building real rapport, while they sewed, embroidered or painted.  But there's no fun in that when you've got to cover Unit 5c annex ii, iv and vii and assess ICT skills of a group of children in the corner at the same time.

 What really worries me is that I can see no end to this.  At some point I may have to assess, record and pass on information about ability to apply backstitch in a design situation.  Where will it end?  Oh yes, I almost forgot, teaching classroom assistants.  Let these undertrained and underpaid workers do my proper job while I sit in a quiet corner of the staffroom and plan.  Except it just won't work.  Aside from the fact that these people will not be trained or paid properly for what they will do, it will be me who has to deal with all the over-familiar, interrupting, distracting pupils that are sent to me.  I won't be a teacher anymore.  I won't even get to plan lessons for someone else to deliver.  I'll be a nanny for malcontents.

 Maybe, and I say this with much reluctance, Margaret Thatcher was right.  Perhaps there is no such thing as society anymore.  In our post-modern world it might just be that some young individuals can not co-operate or work towards the improvement of the group if it doesn't fit in with their sense of self.

 So what are we to do?  I don't have solutions, only suggestions:  grin and bear it, open a newsagents, become an advisory teacher, feign madness through stress and retire early, or my personal favourite, trite though it is: stick it out and remember why you wanted to do this job in the first place.  Nothing's perfect, but nothing ever got better by giving up.


 Now, where's my lottery ticket?

Reviews
Not brave enough
Written by patterjack (1328 comments posted) 20th November 2006
As an ex teacher - ex lecturer I can sympathise with all you have said , but lack courage to expound on the topic  
 
I have no solutions , though I think I could lay a bit of blame for the problems if I wished to do so. 
 
My personal solution was to be aware of The Peter Principle and to indulge now and then in a lateral arabesque
As a corollary I simply ignored bureaucratic or authoritarian directions and taught what I wished to teach in the way I wanted to. 
 
That attitude cost me sometimes ! Never being greatly PC didn't help my career much either . 
 
patterjack
Sympathy
Written by Talisker (1328 comments posted) 20th November 2006
Phil, where to start? My only sister is a primary teacher, sorry was, she BECAME a classroom assistant because of the bureaucracy involved in being a teacher these days, the stress of it all was too much for her. 
 
Like Brian, I have no trite solutions to offer. I DID get belted at school, and while I'm ambivalent on the matter, discipline was undoubtedly better then. Not only that, but kids wanted to learn, and left primary with a firm grasp of the three Rs. 
 
Isn't it the case across the vocations now that disillusionment is rife. Generations now have undervalued the pedagogues, the ones who mould our future adults, have taken you for granted.  
 
Still, the opportunity to make a difference to SOME kids' lives must be some small compensation. Pragmatism dear Phil, pragmatism. 3.35 a.m. 
 
Oli ;)
Oh, sorry...!!!
Written by Talisker (1328 comments posted) 20th November 2006
Very well written young man!! 
 
(See teacher after class!) 
:grin
The 1950s
Written by Fledermaus (3448 comments posted) 21st November 2006
It's not just teachers who are complaining about the lack of discipline and acceptance of authority. I heard the same from doctors, policemen, priests, etc. 
 
I'm too young to have experienced the orderly 1950s, but from what I've heard something must have gone wrong in the 1960s, and I enjoy teasing people who were young back then by implying it was all sex, drugs, rock'n'roll back. 
Now the teachers, doctors, policemen, priests and parents of today are the teenagers of the 1960s... 
 
I guess the problem has two sides. On the one hand there are the authorities who think they should be friendly and allow their clients an opinion. On the other hand there are the clients who think they are wise and smart enough to have one. 
 
Usually I don't question doctors or priests, as I consider them experts in their field, but unfortunately teachers (with the exception of the older generation and professors at the uni) and policemen have somehow lost much of their credibility...

Written by Clifftown (642 comments posted) 21st November 2006
You have a really engaging writing style and I enjoyed reading this. It's a shame teachers with your earnest and positive approach don't get properly rewarded with respect and support from some of the parents. My sister is a primary school teacher and from some of the things she's said, this could have also been written by her. 
 
Hope things pick up for you, and as I said, a great read.
Really thought provoking
Written by johniebg (553 comments posted) 21st November 2006
Although you start this with children's inability to be considerate and focused, the journey you took us on felt more like a purge of your frustrations in bureaucracy and not being able to shape them using the skills you have. It is a very interesting read and very well structured. 
 
Don't every generation consider the one following them to be worse, I know my parents did and their parents before. Isn't it just that there are so many more of us, with twice as many humans on planet earth than there were just 40 years ago! Is it just that it seems like there are more of the unruly ones? 
 
I felt sorry for the kids you mention at the beginning because they are just children and if my work environment is anything to go by, not that different from adults. Smaller unrefined versions of humanity, that often will display the same behaviour through life. Obviously if you have to teach the great masses then these traits I suppose do lose their appeal. 
 
Really thought provoking, hope you didn't write this while in class :)

Written by Garrulous (108 comments posted) 21st November 2006
Phil - A very strongly written account of the problems facing todays teachers and it just affirms my belief that I could never do what you do. 
 
I see some people are holding back on the judgments and that may be best but I would just say one thing. I have two children of school age, before they started school I instilled in them a sense of respect for their elders and they fully understood how I expected them to behave without the need for smacking or ogrish behaviour. They have not let me down. They are immaculately behaved in school and at home and conscientious pupils. I say this because I have friends who have children of the same age and being around them, I did not feel they were pulling their weight in order to ensure their children had some level of respect and a sense of good behaviour, so from my experience I would point initially to the parents. 
People are always defending parents saying how hard it is and to some extent I would agree, especially where single parent families are concerned but I also think it is too easy for parents to blame society for their own shortcomings. 
 
Gar.

Written by Phil (6838 comments posted) 21st November 2006
Thanks for the reviews folks. Much appreciated.  
 
Points: 
 
Written out of frustration? Partly. 
Not brave enough? Probably. 
Restrained? Definitely. 
My job? Mainly rewarding. 
Kids of every generation the same? I don't think so. I've seen a steady decline in attitudes in the eighteen years I've been teaching. I guess it might be my outlook, but I don't think so. 
Not brave enough? Too much accountability to 'your own thing.' 
 
 
Thanks again, 
 
Phil.

   Only registered users can rate and write comments.
   Please login or register.

Powered by AkoComment 2.0!

 Previous item   Next item