READING ROOM
Great Writing - Home
Read and review others' work
Articles on writing
Advice from the community
COMMUNITY
Talk to others in the forums
Events and Competitions
GW News
ABOUT GREAT WRITING
All About Us
Contact Us
WORK AWAITING REVIEW
GW IS...
Great Writing creative writing community is designed to prompt ideas and provide inspiration and motivation within aspiring and amateur authors. Whatever your topic; from love poetry to Doctor Who or Harry Potter fan fiction, Great Writing's online writing group is where you can make new friends and improve your creative writing.
WHO'S ONLINE
We have 1617 guests online and 7 members online
Shorts
Benny
By Toad
21 December 2006
     Linda knows what the sound means as soon as she hears it. Although she had been sound asleep- it is 3:36 AM- her mind is clear instantly. She’d never heard a gunshot before, but it sounds just like in the movies. And a gunshot in her home can only mean one thing. Her brain moves at lightning speed, skipping the obvious. Where the hell did he get a gun?
     She doesn’t scream. She doesn’t leap out of bed. There is nothing she can do now. Years of preventing this event melt away in an instant. She slips into sweatpants and throws on a shirt and walks downstairs, feeling both afraid and surprisingly calm. The sound had come from downstairs. You’re about to see your dead son. She reaches the landing and turns towards the kitchen. Just before the kitchen becomes visible comes the second shot. This time she does scream, a quick involuntary yelp. On the floor is Benny. Falling forward, head glancing off the kitchen table and slumping onto the linoleum is Wes.
     Wes she expected, is to some degree prepared for. But Benny? What the hell? His face is nothing but red. It’s not a face anymore. Linda approaches. The shot seems to have been delivered into his head from the top down into his brain. A sure kill. He had fallen on his side, lying in an expanding pool of collective blood from the two dead. Linda staggers around the bodies and leans on the fridge. A mostly empty bottle of rum and crushed cans of root beer are scattered across the counter. Wow, Wes. I really raised a classy drinker. There’s a note. An actual twinge of excitement grabs Linda, and a shiver shoots up her spine. Here are his last words.
     Linda puts her hand on her heart and feels it racing. She becomes aware of her thoughts, which she realizes have been directing her in a clear, slow voice since she sat up in bed. She has to slow down, experience these moments. This is the last time she will ever share with Wes. Damn it, he can’t take this away. In a day his body will be somewhere else, her kitchen will be clean. But damn you Wes, we’re both here now and this is it for us and for once I’m in control, I don’t have to be afraid anymore. Don’t read the note yet. It’s not going anywhere. She grabs a mug, pours some rum, drinks slowly, sipping and holding it to her breast. She addresses Wes out loud. Your mother doesn’t need to mix her liquor. Root beer. You would down a bunch of root beer on your last night. A smile.
     OK, let’s see that note. Mom, I’m sorry about all this. It’s been a life of pain, and I hope you can appreciate that this is the best thing I can do for myself. Yes, son, I can appreciate that. She really can, but now she is seeing him scoring a goal for his 5th grade soccer team. She examines the statement, looking at the body on the floor, then seeing him score a goal. Now it makes sense, now it doesn’t. He used to score so many goals. But he was proudest when the team had a big lead and the coach told them to stop scoring. Then they played keep-away, passing the ball in triangles, striving only to maintain possession. Did you see how we did that? They barely touched the ball in the whole second half! In tenth grade when he quit the team, Linda wanted it to be ok. The drums, the drums, Wes assured her. He was just interested in different things now. But banging on a drum set couldn’t replace the freedom she used to see in him chasing the ball around, the beautiful control of energy he displayed, his natural bent toward the concepts of the game. Passing, he was always such a great passer. Linda saw it as a reflection of a remarkable emotional intelligence. An intelligence which told her that they both knew it wasn’t ok, and he knew that she knew. But so much went unspoken with Wes. The reality in his mind was outrageous, so he learned to simply speak in acceptable terms. He wasn’t trying to fool her when he told her things were good, he just didn’t know how to say that they weren’t.
     You’re probably wondering about Benny. The thing is, he’s been here all night hanging out with me, and I knew he wasn’t going away, and I just couldn’t do it in his presence. He was just staring at me. So I’m sorry about that, but he was getting to be an old dog anyway.

Reviews
HI Toad
Written by jean.day (2196 comments posted) 20th December 2006
You write well, and you have picked a subject which is full of potential. But for some reason I don't believe that your character Linda would have acted as she did. No matter if she was expecting her son to commit suicide, she would not have taken it so calmly.  
 
I'm sorry he shot the dog as well, and again I think Linda takes it all far too calmly. I couldn't stop crying when my dog died of old age and if it was my son who had committed suicide, I would feel like part of me was dead too.

Written by coosh (822 comments posted) 21st December 2006
Enjoyed this, Toad, woke me up, particularly the opening scenes and the ending. Her subsequent almost self-conscious reaction (slow down and experience these moments) suggested to me that maybe there was more behind it, another angle to the story - (an American soccer player with that level of skill was perhaps less believable) - enjoyed the style, well written.
thanks
Written by Toad (99 comments posted) 21st December 2006
Thanks for the input. This is actually the first short story I've ever tried.  
Linda's calm reaction to the situation is meant to reflect that her son's problems (whatever they may be) have worn her down and she had already accepted his imminent death before it happened. I tried to make her pain and grief more thoughtful and wistful, rather than the expected hysterical reaction. her strange reaction is meant to make her an intriguing, ambiguous character, followed by a deeper characterization via her fond memories of Wes. perhaps the central question is how one should judge Linda. of course if I feel the need to explain so much then the story wasn't a total success.  
What did you guys think about the development and revealing of Benny?

Written by Snodlander (501 comments posted) 21st December 2006
Tricked me a couple of times. I thought Wes was going to be an astranged abusive husband that had wrought vengeance by shooting her son then committing suicide. Then I thought it was the other way round. Didn't expect Benny to be a dog. 
 
I didn't have a problem with her reaction. No-one knows how they are going to react in these circumstances, and people do the weirdest things sometimes. There is no right or wrong way to react. 
 
This could be a nice prologue into something longer, maybe her thinking back to what the problems actually were. Was Wes just self-destructive, or did he have some problem or trauma? 
 
And that we are asking these questions is a measure of success. If we didn't give a damn about the characters we wouldn't want to know more. Leaving room for interpretation is a good thing.

Written by Witzl (1585 comments posted) 21st December 2006
I found myself completely caught up in this story. Normally, as soon as I see that a story is about something awful like a murder or other violent crime, I click right off. This is because I am a great weenie and would rather read funny stories or stories with a lot of interesting personal interactions. So that fact that I stuck with your story right to the end (I was hoping that Wes and Benny would be robots, I am afraid) says a lot. If this is your first story, you really ought to keep this up. I wouldn't have posted my first story on this site for all the Stupid in GWB.  
 
Having said that, while I accept Snodlander's opinion that none of us know what we would do in a situation like this, I have to go along with Jean's opinion. I might not have cried at first, but at some point, the tears would have come, even if I had managed to sit down and have a glass of rum. By the way, I loved the fact that line about rootbeer and rum -- 'Wow, I raised a classy drinker.'

Written by Fledermaus (3159 comments posted) 21st December 2006
You tricked me a few times too. I was thinking crime and thriller, when it turned out drama. Somehow I doubt. On one hand I agree with Jean and Witzl, that she is extremely cool under the circumstances (when I was still thinking this was a thriller I actually thought she might be an assasin or something). Yet on the other hand, as Snodlander remarked, who knows what people think and do? 
 
As for the revealing of Benny, that was absolutely brilliant.

Written by Phil (6388 comments posted) 23rd December 2006
I have no problem with Linda's initial reaction. Perhaps a little later she might have shown more overt emotion. 
 
Not sure at all about Benny. This was a moving and powerful piece and the flippant comment, although believable, took some of the emotion away. 
 
Super bit of writing. 
 
Phil.
Benny
Written by JerryWilkins (7 comments posted) 24th December 2006
I enjoyed this very much. Totally suckered by Benny, I thought, as did someone else, that Wes was Linda's husband. 
 
Regarding Linda's reaction, there is no set guideline for what anyone will do in such circumstances. I cried copiously when my dog died but I accepted it calmly when my parents died, mother from a heart attack, father from old age, 89. 
 
No one knows how they will react until it happens, so no problem with Linda. 
 
As suggested before you may, in the future, return to this as an outline for a fuller story. I, for one, would like to know what was Wes' problem? What had Linda done to try and help? Where is 'father'? 
 
As I said, I enjoyed this, keep it up, more would be appreciated. 
 
Good story, punchy, vivid imaging, a story that I 'saw' as I read it. 
 
Thank you. :)  
 
Jerry.

Written by Thatllbemethen (83 comments posted) 3rd January 2007
This story kept me reading. However, I found it unconvincing insofar that the mother's reaction to the whole situation seemed reflective and dreamy instead of shocked and excited. 
 
I was also surprised that the greater part of the suicide note was given over to the dog, when the suicidee was quick to point out the merits of replacing him. 
 
Still, I accept everybody's actions and reactions are individual and different and this remains an intriguing, well constructed piece. 
 
Thanks

   Only registered users can rate and write comments.
   Please login or register.

Powered by AkoComment 2.0!

 Previous item   Next item