Great Writing - Home > Short S. > Humpty Dumpty
READING ROOM
Great Writing - Home
Read and review others' work
Articles on writing
Advice from the community
COMMUNITY
Talk to others in the forums
Events and Competitions
GW News
ABOUT GREAT WRITING
All About Us
Contact Us
WORK AWAITING REVIEW
GW IS...
Great Writing creative writing community is designed to prompt ideas and provide inspiration and motivation within aspiring and amateur authors. Whatever your topic; from love poetry to Doctor Who or Harry Potter fan fiction, Great Writing's online writing group is where you can make new friends and improve your creative writing.
WHO'S ONLINE
We have 2084 guests online and 3 members online
Shorts
Humpty Dumpty
By Katsinella
23 March 2007
This is a piece written some time ago but recently updated. I had written in the present tense but changed it to past tense for better readibilty.
I am still looking for a style so any/all feedback welcome.



It was a glorious late summer African afternoon. The sky stretched out above me in a piercing blue and the bright sunlight made everything look vibrant and alive.  Standing on the porch, I looked down the sloping garden lawn at the old oak trees, the glinting swimming pool and the open gates at the end of the driveway.  It was a thrilling day; my first birthday party.  Well, not quite my first since I was already four years old but it was to be my first birthday party.

On the porch was a low table laden with all sugared treats so beloved at parties; crisps, smarties, strawberry chews, little individually iced fairy cakes with raisins, a big chocolate cake with four unlit candles.  There was a bowl of wrapped sweeties, a mixture of the hard-boiled ones, the chewy ones, and my favourites, the chocolate ones. Next to all this bliss, was a pile of paper plates and bright yellow napkins.  Under the table stood a box of ice-cream cones, which I knew were for later. 
The smell of the honeysuckle growing upon the wooden fence alongside the garden mingled with the afternoon heat. My excitement made me fidgety and I alternated between looking at feast on the table and down the driveway from where I knew the guests would appear.

My mother appeared through the French doors carrying more plates. She was slim, dressed in a long blue halter neck dress that accentuated her golden brown shoulders. She would always wear wonderful shoes and that day was no exception. She had on open toed sandals with straps that wrapped many times around her slim calves. I longed to wear them too but she’d tell me I was too small.
And ever faithful was Oscar, the bullterrier who traipsed out the house after my mother. He found some shade against the wall, collapsing against it with a grunt.  He was never crazy about the heat.
‘Go put some shoes on. The guests will soon be here’, my mother told me.

I wasn’t an ardent fan of shoes. I’d been taking them off as soon as I was able much to the consternation of my mother. I loved to run barefoot on the grass and feel the cool crispness of the morning dew on the souls of me feet. But I knew that that was not to the time to argue to I followed instructions and went inside to find a pair of shoes.

That morning, I had dressed in a blue nurse uniform with a white apron. My mother used to berate me over mismatched outfits and shoes. I always insisted on dressing myself, and on days when she had no energy, she’d let me win that argument and I would couple together outrageous combinations of colours, textures and fabrics. My choices still haunt me to this day when my mother digs out the family photo album. 
I ran back outside to the porch, shouting ‘Are they here yet?’
Oscar grunted from the shade and my mother told me that perhaps it was a little early.
‘What time was it?’
‘It’s just before 4 o’clock’.
‘But wasn’t that the time when people should arrive?’
‘Yes, but sometimes people run a little late so you need to be patient.’
Being four years old, it was my last year at nursery school and my mother had promised a proper birthday party. My requirements were few as I wasn’t experienced in these occasions but the excitement was uncontrollable none the less. My mother had made a number of invitations. We were new to the area so not knowing the other mother’s, she’d asked the nursery school teacher to distribute the invitations.
16:05 – I peered down to the gates and could see no cars.
16:15 – I looked at my mother sitting on a beach chair on the porch and I asked her where everyone was.  She looked up from her magazine ‘I don’t know, darling, but I am sure they will arrive all at the same time soon.’
16:35 – I sat on the steps with my chin in my hands. I had kicked my shoes off and waited to hear a reprimand but none came.  I looked back at the party table and the cake had been covered with some thin netting to protect it from the flies.  The occasional fly buzzed lazily over the table.
16:40 – ‘Mummy….’
‘I know my sweetie, maybe they’re lost.’
16:45 – Oscar got up slowly, his stiff movements showing his age, and walked over to me. He sat on the steps next to me and we both looked down towards the gates but there was nothing to see.

By 5 o’clock, my mother decided that no one was coming to my party. I felt numb.  How does this happen?  Did they forget? Did they get the wrong date?  Did my mother forget to give out the invitations? No, my mother appeased me on all accounts.  Something must have happened.  In a moment of lucid four year old logic, I asked her how could all the people she invited been involved in the same thing.  Then I started to cry. The tears poured down my little face and my chest heaved as I gasped for air.  Oscar licked my hand to show his compassion.  My mother picked me up, sat down on the beach chair, put my head on her shoulder and let me cry. I couldn’t see her face but I could feel the tension in her body.
‘No one likes me’ I sputtered between heaving sobs, ‘that’s why no-one came to my birthday party’. 
My mother tried to soothe me to no avail.  I looked over her shoulder down to the garden.  The garden was still green, the light still bright but I felt like I was broken into a million pieces and even my mother’s love and hugs couldn’t put me back together again.

Reviews

Written by Rose (12 comments posted) 23rd March 2007
oh my god! this is a very sad story, with a well written ending. i love it when there is a circular theme, beginning and ending with the same idea, and this was done well. The only comments I'd make is that it is difficult for me to imagine a four year old saying these things, of course they are unhappy, but i dont think the dialogue at the end is very believable. . but I suppose these are the thoughts you are trying to convey so its a tough one! also the repetion of birthday and party in the first paragraph is slightly hard to read. sorry ive rambled a bit, but i hope my ideas have helped!  
 
good luck. x

Written by Witzl (1585 comments posted) 23rd March 2007
Poor kid. I will tell you right now that if that had been me, I'd never have gotten over it. I'm still amazed when I send out party invitations and people actually show up.  
 
I wanted to know why no one had showed up. Even just a hint -- the neighbors were snobs, say, the other kids' parents were bigots, the mother was associated with some sort of scandal, or the little girl herself was a bit of a bully or too dogmatic at her nursery school. I think that would make your story even more engaging.

Written by Lizzy (822 comments posted) 23rd March 2007
I thought you set the scene very well with simple descriptions. I too would like to know why no one came to the poor child's party.

Written by ellipinnock (1753 comments posted) 23rd March 2007
Yes I liked this but would have liked an indication as to why no-one came. 
 
I think this reads better in the past than it would have done in the present. One thing - there is a lot of precise detail given that this is someone remembering an event that happened when they were four...It might be better from the mother's perspective? Or, keep it from the perspective of the girl but make it a bit vaguer in places and put in a bit more about her thoughts and feelings now - that might give it a bit more depth as a short self-contained piece. 
 
Definitely potential in this 
 
Elli

Written by anorwegianwood (278 comments posted) 23rd March 2007
I have the exact same advice as Elli. Memories from when you're only four years old aren't usually this clear. We tend to remember people and feelings more than details at that age, though often, a few details are strikingly clear. For example, it's unlikely that someone would remember all the specific foods on the table, but the yellow napkins might stick out vividly in her mind. 
 
I really felt for the little girl in this; you handled the emotion well. I'd be okay not knowing why no one showed up, not if she never found out. If it really is because no one likes her, though, you might want to hint at what it is about her that the other children don't like. 
 
Overall, a nice story with good potential. 
 
~Claire
thanks..
Written by Katsinella (28 comments posted) 23rd March 2007
..all for the useful feedback. The point of view is a difficult one for me here. I really want it to be from the point of the little girl but I understand how it may not seem realistic - too much detail given how young the girl is at the time. 
 
I had thought about writing it from the mother's perspective (Thanks Elli - you are now the 2nd person to suggest this so perhaps I should do it! :-) ) It would be a very differnt piece, perhaps not so poignant? Let me stop rambling and go an do it! :-)

Written by Kathy (220 comments posted) 23rd March 2007
I could hardly bear to read this, which I suppose means that it worked!! Please tell me that the little girl will be alright! 
 
Regarding the little girl's perspective, I kind of agree with the others that she seems to have remembered a huge amount of detail. However, it was traumatic and that would stick in her memory, plus, most of the piece is just describing what the food was and the table looked like etc., and so isn't necessarily 'adult'.  
 
You could play around with it and see what works for you. 
 
Well done. 
Kathy

Written by Phil (6838 comments posted) 24th March 2007
Good bit of writing. Nothing much to add to what has already been said. I don't think not knowing exactly why no-ne came matters - not to me anyway. 
 
Phil.
Hi Katsinella
Written by jean.day (2326 comments posted) 25th March 2007
I very much enjoyed this story, and the emotion of excitement followed by disappointment came across very well. I agree with the others that it would be nice to know why. I expect there was a real reason. 
 
I too have tried on occasion to write things from the POV of a rather young child, and have been told that I was giving them too much discernment and observational ability. But even though a child might not be able to vocalise a lot of these things, she might well have thought them in her own way - and I think writiing it in a four year old's language might have made it a bit too simple sounding. Am I contradicting myself?  
 
Anyway, I did like the story, and would like to read more.
Poor little one
Written by Signa (66 comments posted) 31st March 2007
I really enjoyed this - even though it made me feel sad. Poor little lamb. I hope this didnīt really happen to you.  
 
I liked the bit where she was describing her mums legs - I know that might sound strange but when I think back to being little thatīs what I remember about people - their legs. I suppose itīs because you are only tall enough to see up to someones waist. And I was always fascinated by my mums shoes as well - but I hated my own. (Patent - yuk!) 
 
I liked that there was no indication why no one came because sometimes you donīt get explanations for things and the confusion makes it hurt even more.  
 
I also felt that the language was a bit too complicated for a four year old. When I think back and remember being young I donīt think with big words. Having said that, as jean day said, perhaps writing it in more simple language will spoil it.  
 
I would like to read it again if you play around with it. :)

   Only registered users can rate and write comments.
   Please login or register.

Powered by AkoComment 2.0!

 Previous item   Next item