Great Writing - Home > Short S. > A Bird Whistling Wonderful Melodies
READING ROOM
Great Writing - Home
Read and review others' work
Articles on writing
Advice from the community
COMMUNITY
Talk to others in the forums
Events and Competitions
GW News
ABOUT GREAT WRITING
All About Us
Contact Us
WORK AWAITING REVIEW
GW IS...
Great Writing creative writing community is designed to prompt ideas and provide inspiration and motivation within aspiring and amateur authors. Whatever your topic; from love poetry to Doctor Who or Harry Potter fan fiction, Great Writing's online writing group is where you can make new friends and improve your creative writing.
WHO'S ONLINE
We have 1265 guests online and 8 members online
Shorts
A Bird Whistling Wonderful Melodies
By foxmulder
12 March 2007
It's probably not very funny to be honest, but my friends laugh at it.

A Bird Whistling Wonderful Melodies

By Fox Mulder

Written 04/03/2007



Bertie sat alone on a bench and prepared to eat his lunch. He was at a clearing in a forest that had been specifically designed for tourists to use as a place to picnic. There was nobody else around and this pleased Bertie as he preferred to eat alone. He lifted his plastic lunch box onto his lap and raised its hinged plastic lid, which revealed an immaculately prepared strawberry jam sandwich. Feeling very hungry from his mornings walk Bertie placed both his hands into the box, one hand pinching either side of the sandwich, and lifted the food towards his mouth. It could only have been two inches from his lips when he first heard the whistle and, astonished at its remarkable beauty, Bertie decided to postpone his lunch for a few seconds so that he could listen some more.


The whistling was emanating from somewhere nearby but, due to the acoustics of the clearing, he could not discern its exact location. In fear of frightening whatever it was that was producing the sounds Bertie sat dead still and simply listened. What a wonderful melody it was; so harmonious and magical, such a contrast to the sounds of the city. Bertie soaked the music up, breathed in the fresh spring air of the forest and, with a wide smile on his face, decided to continue his lunch. Again, the sandwich could only have been two inches from his lips when he was interrupted. This time, the sound was far from beautiful; it was a bang, a roaring explosion with such force that it rattled all the leaves on the trees.


The shot silenced the woodland and the whistling stopped in an instant. It took Bertie a few moments to make sense of the carcass on his lap, the blood from its beak seeping into the bread, indistinguishable from the jam.





 

Reviews
Which bit?
Written by Bottleblondesurfer (3331 comments posted) 12th March 2007
Which bit do your friends laugh at specifically? 
I suppose humour is subjective but it sounds as if a fox hunt ending in bloody death would have them peeing themselves; do they have to eat with plastic knives?  
Humour can be shocking, tasteless, un-PC, even offensive but that does need to be leavened with some genuine comedy. I couldn't find it 
cheers 
J
re: above
Written by foxmulder (4 comments posted) 12th March 2007
You're absolutely correct of course. There is no "happy ending" so it is not a comedy in the modern sense. 
 
I guess my friends laughter is instinctive and that they are laughing at the abrupt, absurd ending to the otherwise pleasent piece, rather than the subject itself. 
 
It's really only a doodle, an exercise in style and form, but yes perhaps I have placed this in the wrong section...

Written by Phil (6683 comments posted) 12th March 2007
It is absurd. It's actually pretty well contructed - but it ain't funny. With BBS on this one.  
 
Phil
Yes
Written by givitsum (651 comments posted) 12th March 2007
Yep, wrong section. As Phil & Mrs. B. said, there's nothiig wrong with the writing, its just not funny, which is a bit of a prerequisite for the comedy lounge. 
 
G
Bwah-ha or Boo-hoo
Written by stevetroster (1549 comments posted) 13th March 2007
I cried at the end, poor little dickie! 
No it's not funny unless you are warped, but where else could you put it? (no rude answers please). 
However, if the critiques of your work are funny in themselves, then perchance this is the correct location for it after all. 
Peeing oneself over a fox hunt!...perchance she dreams of a foxmulder hunt? 
 
Best wishes 
 
Estee.
Wake up!
Written by gerardconnolly (1186 comments posted) 13th March 2007
Please don't insult our intelligence. This is not a script. Many of us work hard to make 'Comedy Scripts' different and posting prose on the site makes me wonder whether you can read English. It says 'Comedy Scripts'. What is difficult to understand about that? Script: direction of the spoken word. Prose: non metric narrative continuity. Simple. 
 
What makes it galling is that there are a good number of promising scripters who work hard to improve themselves and encourage others on this forum. This kind of crass thoughtlessness makes a nonesense of what they and the GW site are all about.  
 
My advice is to do us all a favour and place it somewhere else.
RE: above
Written by foxmulder (4 comments posted) 14th March 2007
"gerard connolly" -  
 
I think your comment was rather hostile, to be honest. 
 
I have already admitted to posting this under the wrong section (look above in the comments). The reason I did this is because I had already put a piece in the 'short story' section and I didn't want to 'flood' that board by putting another on immediately. I thought this piece might get away with 'comedy', due to it's absurdity. I was wrong. 
 
I would love to change this to another section. Perhaps instead of ranting about how I'm insulting your intelligence you could actually HELP me by letting me know how to move the piece somewhere else? God knows I've tried. 
 
Just like you - all I want is for my writing to be read.
Gerard is right.
Written by saracen (10 comments posted) 14th March 2007
Gerard is absolutely correct. No way is this a script. What is the point of having a scripts section if people can't tell the difference between that and prose!? God save us its hardly rocket science. And if the author can't decide what his or her creation is, how the hell is the reader expected to know? I have no idea where you should put it, but Stevie Wonder could see it doesn't belong here. 
 
I don't think his comment was in any way a rant. Rather a well deserved roasting. Learn to live with it.
RE: above
Written by foxmulder (4 comments posted) 14th March 2007
Look - I've posted a piece in the wrong section, I haven't killed anyone! Give me a break! 
 
If any moderator can remove it, please do so. I don't know how and people would rather 'roast' me than help it seems.

Written by ellipinnock (1753 comments posted) 14th March 2007
Well you've ruffled a few feathers here sweetie, not bad for your first post  
 
Click on 'view my existing work' (top ish left when signed in) then click on the title of the 'offending' piece (lol) and you'll see a drop down menu with all of the categories - simply choose a new one and then resave the piece and bingo, it should appear elsewhere!  
 
Hope that helps. 
 
Elli 
 
ps. It's a very bizarre piece! That being neither compliment nor criticism... :grin

   Only registered users can rate and write comments.
   Please login or register.

Powered by AkoComment 2.0!

 Previous item   Next item