Great Writing - Home > Short S. > Sonora Heat Wave
READING ROOM
Great Writing - Home
Read and review others' work
Articles on writing
Advice from the community
COMMUNITY
Talk to others in the forums
Events and Competitions
GW News
ABOUT GREAT WRITING
All About Us
Contact Us
WORK AWAITING REVIEW
GW IS...
Great Writing creative writing community is designed to prompt ideas and provide inspiration and motivation within aspiring and amateur authors. Whatever your topic; from love poetry to Doctor Who or Harry Potter fan fiction, Great Writing's online writing group is where you can make new friends and improve your creative writing.
WHO'S ONLINE
We have 2678 guests online and 6 members online
Shorts
Sonora Heat Wave
By bwoz
04 March 2007
It was suggested I post this as prose, derived from a poem titled "Sonora Wave" I posted two days ago. Since there is no category for "essay" or "prose" I put it here. This is for comparison -- whether this piece reads better as prose or as a poem.  The Poem is attached here after the prose section so you won't have to navigate around if you want to compare.

So. Is it poetry or is it prose?


Sonora Heat Wave (prose)

The high-noon Sonoran sky is a blast furnace, 110 degrees of dry heat. So hot the lizards can only survive in shade; if they move too slowly they blister and die.  I step into this gloom of brightness that bakes the old adobe walls like an ancient curse. The sun hound scorches;
turns my shoes into oven bricks. 

I stumble into three rumpled old men sitting outside the dog track. They came in one blighted day some 40 years ago on the boom-town Copper Express; they melted here, then just as now.  They laugh at my suffering as I shade my face and cross the road.  The shadows sweat, then swallow my eyes while terracotta steps splash heat when I walk by.

“Yo, hombre, you got feefty?” One of them asks. I think to myself ‘Goddamn dogs won’t run, can’t even die good in this shit.’

“Yeah man, I put fifty down on a silver Greyhound named Westbound headed for the coast ‘cause its basic survival now.” I tell him.  I drag my brick feet into a saloon to wait for my midnight escape.  The beer is cold but there is no forgiveness here.

Finally, darkness arrives like anger, the temperature still at 105.  Ghostly shapes stir and gather in the aching hume.   Hatted silhouettes of machismo trickle from dark doorways.  They circle and sneer, nod at each other leaning into their own shadows like herons perched on the adobe walls; like the grey herons they call blue.

They become a mirage in the moonlight, just a glassy promise, smoky dull; a sidewalk peep-show of phantom pleasure that will all be dust by morning.  I float away from the bar on beer fumes and hot cement with a ticket in my shirt pocket, past the dog track and a surly prostitute teasing three old men.  Those melted old men. They bet the 3 and 5 daily double and coaxed another lizard from the grey heron’s mouth.


Sonora Wave (Poem)

The high-noon Sonoran sky is a blast furnace,
110 degrees of dry heat. So hot
the lizards can only survive in shade,
or they blister and die.

I step into this gloom of brightness
that bakes the old adobe walls
like an ancient curse.

The sun hound scorches;
turns my shoes into oven bricks. 

I stumble into some rumpled old men
sitting outside the dog track. They came in
one blighted day some 40 years ago
on the boom-town Copper Express

they melted here, then just as now

They laugh at my suffering
as I shade my face and cross the road.
The shadows sweat, then swallow my eyes
while terracotta steps splash heat
when I walk by.

Yo, hombre, you got feefty?

I think to myself
Goddamn dogs won’t run,
can’t even die good in this shit.

Yeah man, I put fifty down
on a silver Greyhound named Westbound
headed for the coast ‘cause its basic survival now
I drag my brick feet into a saloon
to wait for my midnight escape.
The beer is cold but there is no forgiveness here.

Finally, darkness arrives like anger,
the temperature still at 105.
Ghostly shapes stir and gather in the aching hume

Hatted silhouettes of machismo trickle from dark doorways.
They circle and sneer, nod at each other,
leaning into their adobe shadows like perched herons;
like the grey herons they call blue.

They become a mirage in the moonlight 
just a glassy promise, smoky dull
a sidewalk peep-show of phantom pleasure
It will all be dust by morning

I float away from the bar on beer fumes and hot cement
with a ticket in my shirt pocket, past the dog track
and a surly prostitute teasing three old men.

Those melted old men. They bet
the 3 and 5 daily double
and coaxed another lizard from the grey heron’s mouth.


Reviews
Prose
Written by twriter (117 comments posted) 4th March 2007
Hi, 
 
I first read this (due to the way you had posted) as prose and really enjoyed it. I feel that it works both ways but somehow I preferred the feel that the prose gave me more than the poem, leading me through the story. 
 
It's up to you though! 
 
TW
Poetry
Written by Phil (6713 comments posted) 4th March 2007
A good piece of prose, but I prefer the original poem - it has more impact. As a piece of prose I feel it's missing a sentence or two here or there to allow it to flow fully. As poetry, the ideas add up to a sum greater than the parts.  
 
Just an opinion. 
 
Phil
Poetry
Written by jfofnian (18 comments posted) 4th March 2007
It's a tough one and it certainly flows well as prose, but since it's a very poetic style of writing and the line structure of the poem gives it slightly more resonance, I'll vote poetry. 
 
Brilliantly evocative piece, either way.
Prose...
Written by anorwegianwood (278 comments posted) 4th March 2007
...but I'm a biased judge. I almost always prefer prose to poetry, just as a matter of personal taste. It works very well either way, though. Really nice imagery in this piece. I especially like "The shadows sweat, then swallow my eyes while terracotta steps splash heat when I walk by." 
 
Claire

Written by Bottleblondesurfer (3351 comments posted) 5th March 2007
I really enjoyed it as a prose piece, for me if flowed better and I was more drawn into it. Poetry can sometimes be a bit self concious and the strucure of it fractures the narrative. 
I felt the heat of it in the prose piece, it enveloped me. Either way if was a brilliantly descriptive piece 
J
The votes are in, Prose it is
Written by bwoz (125 comments posted) 5th March 2007
And I was sure I had written a poem. Thank you all for commenting and offering valuable suggestions and opinions.  
 
I normally do write poems like this out in prose format first -- as I did this. And I guess it shows when I try to convert it to poetry.  
 
Still, I was hoping the poem would ring a louder bell for most, as far as being more "out there" and descriptive. When I read it I imagine a Mickey Spilane voice in my head, maybe that helps. 
 
Thanks a bunch, you all have point many good things out and I appreciate it a bunch. 
 
BW

Written by ellipinnock (1753 comments posted) 6th March 2007
Well as it is I reckon you're a bit betwixt and between. If it was me I think I'd either condense the poem which does get a bit prosy in places or expand the prose. At the moment the prose reads a little jerky and gappy for me, I'd have liked some of theblanks filing in. Either way it's a good piece and interesting given the recent discussions about the border between prose and poetry. 
 
Elli

   Only registered users can rate and write comments.
   Please login or register.

Powered by AkoComment 2.0!

 Previous item   Next item