Great Writing - Home > Non-Fiction > The arrogance of truth - Part 2
READING ROOM
Great Writing - Home
Read and review others' work
Articles on writing
Advice from the community
COMMUNITY
Talk to others in the forums
Events and Competitions
GW News
ABOUT GREAT WRITING
All About Us
Contact Us
WORK AWAITING REVIEW
GW IS...
Great Writing creative writing community is designed to prompt ideas and provide inspiration and motivation within aspiring and amateur authors. Whatever your topic; from love poetry to Doctor Who or Harry Potter fan fiction, Great Writing's online writing group is where you can make new friends and improve your creative writing.
WHO'S ONLINE
We have 1421 guests online and 15 members online
Non-Fiction
The arrogance of truth - Part 2
By Phil
18 December 2006
Context of piece - This follows The Arrogance of Truth Part 1 which included: Introduction, Speaking in Tongues, Living by Faith.
Again, this is not an attack on faith or religion, just the story of my journey through other people's beliefs.

For those who are interested, there is a 'companion poem' over in poetry: The Laying On Of Hands. You can go straight to this by clicking on:
http://www.greatwriting.co.uk/index.php?option=com_content&task=view&id=6315&Itemid=77


Praise God he broke his legs – the logic of a ten year old.


God moves in mysterious ways, or so they say.

My parents always told my brother and me that we had free will. As far as they were concerned, there was no predestination, all was choice, especially when it came down to sinning and repenting. To a child, this made eminent sense. It was me who was responsible for my actions. However, all became a little confusing at a prayer meeting I had been taken to.

One of the members of this group of believers had had a road accident and been pretty badly injured. At the time of the meeting he was in a coma and had two broken legs. The praying started and by and by I noticed a pattern to the prayers that caused me to re-evaluate my theories concerning the nature of God. The prayers went something like this: “Thank you Lord for protecting your loyal servant [insert name here] and protecting him from even worse injuries.”  Well, there’s me thinking, protecting? no predestination? the two don’t go together. Even worse, I thought this: if God stopped him being killed, He actively allowed him to be injured. Where’s your loving God in that? This was further compounded by more prayers asking God to heal him. This led to all sorts of confusion. I hoped God would heal the man, but what about everyone who didn’t get better, didn’t God love them? If the guy didn’t recover did that mean God couldn’t heal him? What sort of God was that? To a young boy it was all very confusing.

Later, when I spoke to my dad about this, his answer was, ‘God moves in mysterious ways.’ That’s an answer I found very unsatisfactory at the time, and when I hear it now, it smacks of a get out clause. I know, I know; to understand God is divine. But to fudge a cheap answer is human.




Cherry picking the Bible

Both my parents were literal believers in what they referred to as, ‘The Scriptures.’ For a young boy this was easy. The world was created in six days, God flooded the Earth and all the animals went on an ark, Jesus was born of a virgin in a stable, He was crucified and rose again. Simple. It was even comforting. It provided a scaffold for our lives. If there was a problem, enlightenment was always to be found somewhere in the Bible, and as every word was the word of God, you couldn’t go wrong.

When I was about eight, I was given my first Bible. I’ve still got it, a Revised Standard Version with all of Jesus’ words printed in red. I guess I must have been a little older, say eleven, twelve or thirteen, when I began to read critically. I’m not going to list them here, but there are so many contradictions in the Bible, to take it as a literal truth, besides being naïve, requires a certain tunnel vision.

To give my parents and their circle credit, they were willing to discuss this, but when push came to shove, it came down to another cheap cop out: how can we understand the word of God son? All very well I thought, but our whole life was based on what they had chosen to understand of the word of God.



Being Born Again.

My parents believed in rebirth as Christians. Only those who were ‘saved’ would go to heaven, the rest; Anglicans, Catholics etc (not to mention other faiths) were doomed.

Being reborn was a process of, ‘Inviting Jesus into your heart as your personal saviour.’ Then, and only then would you be saved and really know Jesus. This was a great moment in any Christian’s life.

One Saturday evening, I think I was about ten; I was taken to watch an all Christian band play at the Central Methodist Hall. (I think John Wesley may have been doing some grave spinning that night.) It all started very well with upbeat numbers to get everyone going. As the night drew to a close, the music got slower and slower and more soulful. To some, music is a very powerful medium. As the band went into their last number, an instrumental, the lead singer made his pitch. Low and insistent, he asked if anyone wanted to give their heart to Jesus. Over and over. Don’t be afraid, there are people here to help you. Over and over. Come down to the front and let us help you. Over and over. It was as if there was an invisible rope pulling me down the centre aisle towards the front. All the time that music playing in the background.

I don’t remember much about the praying that went on in back room, but I do remember arriving home. Mum and dad were very proud. This was something they had been patiently waiting for. To be honest, I felt relieved. I’d felt the ‘Holy Spirit’ at last and taken the plunge.

This was the beginning of the end. Although I didn’t expect miracles, and certainly nothing overnight, I did expect something – some little twinge, a different feeling inside. As the weeks and months went by, I felt absolutely nothing. I began to feel as if God didn’t want me. Looking back from my adult perspective, I’m amazed I coped so well. All my life I’d been brought up to believe that God was everything, and then I felt that God had rejected me. Not only that, the rest of my family continued to revel in Jesus.

Reviews

Written by Novu (12 comments posted) 18th December 2006
I found this very engaging, even more than your first piece of writing.  
 
I especially found it easy to relate to the part about the realisation of the Bible's contradictions.  
 
It's interesting, as you are talking about it from your adult perspective, looking back, so you have a more varied response than when you were a child.  
 
Fascinating. Thanks for the read.  
 
Novu  
Hi Phil
Written by jean.day (2257 comments posted) 18th December 2006
Another very insightful episode in your personal unravelling.  
 
It's hard for parents who believe strongly in something to not want the same for their children. But your parents seemed quite caring - they were pleased when you saw the light - but nobody forced it on you. 
 
I too find the selective nature of healing and answering prayers hard to take on board. If you ask and don't receive, it either means you didn't ask well enough or it wasn't in God's plan. but having said that, I have had a couple of instances in my life when groups prayed for me, or in another instance my granddaughter - and things which might have been rather nasty turned out good. Maybe it would have happened without the prayer, who knows? Lots of people prayed for my sister when she was diagnosed with mesothelioma, and it didn't do any good at all.

Written by Clifftown (619 comments posted) 19th December 2006
I found this a very absorbing read, more so than your first piece (although I still enjoyed that!) I agree with all of your sentiments; I suppose it would be interesting to read a viewpoint from someone who did not.  
 
Will there be any more? I for one am intrigued as to how your parents dealt with your "seeing the light" and then the subsequent feeling of rejection.

Written by Fledermaus (3238 comments posted) 19th December 2006
These are very interesting reads. I've always been interested in other people's faiths. The scenes you paint don't seem too inviting though...

Written by Snodlander (501 comments posted) 19th December 2006
I agree, a more readable piece. This one seemed more argued and less emotional than the first, and was better for it, I think.

Written by Phil (6635 comments posted) 19th December 2006
Thanks for the comments everyone. Still one or two pieces to come. Interesting that this one was seen as less emotional - it didn't seem it as I wrote - but I did try to keep the emotion out. 
 
Thanks again, Phil.

Written by Witzl (1585 comments posted) 19th December 2006
You write these pieces so well and so believably. I have been working and reworking my 'Church of Christ' piece, and it all sounds rather mean-spirited and shallow.  
 
I really look forward to more of this, Phil I will try to withhold my comments until I have read it all.  

Written by JourneyAtNight (314 comments posted) 19th December 2006
Another great read . I think everyone has a religion of some sort, even athesists - to me its simply a way of life, and how we all view life as individuals. Don't know if that makes sense, but I'm always eager to hear about these different perspectives, and reading your account of it when you were a child is really interesting.  
 
Looking forward to more. 
 
Best wishes, 
 
E:)
typo..
Written by JourneyAtNight (314 comments posted) 19th December 2006
atheists...sorry :x
brilliant
Written by johniebg (538 comments posted) 19th December 2006
I love the way you have laid this out. Not to sure on the pussy footing about not wanting to 'attack' faith, this feels like you are just starting to unravel this in your mind. Christians have been imposing their twaddle on us for long enough and about time it was just over, attack, attack, attack. 
 
It is so good to see this stuff written down, so seldom will people be honest enough for some dark fear that yahweh will strike them down in a flash of lightning, miserable git (hebrew god that is, not you). 
 
Can't wait to read more, this is very motivating.

   Only registered users can rate and write comments.
   Please login or register.

Powered by AkoComment 2.0!

 Previous item   Next item