READING ROOM
Great Writing - Home
Read and review others' work
Articles on writing
Advice from the community
COMMUNITY
Talk to others in the forums
Events and Competitions
GW News
ABOUT GREAT WRITING
All About Us
Contact Us
WORK AWAITING REVIEW
GW IS...
Great Writing creative writing community is designed to prompt ideas and provide inspiration and motivation within aspiring and amateur authors. Whatever your topic; from love poetry to Doctor Who or Harry Potter fan fiction, Great Writing's online writing group is where you can make new friends and improve your creative writing.
WHO'S ONLINE
We have 1419 guests online and 5 members online
Shorts
Excerpt
By Toad
18 January 2007
This is an excerpt from a long piece I'm working on. The chapters alternate between present tense and narrative sections which progress through the protagonist's past. Hope you enjoy.

                When I was nine my family attended a relative’s wedding. During the reception, I kept to myself. I avoided the other kids, because I thought that they were weird. With my parents and sister up and mingling, I had nowhere to sit without being a sitting duck for some strange woman to come ask me why I wasn’t playing with the other kids, or to stoop down to my eye level and strike up a conversation in which she inexcusably asked me what I wanted to be when I grew up. I always wanted to tell people that when I grew up I wanted to be someone who didn’t ask kids what they wanted to be when they grew up.
                One person who would undoubtedly not ask that question was my great-uncle Walt. I had never met him, but Jen had told me about him. He had lived alone for a long time, and was an alcoholic. When he became too old to take care of himself his daughter took him in. Deprived of his booze, he was more miserable than ever.
                He sat alone in one of the hall’s large circular tables, which could seat nine. He was quite a sight. Unhappiness emanated from his general area.
                I was drawn to him. I fixed a plate of food and sat down at his table, leaving one chair between us. I took my seat without smiling or even making eye contact, saying only “Hi,” and then began eating. He regarded me silently and suspiciously, then resumed his business, which was scowling and ferociously clearing his throat. I loved it; two lone wolves. I could tell I had thrown him off, though, by not doing anything to justify one of the nasty responses that he gave to maintain his solitary possession of the table. When I rose to get another plate of food I asked him if he wanted me to bring him anything. He grunted that he could get his own damn food. That response amused me, because he obviously still had no justification to be rude to me, I hadn’t crossed any of his lines, but he was pitifully groping at his best chance to keep up appearances.
                When I sat down again he stared at me for half a minute or so. Finally, he said “You’re a smart kid, aren’t ya?” I nodded. “Maybe you can tell me something.” He turned to glare at the next table, where a group of guests, including his daughter, had been continuously breaking out in loud bursts of laughter. “Tell me what the hell is so goddamn funny.”
                After a few moments, all I could say was “I’m sorry, I don’t know.” We resumed our silence, but those words had instantly burrowed into a nook in my brain that they would never relinquish. He could have talked for hours without revealing as much as he had in that sentence. In the end, the laughter stops. It was never real, it could maintain only until old age’s indifference to consequence pulls its plug. When it’s all said and done, you still don’t know what the hell was so funny. My Uncle Walt had lit fire to my suspicions that the happy arc of life may not be for everyone, that the world and its people were not necessarily aligned correctly. A few minutes later his daughter came by to check on him. She was baffled by my choice of company. “Why aren’t you playing with the other children?”

Reviews
Tops.
Written by NeilTollfree (51 comments posted) 18th January 2007
That's really nice stuff. I definately want to read more. I like his joy at being 'two lone wolves.' And I loved the fact that they didn't bond, that he didn't see something in the kid that reminded him of himself and they became great pals and all that guff.  
 
I'm not sure about the opening paragraph. Two 'sit's in close proximity and is 'inexcusably' the right word. Feels odd. 
 
Looking forward to more of this though.

Written by Phil (6645 comments posted) 18th January 2007
This was a very well written scene. Liked it a lot. Very easy read, but it had some depth to it too. One criticism would be the last line. I know you set it up early on and in many ways, it works well, I just didn't think its flippant tone quite fitted the rest. Perhaps it's just me. 
 
Really very good. 
 
Phil.

Written by Snodlander (501 comments posted) 19th January 2007
I enjoyed it, but if the whole book is in such a sombre mood, I'm not sure how much of it I could enjoy. 
 
A couple of typos in the last para 
 
' instantly burrowed a nook' should read ' instantly burrowed into a nook' 
 
'in at sentence.' should read 'in that sentence.' 
 
And I quite liked the last line.

Written by Fledermaus (3238 comments posted) 19th January 2007
Heheh... Some people just enjoy being grumpy. Seems that in your own way you and uncle Walt made the best of it. But then, pretending to enjoy yourself is probably even worse...

Written by Witzl (1585 comments posted) 19th January 2007
This cheered me up somehow: the thought of a savvy kid and a grumpy old git sitting together and enjoying a few dour moments, not bonding, as NeilTollFree has said -- it makes a good vignette. Personally I am more of a 'What is there that is NOT funny?' type, but I believe that people should not have to conform to the moods of others; if you feel like being a grouch, you might as well be a grouch. Though of course you won't get invited to many weddings. . . 
 
I didn't think the two uses of 'sit' here were infelicitous: the first 'sit' is used as a verb and 'sitting duck' is a figure of speech. I think I might have gone for 'obnoxiously' instead of 'inexcusably,' but I too find that 'What are you going to be . . .?' question pretty inexcusable. I hated it when I was a kid, and used to give really arcane job descriptions. The adult was then forced to engage in a proper conversation with me to find out what it was that the job entailed.  
 
Good writing, Toad.

Written by Toad (100 comments posted) 19th January 2007
It's interesting for me to see the differing effects this piece had on its readers.  
I think that the whole first paragraph is rather shaky, and I'll probably revise it eventually.  
I try not to write in too "sombre" of a mood, but I do tend towards it. I do my best to find a balance between "down" and "up."  
Thanks for the comments, and the typo spotting.

   Only registered users can rate and write comments.
   Please login or register.

Powered by AkoComment 2.0!

 Previous item   Next item