READING ROOM
Great Writing - Home
Read and review others' work
Articles on writing
Advice from the community
COMMUNITY
Talk to others in the forums
Events and Competitions
GW News
ABOUT GREAT WRITING
All About Us
Contact Us
WORK AWAITING REVIEW
GW IS...
Great Writing creative writing community is designed to prompt ideas and provide inspiration and motivation within aspiring and amateur authors. Whatever your topic; from love poetry to Doctor Who or Harry Potter fan fiction, Great Writing's online writing group is where you can make new friends and improve your creative writing.
WHO'S ONLINE
We have 1180 guests online and 2 members online
Non-Fiction
Pants
By anorwegianwood
20 February 2007
Why is it that so much of what I write is about music and insubstantial clothing?  Write what you know, they say...

This is one of my fondest memories of high school.  The first time I wrote it, the message didn't come across well.  I rewrote it to be obvious--too obvious.  This is the average of the two versions.  Let me know what you think of the ending.

Since this is a UK community, I will add this: Please, for the sake of my own dignity, mentally edit "pants" to "trousers" if needed.  Don't go wandering down the dark and twisted paths of the R-rated.  Clean minds, okay?


“Did you bring your form?”

“No.”

“Sarah, it was due last week!”

“Don’t worry, Mr. Vogel, I’ll write it on my hand.”

My orchestra conductor watches half in exasperation, half in amusement as Sarah adds another reminder to the back of her left hand.  Or rather, her left wrist.  Her hand is already blue with the smeared ink of several other reminders.  An epidermal to-do list.  Among the homework assignments and phone numbers, the message “Bring form!” appears to have already been written there, just below her knuckles.  She adds a few extra exclamation points to the new note on her wrist, just to be safe.

To an outside observer, it must be hard to believe that this rather scatter-brained seventeen-year-old is, in fact, one of the most gifted violinists my high school has ever known.  Concertmaster since her freshman year, pride of the music department, Sarah can play Bach’s infamously difficult Chaconne, but can’t seem to remember to turn in a permission slip for, of all things, an orchestra trip.  This forgetfulness is easily forgotten, however, in the light of her musical talent.

During class, Mr. Vogel usually seats underclassmen with upperclassmen, just to help pull them along, even if they won’t actually play together during the concert.  As a lowly sophomore and one of the few underclassmen first violins, I found myself seated next to Sarah, and often feeling a bit overwhelmed.  I’m no prodigy, but I can play well enough.  Sitting next to a prodigy, however, can make anyone feel like a complete beginner.  To hear Sarah sight read Dvorak, a task that makes most string players start whimpering within the first six measures, is enough to make most student musicians wonder just where exactly they’d been going wrong all these years, and why they were still bothering to practice at all.

Sarah caps her pen, picks up her bow, and looks expectantly at Mr. Vogel who, with a slight shrug, gives the downbeat.
 

The next day, I walk to my orchestra class as I always do, calmly unaware of everything going on around me, my mind on what I’ll have for lunch.  My thoughts are suddenly interrupted and my path blocked, however, by a rather panicked-looking girl holding a cake of violin rosin in her ink-stained hand.

“Can I borrow your pants?”

It takes me a moment to register what Sarah has just said.  “My what?”

“Your pants, can I borrow them?  Just for this class period.”

I look down at my black corduroys, then back up at her wide eyes.  Not knowing what else to say, I try, “Okay?”

“Great!”  Sarah grabs my hand and pulls me into the nearest girls’ room.  A girl fixing her eyeliner in the mirror looks up in surprise as Sarah enters the bathroom at a dash, me at a stumble.  After setting her rosin on the edge of one of the sinks, Sarah starts undressing and explaining.

“I’m supposed to play in a quartet for some guests of the school during this class period.  Vogel wants us in all black.”

“And you wore…”

“Jeans and a red T-shirt.”  She appears to have already swapped shirts with someone, but her faded jeans are resolutely unblack.  “Quick,” she cries, motioning frantically for me to remove my own pants, “I haven’t even tuned yet!”

I kick off my boots and take off my pants.  Sarah, a bit taller than me, pulls them on quickly and just manages to button them.  A little too much sock shows, but it’s close enough.  I pull on her jeans, rolling up the cuffs a bit to keep from tripping.  The girl with the eyeliner watches us in the mirror with a confused expression on her face, the liner still only halfway to her eye.

Sarah slips back into her shoes and runs out the door, calling a hurried “thanks!” over her shoulder.  After a few seconds, the door bursts open again.  I wordlessly hand her forgotten rosin cake to her.



“Did you bring your form?”

“No, but I’ll write it on my hand.”

If Mr. Vogel knows about yesterday’s clothing switch-off, he’s not saying anything.  Sarah played her performance, and we both met up in the bathroom to return each other’s pants.  Today, there is no need to swap clothing, but the permission slip is still MIA.  Next to me, Sarah is rummaging in her bag, checking all the pockets for the pen she’s mislaid.  It’s a strange feeling, being simultaneously awed by someone’s musical gift and amazed by their persistent forgetfulness.  It doesn’t seem at all unusual when an average high school student forgets a homework assignment, but it’s somehow harder to believe that someone with a talent worthy of Julliard could forget her own concert.  Who would have thought that such a person is a regular teenager?  I’m just contemplating this new revelation when Sarah resurfaces.

“Can I borrow a pen?”

I smile and reach for my bag.

Reviews
Nice story
Written by richard (88 comments posted) 20th February 2007
This is a nice story and well put together, except that of course the pay off in real life doesn't always do justice to the set up.  
 
As a piece of writing it's great. Holds the interest, seems to work well. Only thing is that the ending is a bit of a let down after the comedy of the pants change episode - which you could have spun out much more as I suspect this must have been hilarious.  
 
Have you thought about usiing this as the basis for a short story - the forgetful musical genius is a great start for a character, and the incident of forgetting to wear the right clothes is a great start for a story. You could let it go wild! 
 
I enjoyed it as it was, but you could have some real fun with this a story....
Richard: Funny you should say that...
Written by anorwegianwood (278 comments posted) 20th February 2007
As a matter of fact, this may become part of a larger work. I'm currently working on a collection of embellished memoirs of the various bizarre things that happened in my high school orchestra (and there were many ;) ). I posted part one of The Dorkestra in extended works, but I've discovered since then that I can't write it in order. I've been doing bits of it here and there, and I've found that some things I needed to write as they actually happened before going back a little later and changing things to suit the overall plot and characters I've created. Thanks for the nice review! 
 
~Claire

Written by Phil (6836 comments posted) 20th February 2007
Lovely story. I'd agree with Richard about the ending if this were fiction, but it isn't and you handled it very well. 
 
Well written, it drew me in from the start. You've structured this cleverly to make it read like a piece of fiction - probably why Richard mentioned the ending. 
 
He is right, you could have some real fun with this if you fictionalised it. 
 
Good stuff, 
 
Phil.

Written by ellipinnock (1753 comments posted) 21st February 2007
pants duly edited to trousers! I liked this - an entertaining read that trotted along nicely. One minor point - there are quite a few exclamation marks in this piece - I reckon at least some of them are extraneous. 
 
Good anecdote - a fictionalised collection of these might be very good indeed though it'll need a fair amount of work to maintain interest over a longer time period I reckon. I thought you did a good job though - it's not easy to write an interesting high school piece without going all 'teen' about it. I don't think I'm making sense anymore so I'll shut up and just say I liked it! 
 
Elli

Written by SJP (7 comments posted) 21st February 2007
I thought this was a nice piece, it is friendly and fun. I think any longer and it would have lost it;s impact, the ending was my favourite part, very succient!

Written by Kathy (220 comments posted) 27th February 2007
I managed to sneak aside a bit of time to read this and I'm really glad that I did. It was great fun.  
 
My take on this is that sometimes people who are very talented can be disorganised in everyday life because - it is as if their talent (whatever that may be) takes up so much effort. My son is gifted academically, taking exams early etc., but his bedroom is a total No-Go zone and he is ALWAYS loosing things ... very frustrating. 
 
Your descriptions create a very clear picture in the mind of the reader and I sense a very obsevervant and shrewd mind - if I may be so bold!! 
 
Love, "An epidermal to-do list" and the timing of "I wordlessly hand her forgotten roisin cake to her". Really good stuff and very easy to read. 
 
I also loved the ending.  
 
Regards, 
Kathy

Written by alamo (32 comments posted) 19th March 2007
I like the ending too, and also agree with Kathy about the "epidermal to-do list".  
 
Also liked "Sarah enters the bathroom at a dash, me at a stumble." Good contrast. 
 
Quality
Written by johniebg (553 comments posted) 21st March 2007
This is quality for all the simple reasons. It is mostly in the way you describe Sarah, which is what makes this so special. It is in the un-emotional but glorious detail - the writing down the arm, the cake which I have never heard of but imagine comes in a small plastic pot, describing her talents without awe or worship. 
 
I have no idea what fun anyone might think you could of had if this was fiction, it was all the better for its reality. 
 
Heading over to the rest of your stuff ... admittedly 'pants' did draw me in for all the wrong reasons, but then I am English and the prospect of a story about pants not trousers ...
Johniebg:
Written by anorwegianwood (278 comments posted) 21st March 2007
Thank you so much for the lovely review. I'm so glad you enjoyed it. :grin  
 
~Claire

Written by austheke (35 comments posted) 5th May 2007
very fun. do you know how often i've actually seen this happen? a lot of times. i've got a bunch of orchestra friends. i avoid wearing black on their performance days. or white. 
 
it's very nice. i like it. made me smile.

   Only registered users can rate and write comments.
   Please login or register.

Powered by AkoComment 2.0!

 Previous item   Next item