Great Writing - Home > Extended > The Dorkestra (Completely Different), Ch. 1: The Four Fours
READING ROOM
Great Writing - Home
Read and review others' work
Articles on writing
Advice from the community
COMMUNITY
Talk to others in the forums
Events and Competitions
GW News
ABOUT GREAT WRITING
All About Us
Contact Us
WORK AWAITING REVIEW
GW IS...
Great Writing creative writing community is designed to prompt ideas and provide inspiration and motivation within aspiring and amateur authors. Whatever your topic; from love poetry to Doctor Who or Harry Potter fan fiction, Great Writing's online writing group is where you can make new friends and improve your creative writing.
WHO'S ONLINE
We have 1647 guests online and 4 members online
Extended Work
The Dorkestra (Completely Different), Ch. 1: The Four Fours
By anorwegianwood
22 March 2007
This isn't a rewrite; it's a completely different first chapter, and I could really use some constructive reviews on it.  The chapter I originally posted about a month ago is from a work by the same title, but is not at all like this new one.  I've been planning this collection of embellished memoirs for a while, but I didn't like the way it was going, so I scrapped it and started from a new angle.  This is the start of the new angle.

This is a long intro, so you can jump right into the story if you want, but I thought I might explain where this is coming from and where it's going if anyone's interested.  This is semi-autobiographical.  Most of the things that will happen in this work really did happen in my high school orchestra.  The characters, however, are combinations of many different people and a good dose of my own imagination.  I was originally writing this as a series of memories of the three main characters spanning four years.  As I wrote it, I found that it was impossible to keep everything coherent and connected, so I started over, intending to follow these characters through their senior year, perhaps with occasional flashbacks, but basically a linear story.  The problem was I couldn't figure out how to start it.  I needed to explain a good number of things within the "culture" of this orchestra.

I am a huge fan of M*A*S*H.  It’s my favorite TV show and one of my top favorite movies and books.  In particular, I love the way the characters are presented in the book.  I realized that I unintentionally created three characters (Oz, Astrid, and Heather) in very much the same position as Hawkeye, Trapper John, and Duke: three talented people excelling at a challenge so well that they can get away with being a little unorthodox, simply because they are indispensable.  I decided to take a cue from Richard Hooker and open with a secondary character observing the main characters: my own Radar.  I even gave M*A*S*H a nod and named the school after Trapper John’s high school, Winchester High (which, of course, eventually showed up in the series in the form of Major Charles Emerson Winchester, III).
 

So, does this work as an opening?  Most importantly, do you want to know more about Oz, Astrid, and Heather?  Matthew will still be part of the story, but this trio is the focus.  Each will be properly introduced to the reader in the following parts, but I want to introduce them as a group first before delving into their individual stories.


There’s no ceiling.  That’s the first thing he notices.  There’s the metal grid where the ceiling tiles should go, but no more than about fifteen actual tiles.  He can look right up into the mess of pipes and wires between this floor and the one above.  The few ceiling tiles still in place are yellow and orange with water damage.  The room has a distinct feeling of neglect.  Chipped paint, old chairs, a stained floor, and no ceiling.  This can’t possibly be the right room.  Nationally renowned high school orchestras do not practice in basement classrooms with rattling air vents and rust-stained walls.  And they certainly do not practice without ceilings.

Matthew Wellings is, however, certainly in the right room.  The instrument lockers and cello racks and slightly crooked music stands make that clear.  It doesn’t seem possible, but this is the orchestra room, and he will be spending every afternoon here for the next four years.  He sighs deeply and drops his trumpet case on the nearest scuffed chair.

Matthew plays the trumpet, but he is not a trumpet player.  At least, he has never considered himself a trumpet player.  Trumpet players are loud and self-assured, happy to stand out in the brass section.  Matthew, on the other hand, is a quiet, slightly awkward introvert who just happened to pick the trumpet because he liked the way it looked, all twisted back on itself.  It’s not that he doesn’t enjoy playing the trumpet, it’s just that he never feels like he fits in with the other players in his section.  He occasionally wonders if he’d prefer the quiet life of a bassoon player.

He wanders slowly around the edge of the room, reading the plaques and awards from orchestra festivals of the past.  There certainly are a lot of them.  A few are for the open level symphony orchestra, but most of them are for the audition-only chamber ensemble, the group of forty or so players representing the best of the high school music students.  The Dorkestra, as they like to call themselves.  This is the group that has made Winchester High School’s fine arts department one of the best in the nation.  This is the group that Matthew still can’t quite believe accepted him.

Matthew checks his watch for the twenty-sixth time.  It’s definitely the right room, but is it the right time?  He could have sworn he heard the eighth period bell ring, but there’s no one here, not even the teacher.  He pulls out a dog-eared schedule.  This is definitely the right time.  So far, he has spent his first day of high school getting lost and arriving everywhere several minutes late.  Now, for his last class, he finally manages to locate the room on time, only to find it completely deserted.  He is just about to go to the office and ask if there’s been some mistake when a voice startles him from behind.

“We’ve got a freshie!” the voice cries out in delight from the doorway.  Matthew turns quickly to see an older boy with eyes the color of Windex striding confidently into the room, carrying a small black case and followed by a group of chatting students.

“What?” Matthew asks timidly, not exactly sure what the boy just said.

“You’re a freshman!  We don’t get many of those, you know.”

“How do you know I’m a freshman?”  Is it really that obvious?

“The youthful light of energy and terror in your eyes.”

Matthew blinks in reply.

“Plus, you got here on time when everyone knows that Dorkestra members are permitted three extra minutes travel time.  Don’t worry, young child, you’ll learn.”  The boy sets his black case on a chair near Matthew’s, then puts one foot up on seat, resting crossed arms on his knee and looking around the room as if he owns it.  Matthew looks at the case and recognizes it as a trumpet case.  He should have guessed.  “What do you play, freshie?” the boy asks as he starts unpacking his instrument.

“Trumpet,” Matthew replies, hastening to unpack his own.

“Really?  I had you pegged for a bassoon player…ah, well.  You’re in my section.  I’m Oz.”

“Matthew.”

“We’ve already got one of those.  Two, actually, now that we’ve picked up that sophomore violist.  ‘Freshie’ it is, then.”

Matthew opens his mouth to reply, though he’s not exactly sure what he’ll say.  He never finds out, though, because at that moment, a tall man with thinning hair enters the room carrying a flat, thin box.  He takes a paper from on top of the box and sets it on the kettledrum.  “Seating chart,” he says, and disappears into a small office off the side of the room.

After checking for his seat, Matthew finds that he is one of three trumpets, Oz as the section leader.  The other trumpet player, sitting between Oz and Matthew, is a burly junior named Adam wearing ripped jeans and an over-sized T-shirt.  When Oz gets up to talk to a group of students just entering the room, Adam leans over to talk to Matthew.

“He doesn’t mean anything by it, it’s actually a compliment,” he says quietly.

“What is?” Matthew asks.

“‘Freshie.’  It’s what his section leader called him when he was a freshman.  He’s a Four.”

“Four what?”

“This is his fourth year with the Dorkestra,” Adam says.  “We call people who start as freshmen ‘Fours,’ but they’re pretty rare.  Most people don’t get into Dorkestra until sophomore or junior year.  We’ve only got a total of three Fours in the group right now, all seniors.  I don’t think any freshmen made it last year or the year before that.  You’re probably the first since Oz.  And Astrid and Heather.”

“Who are they?”

“Those two seniors over there,” he says, pointing.

Matthew looks over to see two girls talking to Oz near the front of the room.  One, a brunette, is talking around a reed stuck in the corner of her mouth.  The other, a petite blonde, is rosining a violin bow and laughing.

“Heather’s the hot one,” the junior tells him.  “Astrid’s the oboe.”

After a minute, the brunette, Astrid, returns to her seat two rows in front of Matthew and transfers the reed from her mouth to her oboe.  She walks with all the confidence of Oz, her fellow Four, but none of the arrogance.  She smiles quickly at Matthew before sitting down.  The stack of books under her chair is imposing.  All appear to be Advanced Placement or Honors course books: multivariable calculus, statistics, German, chemistry, physics, European literature, psychology.  Matthew didn’t even know students were permitted to take so many classes.

Once her reed is in place, Astrid starts playing.  Matthew doesn’t recognize the piece, but he’s awed by how beautiful it is.  Her playing seems effortless.  She moves her whole body as if the music is coursing through her.  He leans forward to see what she’s playing, but there’s no music on the stand.  He assumes it’s a piece she has memorized, but then he notices how fluid and rapidly changing the music is, occasionally interrupted by a barely detectable pause.  She’s improvising.

Matthew looks to the front of the room where Heather is sitting third chair in the first violin section.  She twists her curtain of blonde hair back from the left side of her face and secures it with a bobby pin.  On her neck, just below her jaw, Matthew can make out a small, red mark.  A violin hickey, as the industry term is.  A place where the fixture for the chin rest of the instrument has actually rubbed the skin raw from constant playing.  A mark of endless hours of dedication.

Matthew immediately feels a sickening feeling as he realizes just what sort of talent these people have.  There’s a reason freshmen so rarely make it into the Dorkestra.  There’s a reason there are only three Fours in this group.  Matthew turns back to the junior next to him, trying to find something else to think about.  “Why do we get three extras minutes before class?”

“It’s because we stay an extra hour after school.  We have a longer rehearsal period than regular orchestra, so Bax gives us a few extra minutes to get ready.  It’s his way of reminding us that he actually does like us.”

“Bax?

“Mr. Baxter, the conductor.  That guy,” the junior says, pointing as the tall man with the thin box emerges from his office and crosses to the front of the room.  He sets the box on the conductor’s stand.  Matthew squints to see what’s written on the side of the box.  Dvorak: New World Symphony, score and parts.  Matthew looks at it with apprehension.  The New World is no easy piece.

Oz returns to the back of the room to take his seat, but pauses when he sees the look on Matthew’s face.  “Hey, Freshie,” Oz whispers.  “Don’t look so freaked out.  You’ll be fine.  You wouldn’t be here if you couldn’t handle it.  You’re the fourth Four.”

Mr. Baxter calls for attention and the class quiets.  “I’ll start with roll.  Let me know if you go by a nickname, please,” he says and begins reading off names.  At the third name, he pauses.  “Austin, I presume you’re still going by ‘Oz’?”

“You bet,” is the response.

“To each his own,” Mr. Baxter mumbles.  “Michael Evans, do you go by Mike?” he continues, working his way down the list.  He comes to the last name.  “Matthew Wellings, do you prefer Matt?”

“No,” Matthew says after a moment.  “I prefer ‘Freshie.’”

Reviews
Not for me thanks
Written by Moonglum (15 comments posted) 22nd March 2007
It is quite well written, grammar seems o.k. 
But what's your target audience? Unless you get a bit of zing in it I feel that most people are going to doze off!
Moonglum:
Written by anorwegianwood (278 comments posted) 22nd March 2007
That's essentially my problem. I have written several short stories about events that will eventually happen in this work (one of which, "Pants," is in non-fic), and have gotten positive comments on them. I just can't figure out how to introduce a longer work on the same topic. My experience has mainly been short stories and novellas so far. So far, I have been thinking that this may work better as just a series of short stories, but I'd like to continue with this experiment if I can.

Written by Kathy (220 comments posted) 22nd March 2007
Claire 
 
I think that this is extremely well written actually! No 'quite' about it! 
 
I can see this working as part of a longer story, but agree that you may need to depart from your base in your own past and allow it to develope a 'happening' of its own.  
 
I know what you mean about linking things together but perhaps you can use your own experience as a background. You can hang certain characters on real people that you have known and not stick rigidly to actual events around which you are trying to build a story. Think about what you would like to happen to these people and you can fill the story and characters up by adding touches of real people and real events... 
 
Just a thought that you have probably had already! 
 
I am giving it 3 stars not because I don't think it is very good but because it is a work in progress and we haven't seen the end result yet. 
 
Best wishes 
Kathy
If you are so keen..
Written by stevetroster (1549 comments posted) 22nd March 2007
.. to write this story, why not try a bit of non-linear. Start with something that is exciting and then go back to how it all started.
Kathy and Steve:
Written by anorwegianwood (278 comments posted) 22nd March 2007
Kathy: I'm so glad that you liked this extremely rough draft. I'm still very unsure about how I want to do this. I'm just trying a bunch of different things and seeing what happens. I have been thinking about the personal journeys of these characters, but perhaps I should spend some more time on that first. 
 
Steve: That's good thought, and something else I've been playing around with. I may give it a more serious try. 
 
Thanks for the input! 
 
~Claire
Steve is possibly right .......
Written by Bagheera (683 comments posted) 23rd March 2007
......... in that it's such a 'specialised' field.  
The cadré of an orchestra is sometimes thought of as an elitist group, which from personal experience I think is unfair but a common misconception! :sigh  
I think that (maybe) you need something a non-orchestra member can relate to, perhaps a bit of banter or silliness before the maestro (Mr. Baxter) makes his entrance???????? 
Having said that, the trials and tribulations of an orchestra (especially if they go "on the road" at some point?) has a wealth of possibilities and I can't think of anything of a similar nature which could be held up to it as a comparison .... :)

Written by Anyanka (33 comments posted) 23rd March 2007
Really good writing - a pleasure to read. I have been dismayed to find that many aspiring writers are only concerned with story & plot, but do not understand the importance of the words!  
 
The absence of a discernible plot does not bother me; your writing is so confident that I automatically trust that you will lead me somewhere interesting. I love the bits of info like the 'violin hickey'. 
 
This one cracked me up: 
“Heather’s the hot one,” the junior tells him. “Astrid’s the oboe.” 
 
However, I found myself skim-reading because I'm just not at all interested in American high-school details. I don't care how many courses someone is allowed to take; the whole freshman/senior/sophomore terminology turns me off because I don't understand it and feel excluded. Not a problem when you're writing for the US market, probably.  

Written by anorwegianwood (278 comments posted) 23rd March 2007
Bagheera: Another good thought, and something I should probably play with a bit. And yes, we did go on the road, and entertaining things did indeed happen. I'm surprised our hotel didn't give us all a life-long ban. ;)  
 
Anyanka: Thank you so much for that lovely compliment! And thank you for mentioning your boredom with the high school details. I never thought about the US vs. the UK education systems. There's a girl from Wales in my dorm who always complains when we all start talking about AP classes and upperclassmen and senior priveleges. Ultimately, I don't intend this to be a "high school story," but some of this info is necessary. Thanks for pointing this out. I may try to find different ways to incorporate it, a bit at a time so it doesn't seem so prevalent.

Written by Anyanka (33 comments posted) 23rd March 2007
To be honest, Nor'wood, it's not just the US school system! I can see why some of it is necessary in your story, but would just recommend keeping it to the minimum. Other than that, I'm looking forward to reading more.  
 
My current novel is set partly at an English sixth form college, by the way, but I have no intention of going into too much detail about the system (it's not essential for my story, but also - I don't know exactly how it works!!!)

Written by ellipinnock (1753 comments posted) 23rd March 2007
Yep I thought this was engaging. You're probably going to have to be inventive to keep the interest high over time but that's no bad thing. There's enough in this to make me want to read more anyway, first para particularly good. 
 
Elli
Another thought ........
Written by Bagheera (683 comments posted) 24th March 2007
........ especially to Anyanka, if you read this! 
They say "write from your own experiences" and for this reason the START of my "Radical Regionalism" political thriller [see "Extended" for 1st instalment!] is based in fact, the Reunion Dinner of my old Grammar School in Liverpool ....... the rest is pure fiction, however!! :grin  
 
Nothing wrong with using the framework of a school/college/uni as far as I'm concerned - it doesn't HAVE to develop into another teenage high school soap opera .... :eek
Hi
Written by Bottleblondesurfer (3352 comments posted) 25th March 2007
Hi, well you asked for comments so I'll give mine. 
I thought it well written in a clear, direct and descriptive style; focussed on character and free of literary aritifice i.e you are concentrating on telling a story rather than trying to write "literature"  
It was an easy read but there is little narrative "pull" to it yet. I realise it is only the intro but it would be a good idea to put in some short term hooks which you can pay off quickly as well as setting up some long term ones which you will keep us waiting to see paid off. 
For me, the beginning was a bit of a turn off. Start with people [unless you are appealing to architects] You can always go back to teh description once you have hooked 
us 
It might have been better to start at  
 
"Matthew plays the trumpet" 
or better still 
 
“We’ve got a freshie!” the voice cries out in delight " 
It takes us right into characater and creates curiosity that you can then satisfy; and then give us all the context we need 
It's vital to create curiosity first IMHO 
Just some reactions feel free to ignore 
cheers 


Written by anorwegianwood (278 comments posted) 25th March 2007
Thanks for the input, J. Some good suggestions I'll have to play around with. 
 
~Claire
okay, i'm an idiot
Written by robokent (84 comments posted) 4th April 2007
C, 
 
Hey, just commented on your first draft of this because the story appeared in the randomly generated 'awaiting comments' section, but then I saw when you'd posted it, and when seeking out part two, I stumbled across your re-write.  
 
Love it. I read the first comment up top, and I don't agree. I was pulled in right away and my interest was kept right through to the end.  
 
I'm looking forward to reading more. 
 
RK

Written by Witzl (1585 comments posted) 4th April 2007
I don't agree with the comment on top either. There's plenty of zing in this, and I was never in any danger of nodding off. Your dialogue worked well, and kept this moving along nicely.  
 
It might be good to start this off with a bit of dialog, then add the observation about the ceiling and Freshie's suspicion that he'd goten the room wrong afterwards. But I thought it was fine the way it was, and I'd certainly read more.

Written by Signa (66 comments posted) 4th April 2007
Everyone seems to have different opinions on this. Here are mine. :) 
 
I love the title! :grin  
 
I struggled with the first paragraph but from the second paragraph on I was completely absorbed. I thought it was very well written. 
 
I liked the whole ¨Freshie¨ thing very much. It was a great way to end it. 
 
I liked the way that Oz was nice to Freshie at the end there reassuring him that he could handle it and calling him the fourth Four. Arrogant but sweet? Ooo yes I want to know more about him.  
 
A hot girl with a permanent violin hickey? So sheś hot but not too vain. Cool. Interesting.  
 
Astrid - with all her books - is she some sort of genius? I want to know more about her too.  
 
I suppose the only one I not so bothered about it Matthew/Freshie but you implied that he was meant to be taking a back seat anyway.  
 
I know bugger all about orchestras - I never played an instrument in my life but that didn´t matter at all. As I say I was completely absorbed.  
 
I´m going to look for other chapters of this now! :grin

Written by Signa (66 comments posted) 4th April 2007
Oh there aren´t any more... Oh well!
RK, Witzl, and Signa:
Written by anorwegianwood (278 comments posted) 4th April 2007
Thank you all so much for your comments. I'm glad you were kept interested by this. As someone who has mainly written short stories, I've been writing this in chunks, often out of order, which is partly what made finding an opening so difficult. There are still things about it that bother me, but I'm happier with this version than with earlier ones. I recently rewrote it again, starting with Matthew wandering down the hallway and asking for directions to the orchestra room, so it doesn't start with just a description of a setting (which is totally accurate, by the way, my HS orchestra room lacked a ceiling as well). I can't promise more of this yet as I'm pretty well immersed in the final month of the academic year (and thus, term papers :x ), but I hope to get around to posting some more this summer. 
 
~Claire

   Only registered users can rate and write comments.
   Please login or register.

Powered by AkoComment 2.0!

Next item