Great Writing - Home > Non-Fiction > The arrogance of truth - Part 1
READING ROOM
Great Writing - Home
Read and review others' work
Articles on writing
Advice from the community
COMMUNITY
Talk to others in the forums
Events and Competitions
GW News
ABOUT GREAT WRITING
All About Us
Contact Us
WORK AWAITING REVIEW
GW IS...
Great Writing creative writing community is designed to prompt ideas and provide inspiration and motivation within aspiring and amateur authors. Whatever your topic; from love poetry to Doctor Who or Harry Potter fan fiction, Great Writing's online writing group is where you can make new friends and improve your creative writing.
WHO'S ONLINE
We have 2793 guests online and 4 members online
Non-Fiction
The arrogance of truth - Part 1
By Phil
17 December 2006
This started life with the title and was not intended to be recollections of my upbringing. However, that is how it's turned out. As it turns out, it's going to be pretty long, so I've posted what I've written so far. It is definitely not finished.

Whatever else this is, it is not an attack on anyone's faith, just the story of my journey through other people's beliefs and my reaction to them.

The arrogance of truth.


I grew up in house of certainty. God was in his heaven and at the same time He found time to look after every single one of us. My parents both ‘knew Jesus as their personal saviour’ and were literal believers in the Bible. Homosexuality was wrong, all other religions were sacrilege, Catholics were misled, gambling was evil, drinking was sinful and the only way to avoid hell was to confess to God and ‘invite Jesus into your heart to be born again.’ As you can probably imagine, this had a strong effect upon me as I grew up.

I have vivid memories of events throughout my childhood, as most people do, but a great many of those memories are religious ones. To say that God and Jesus (not forgetting the Holy Spirit) were at the centre of my family’s existence would not be an exaggeration.



Speaking in tongues.

I was dragged around to many non-conformist meetings. These took place in various places: churches, mission huts, houses. Some of these would be what most people would view as reasonably traditional worship styles, others were quite unusual.

One evening, I think I’d be about seven, I was taken to a meeting. I don’t remember whether I was with my mum or dad or if my older brother was there. I remember the place though, a cold wooden hall, painted green on the outside and roughly furnished inside. There were bare wooden floor boards and the ‘congregation’ were sat on wooden chairs that were all too small – probably from an old school. It was warmed by a black, cast iron furnace set in the centre of the hall. You could still see your breath. The altar was just a simple table with a cloth.

The man at the front (I don’t know what his title was – pastor, reverend, minister etc) began his sermon. It was the usual tub thumping stuff that at that age I recognised as blunt and scary. As was often the case, part way through, someone was invited to give their testimony – how they had lived a Godless life and then found Jesus. It was at this point that the man next to me stood up. He was tall, wearing a grey/brown raincoat, had dark greased back hair, glasses and a thin moustache. Looking back as an adult, I can see there’s a certain stereotype here, but at the time, he was just some bloke I’d never met before. So, he stood up and started shouting in what I was later to discover was called tongues. I’m guessing this refers to a story in the Bible when God gave the disciples the power to talk to peoples from all over the world. Anyway, off he went babbling away. The only word I can remember is Malachi, a minor prophet of the Old Testament. What I have a clearer memory of, was being absolutely shit scared.



Living by faith.

All through my childhood and adolescence there were regular meetings in my home. The otherwise rarely used front room was utilised for this and many mismatched chairs and stools from other places in the house were squeezed around the perimeter. Some of these gatherings were prayer meetings: a sort of relay where one person would pray and then pass the (spiritual) baton onto the next. Others were Bible studies where a text from the Bible would be studied in great depth to winkle out its deepest meaning. Some gatherings were an opportunity for this particular community to meet with people who were thought to be dong something special with their beliefs. Many of these people professed to live by what they called ‘faith.’

One such couple really stick in my mind. After nearly thirty years, I don’t recall their names but do remember - him: balding, thick rimmed glasses, cockily confident – her: aging, earnest, simpering – the couple as a whole: odd, hypocritical, dishonest. I’m being as candid as I can be here, and I admit, time may have corrupted some of this, but those were the feelings I had of these people at the time. I was maybe twelve.

The story they told (interspersed and interrupted with many ‘praise the lords’ and ‘hallelujahs’) was a pretty simple one. They went around the country preaching to the unconverted. They did this in a camper van. They were proud of the fact that they received no financial help from official churches and nor did they sign up for any state benefits. They lived on what they called faith – kind and unsolicited gifts from the faithful. Even at the age of twelve I could see the flaw in the logic of their argument. Just describing how they existed was soliciting. They went on to tell the story of an old lady who anonymously left a brown envelope full of bank notes under a window wiper of their van. (Only discovered they said because they saw her sneaking away.) This old lady was apparently very poor, but her kind gift enabled them to go on doing ‘the work of the Lord’ for a few weeks longer. For those who have any kind of Christian upbringing, this story should ring many bells - think of the old lady giving her one coin outside the temple. Of course, this story ensured they left clutching more money to further evangelise around the country.

Living by faith, or living by gentle con? I’ll leave you to decide but will add that when I was growing up, we had very little. My dad worked bloody hard for every penny and my mum was extremely careful with her house keeping. Watching a couple of strangers leave my home with some of my parents’ money made me bitter indeed.

Reviews
Hi Phil
Written by jean.day (2279 comments posted) 17th December 2006
This is the beginning of what I am sure will be a very interesting piece of writing. It comes across as honest and with the details of things as you saw and interpreted them as a child.  
 
I'll look forward to the next bit of it. 
 
It is scarey how we can effect our kids by our beliefs or lack of them. I get the impression even from this first small bit that religion had exactly the opposite effect on you as to what they were expecting. Are they still alive? Are they still as involved in their beliefs? Are they upset by your not absorbing what to them was obviously a very important part of their lives.  

Written by Phil (6713 comments posted) 17th December 2006
Jean, thanks for the comment. It's always good to get some encouragement. 
 
I'd feel rude if I ignored your questions, but much of this will come out in further pieces. 
 
Phil.

Written by Witzl (1585 comments posted) 17th December 2006
Phil, I find this fascinating. I grew up in one of those homes too -- for the first seven years of my life. I have been working on a piece about this for the last month, but I am not happy with it. I know how hard it is to get this right.  
 
Have you ever read anything by Garrison Keillor? If not, I strongly recommend him. He too grew up in a fundamentalist home and writes a lot about it. Reading one of his autobiographical pieces, I laughed so hard I actually started crying.  
 
Religion caused a lot of trouble in my mother's family. Her father was a straight arrow, but he had two brothers who were 'ne'er do wells.' They came to him everytime he had some money and begged for it -- promised they would reform, be better Christians. To save their immortal souls my grandfather put his own family in penury many times.  
 
Looking forward to more of this.

Written by Clifftown (620 comments posted) 18th December 2006
This was such an interesting read, and what a perfect title. I am as intrigued as Jean to know more about how your beliefs were shaped as you got older, and your parents' reactions. 
 
I too have memories of religious meetings and services taking place in extremely cold halls and churches - it's my enduring memory of such events as a child. 
 
Very much looking forward to Part 2.
Hi Phil.
Written by JourneyAtNight (314 comments posted) 18th December 2006
I can only repeat what was said above - I found this very interesting to read and I'm very much looking forward to the next instalment. 
 
I've also grown up in a religious family. Not Christianity, but the same sort of thing. I've experienced the same sort of people too. I would call myself religious now, but perhaps not to the extent that is 'expected'. 
 
A gripping piece. 
 
Best wishes, 
 
E :) 
and an often repeated story ...
Written by johniebg (538 comments posted) 18th December 2006
... you hear this from so many, I purged it from my system earlier this year with the 'who am i?' essays. I do not think you should apologise for how people receive this, you have a right to your own opinion, if anyone gets offended it shows them for what they are! 
 
This is effective for the un emotional dialogue that you know is the result of years, probably decades working in your mind and probably a lot of angst. 
 
I have been working on a 'debunking christianity' essay for christmas, this has given me extra motivation to get it finished. 
 
Good stuff.

Written by Bottleblondesurfer (3351 comments posted) 18th December 2006
I can't help but comment on the irony of the title as religion has a lot to do with arrogance and very little to do with truth.Although this was written in a cogent understated almost journalistic way I thought I detected some real anger in the telling, as a powerless child there is nothing you can do but recounting it as an adult with hindsight you can somehow comfort that boy and understand the gullibility of the "believers" 
Although it is such a personal piece the qualilty of the writing has prevented it from being exclusive and allowed the reader some thoughts of their own. I thougth there was a powerful universality to the piece. 
Have you read Dawkins? (I'm sure you have) 
Glad to see you've taken time to post, I should follow you example 
J

Written by ellipinnock (1753 comments posted) 18th December 2006
A really powerful piece Phil. I don't have much to add to what has been said above. I would echo Jane in saying that, for such a personal piece of writing, it was a very accessible read. I find the whole concept of soliciting money, especially from people who do not have a lot of it, in order to fund a personal missionary zeal very distasteful and contrary to what religion should stand for. Thanks for sharing this, a thoroughly absorbing piece. 
 
Elli

Written by Snodlander (501 comments posted) 18th December 2006
Oh dear. I hope I'm not going to be drummed out of the club :)
 
People's opinions of religion are often coloured by their childhood. My parents were open to religion, and would invite the JW's in. But they never mandated anything to us. Consequently, of the four of us we have two Christians (who in their youth were evangelical in the tradional meaning), an athiest and a Chaotic Wiccan. 
 
There is arrogance, greed and hipocracy in the church (of whatever religion). How else could this be? The church is made up, not of super-saints, but of ordinary people. There is also humility, generosity and honesty. I'm sorry your early life coloured your experience (and apparantly, every other member of the forum ;) ) negatively. 
 
I'm not sure of your motivation in writing this. I think that it will confirm people in their own existing opinions. If you want to sway people from their own mindset, a gentler approach might be better suited. From the first line it is obvious as to your opinion, and this will either alienate those who disagree, or confirm those who already agree. 
 
Of course, you may not be seeking to sway anyone one way or the other, in which case, carry on.

Written by Fledermaus (3281 comments posted) 18th December 2006
Too bad that some people take such an aggresive take on religion, for it can be such a wonderful thing. Traditions, including religion, can be very helpful, but they shouldn't be forced on anyone. 
It's a shame really, that many people seem to be so traumatized by their upbringing that they don't want to have anything to do with religion anymore... There is a clear difference between devoutness and fanatism.

Written by Phil (6713 comments posted) 18th December 2006
Thanks for taking the time to comment everyone, much appreciated. Just to re-emphasise, whatever else this is, it is not an attack on anyone's faith, just the story of my journey through other people's beliefs and my reaction to them. 
 
I do have personal beliefs and opinions - they'll perhaps come out in subsequent pieces. 
 
Phil.

Written by Novu (12 comments posted) 18th December 2006
This is an interesting account of your life, Phil.  
 
I found the curiosity of you as a child to be fascinating in showing how children, with a fresh view on how religion works, can find it altogether overwhelming and frightening.  
 
I know a few people who have grown up in Catholic households, of whom I thought when reading this. They were troubled by the ways in which their family acted when they were children. I am not religious myself, but I do find it intriguing how someone copes in a family with those kind of devout beliefs without necessarily sharing them.  
 
Looking forward to reading the next instalments.  
 
Novu

   Only registered users can rate and write comments.
   Please login or register.

Powered by AkoComment 2.0!

 Previous item   Next item