Great Writing - Home > Extended > Benmore: Back Side of Beyond, Chapter 1
READING ROOM
Great Writing - Home
Read and review others' work
Articles on writing
Advice from the community
COMMUNITY
Talk to others in the forums
Events and Competitions
GW News
ABOUT GREAT WRITING
All About Us
Contact Us
WORK AWAITING REVIEW
GW IS...
Great Writing creative writing community is designed to prompt ideas and provide inspiration and motivation within aspiring and amateur authors. Whatever your topic; from love poetry to Doctor Who or Harry Potter fan fiction, Great Writing's online writing group is where you can make new friends and improve your creative writing.
WHO'S ONLINE
We have 1777 guests online and 3 members online
Extended Work
Benmore: Back Side of Beyond, Chapter 1
By Witzl
21 December 2006
Don't be shy about criticizing this. It needs it. It has been to ten agents and (in parts)  two competitions, and it has been given the cold shoulder. You will have to be cruel to be kind, here, and I am open to all suggestions, particularly from people who know kids and what they like -- but even from those who don't, who are, for whatever reason, crazy enough to give this a go. I would post this in the 'For Children' section, but I suspect that Alex, the boy who is telling the story, would deeply object to being called a child.

BENMORE:  BACK SIDE OF BEYOND

15 August

   The first thing I want to say is that none of this was my fault. It was all my Mom’s idea.

    Mom won’t admit that she’s made a big mistake. She keeps saying that we’re having an adventure. That being in an entirely new place will teach me to take more initiative. Mom’s big on initiative.

  We’ve been here a month and we’re still in sleeping bags on the floor in a place that has not gotten warm once – and this is summer. If we’re shivering now and needing to wear our coats in August, what’s it going to be like in January?

     In London, I was happy. In London, I had friends. I understood people. We lived in a nice house.

    Now we’ve moved. From London, a city with a cool factor of 99.9%. To Benmore. Which is in a place where the sun hasn’t been anywhere near for the whole month, in August. And the question is WHY?  Why move when things were fine the way they were?

   Well, because Mom says things weren’t fine for her. And now it is no longer just Mom and me, it is Mom and me and the three aunties and a Goth called Arnie. I won’t get into describing them just yet, ‘cause I don’t want to get really depressed.

    It’s 11:30 at night.  I’m sitting here at the computer which Mom and a woman I’m supposed to call Auntie Kathe got installed this afternoon after a lot of swearing and sweating. You wouldn’t think that two grown women would swear that much around a kid, but I’ve learned stuff just listening to them. So now I finally get to use the computer because everybody else has gone to bed. I’m not supposed to be up this late, but who’s going to stop me?

   The computer’s going to be my life line.  I’ve already e-mailed all my friends back home and I’m starting an e-journal, as of this very minute. What else have I got to do? (Besides installing the fire-wall and anti-virus software that it looks like Mom and Kathe – pardon me, Auntie Kathe – never bothered with.)

 My Mom’s American. Which is why I call her Mom and not Mum. When I was little I called her Mum, and she’d always tell me to call her Mom instead. So then at school, whenever we had to write stuff about our mothers, the teacher would always return my compositions with a big X through Mom.  I’d show them to my Mom and she’d just shrug and say Well, it’s not my problem if they want to be rigid and close-minded.  

Mom's weird about a lot of things. For instance, she hates to hear kids calling adults by their first names without using ‘auntie’ or ‘uncle’ first. She’s also someone you don’t talk back to (well you can if you want, but I know better), partly because she’s from New Jersey and grew up tough, and partly because she’s just plain stubborn and kick-ass. So if she wants me to call people aunties, then aunties they will be. Anyway, just to show you the fun and interesting ways I am now spending my time here in beautiful Benmore I’m writing down what I did today. I’ll contrast it with a typical day in London, just to give you an idea.

 MY EXCITING NEW SCHEDULE!!! 

 7:30  Woke up to the sound of two women (one of them being my own mother) screaming and swearing. Turns out that Kathe fell through the rotten floorboards in the hall while examining the wiring in our “new” home. ( It’s not new, actually, it’s about 150 years old.  I mean the home, of course, but it’s probably true about the wiring too.)

   8:00   Got up and helped to clear up the plaster and rubble from the floorboard accident. Does that sound like something you’d enjoy doing at 8:00 in the morning during your summer holiday?

   9:00   Had a breakfast of burnt toast and sour milk. (The toast was burned because Arnie the Goth from hell made it and he freaks out if the toast is only a little bit toasted. Bread cannot look like bread if he’s going to eat it, so every time he makes toast, it has to be as close to charcoal as he can get it without burning the house down. The reason for the milk being sour is that nobody’s been to the store in a couple of days – too busy with all the rewiring and floorboard accidents and stuff.)

  10:00  Helped clean rubble out of garden. Cleaned mouse crap out of kitchen.

  11:00  Took a trip to the local tip to get rid of rubble and plaster dust. Came home. Loaded up car and visited tip two more times. This was probably the biggest thrill of my day.

  12:-00  Lunch break. Dined on cold left-over omelette and soggy chips from last night’s evening meal.

   Okay, that’s enough of that. You get the picture, I’m sure. Now compare that with a typical day in my life a month and a half ago, before we moved:

MY LONDON SCHOOL HOLIDAY SCHEDULE

   11:00  Wake up and make myself something tasty and edible for breakfast. (Mom’s already at work by this time, so I can spread as much jam on my toast as I like and leave stuff out of the fridge without her screaming at me.)

   11:45   Go meet friends and hang out with them.

      6:00    Go home and have dinner with Mom. Sometimes even eat out at places that have more on the menu than soggy chips and deep fried haggis.

       See the difference?  Okay, now I’ve depressed myself again. I’m going to bed and I may not get up at all tomorrow morning.

16 August

   Well, I’d have stayed in bed all day long if it’d been up to me, but Mom’s got a way about her. Put a cattle prod in her hand and she’d do fine as one of those high security prison wardens. In fact wipe that first part – Mom doesn’t need the cattle prod.

   Kathe and Mom have been clearing the rubble out of the garden all day long. Arnie got out of doing this for some reason. Weasel.

   So I got stuck with dragging these big bags of rubble to the car and one of them broke and leaked rubble and plaster dust everywhere. So Mom yells at me for dragging the bag instead of lifting it and guess who has to clean up all the mess?  Ever tried to get plaster dust off of loose gravel?  

   School starts in a couple of days and for the first time in my life I’m actually really looking forward to it.

17 August

   It has just occurred to me that I haven’t yet explained who everybody is. Might as well do it now and get it over with:

   First of all, there is Kathe, the mother of Arnie, the Goth.  Kathe worked as a florist in London and got tired of it. She says London has too much pollution and the chavs in Arnie’s school were a bad influence on him. Arnie’s got a couple of rings in his nose and dresses entirely in black. He walks around with this dead-eyed expression all the time and he won’t talk to anybody, so it’s kind of scary to imagine kids who are a bad influence on him.  Kathe and Mom have been singing the ‘Gosh-I’m-glad-to-be-out-of-London’ song ever since the first day we got here. Kathe talks baby-talk to houseplants and has quarrels with things like drains, table legs and the corners of cabinets.  She has this thing about spending money, too. She’s always going on about how you could have bought something for £2 but you went and bought it for £2.15 instead. Like, big deal! Mom went shopping and brought home tinned tomatoes and Auntie Kathe freaked out ‘cause Mom had bought the organic ones that cost 39 p a tin (on special offer, Mom kept pointing out), whereas the ones Auntie Kathe usually buys are only 18 p a tin and she can’t tell the difference. All that fuss over 21 p – is that pathetic or what?

 Next is Ellie. She can do anything. Cook meals, bake cakes with fancy icing on them, fix furniture, knock down walls, build things, sew stuff, repair machines – you name it, she can do it. She’s strong too, and bossy, and kind of a show-off.  The first day we were here, Mom complained that the hoover was heavy. So what does Ellie do? She picks it up – with her little finger (and it really does weigh a ton) – and carries it up the stairs. Okay, if I hadn’t seen it, I wouldn’t have believed it either, but trust me, it happened. She scares me, she’s that tough (she says it’s ‘cause she grew up in Glasgow, which I think is kind of like New Jersey). She’s got a temper too. I’ve seen her lose it a couple of times already. Knowing about her temper makes me nervous, especially after seeing her with the hoover that time. I mean, if she can do that with her little finger what could she do with, like, her whole hand?

   Mom says you could set Auntie Ellie down on a desert island with a hammer and some driftwood and in a year’s time she’d have built her own town. If I saw her, say, build an airplane, hop in it and fly it around the house, I wouldn’t be the least bit surprised. That’s the kind of person she is.

  Last but not least of the aunties is Lorene. This is a woman who dresses like it’s still 1968. She wears long skirts and hiking boots, and she’s seriously into chakras and auras. She’s sort of bogus. You’d just have to meet her to see what I mean. Lorene talks a lot. Mom and the others have been doing stuff ever since we got here, but Auntie Lorene just seems to stand around and talk all the time.

 Finally there is Arnie, my new roommate. He’s a year older than me, but you’d think he was at least that much younger. He’s kind of dark, skinny and weasely, that’s the only way I can describe him. If you were a Martian and Arnie was the only person you’d ever seen, you’d assume that all humans had a mobile phone attached to their hands. I’ve never seen him without his. Not once.  And he doesn’t talk on his phone, either, he just presses its buttons all day long. In fact he doesn’t talk at all. Or at least not around me.

 That’s the lot. You know what Mom tells me? That they’re my new family. That we’re all going to work together and play together and bond into a family. Please.

Reviews

Written by Toad (106 comments posted) 21st December 2006
The only constructive thought I had is that it might be more engaging if there was more about actual interaction between the speaker and the other characters, as opposed to descriptions and storytelling. I think it's fine to write without actual dialogue, but there should still be conversation and interaction.  
I really liked that the Goth liked his toast burnt.

Written by Witzl (1585 comments posted) 21st December 2006
Thank you, Toad. That is a helpful comment, and I love doing dialogue. I posted a short story that summed up 'Benmore' earlier, and one of the comments made was that it would be good to have the perspective of some of the adults, too, that this gets static when it is just the boy monologuing. Ever since reading that comment, I have thought about how I can rewrite this, incorporating observations from Alex's mother. After reading your comment, I think it would be fun to look at this from a neutral perspective as well. So I will see if I can weave all of these things other elements into the story. Thank God for computers. And I am very grateful to have all the readers on GW, too, to help me come to these conclusions.
HI Witzl
Written by jean.day (2366 comments posted) 21st December 2006
Good first chapter - but in my creative writing class where everybody was writing novels the teacher was a big stickler on having an inciting incident as soon as possible to hook the reader in. So far in your story you have a very bored boy with his collection of aunties and you do a good job of describing everybody - but I as the reader have no idea what sort of adventure or trauma is going to happen later on, which I might need to encourage me to keep reading. 
 
I don't know from what you have written whether Alex considers himself an American or not - probably not. In which case he wouldn't use gotten - an Americanism that I am always having to change. Second nature to us, incorrect to the English. 
 
Do you really get your kids to call you Mom when all their friends have Mums? I was always Mum from the time mine could interact with other children.  
 
I created a real embarrasing situation for them, without intending, by teaching them to eat like I do. They were criticised and laughed at when they started school - and blamed me for it, rightly. But I still eat how I was taught.

Written by Witzl (1585 comments posted) 22nd December 2006
This is good advice, Jean, and my husband will be particularly pleased because it is exactly what he has been telling me! 'Too much teenage angst, not enough action.' I am going to change that first chapter right away and I've got just the thing: a plaster ceiling caving in. This happened in our house, and I've only just gotten over it. Very dramatic, and hopefully exciting enough, if I embellish it. I really appreciate your pointing this out to me. 
 
I haven't worked too hard to get my kids to call me 'Mom;' though oddly enough, in Japan I was always 'okaasan,' the formal for 'mother,' and nothing I said could persuade them to call me 'Mama,' which is what a lot of Japanese kids call their mothers. I made Alex's mother American to cover precisely the kind of infelicity I knew would creep in -- sneaky little 'gottens,' the odd American idiom, etc. But I do try to edit out my 'gottens' from writing, when I can remember to do it. (In speech, I insist on using them: 'gotten' is, after all, the old strong past perfect of 'get,' used back in Shakespeare's time!) As for table manners, I am still well ahead of my kids, and they do not copy me or my husband.  
 
The way I see it, all kids will find something to blame their parents for, right or wrong. Being American, I know that I do some things differently and my different behavior will no doubt rub off on my children. But occasionally I get credit for being different, too. One friend of my daughter's told me shyly, in the broadest possible Scots, that my accent was 'cool.' What accent?

Written by johniebg (553 comments posted) 3rd January 2007
... there is definately something wrong with this but not sure I can put my finger on the problem but will give it a good go. As an adult reading this it didn't pull me in, although there is lots of talking around the two women they are not created in any way in the mind, you feel for the kid but by not knowing more of the why they moved you dont get to buy into his frustration (think its a he), instead the reader gets frustrated, maybe the journal could have been earlier - although I have to admit I gave up just when it started comparing to London. Apart from the description of Benmore's weather there is nothing about the place that draws you in either, maybe done with a wry sense of humour and more locality. 
 
This reminds me a lot of the longer essays you posted here about august of 2006 where there was alot of crafted prose but not enough that brought the reader into the moment, your later stories were much tighter and engaging. 
 
If this is meant to be written for children then it simply fails because it isnt written from a childs point of view, it sounds like an adult writing what a child might think. 
 
Not much good news but is honest. There is lots of your writing that I love, this just is not one of them, I would guess you wrote this a long while back, might be worth rethinking, what was I trying to say in this?

   Only registered users can rate and write comments.
   Please login or register.

Powered by AkoComment 2.0!

 Previous item   Next item