Whenever I hear the assertion that Americans don't get irony I always inwardly chuckle at the idea of them getting irony so well that they choose not to enlighten the silly people making such claims.
SOURCE(
NeuteredNEWS): In an impromptu news conference called by the Pentagon, a US official stated that Americans do in fact get irony.
Pressed for more details the official cited medical reports for returning WW2
GIs, many of whom doctors diagnosed to be suffering from 'Venereal Diseases, Shell shock and a laconic ironic wit'.
Research revealed that the soldiers stationed in England suffered mainly from the venereal diseases and the ironic wit, while those that had met the French had shell shock. The researchers were further able to distil the essence of irony and presented their findings to the Pentagon. The Pentagon officials keen to exercise their new found comedic vehicle decided to withhold their findings from the rest of the world, which caused many a chuckle filled meeting in the oval office as agents from around Europe relayed eavesdropped conversations lamenting the American inability to get irony.
Soon a nationwide program was developed to teach the basics of irony to every school child in America, and while the rest of the world thought they were learning to survive nuclear attacks by hiding under their school desks, they were in fact reading specially prepared notes on the bottom of their desks.
Asked why it had taken the Pentagon so long to come clean the official replied,
"
Sheesh guys we have been dropping hints for awhile now, you know saying things like 'We think Saddam may have
WMDs' after we sold him most of the ones he did have."
This begged the question as to whether other countries, like Iran, have also had any Irony Development programs. A UN official assured reporters that Tehran had failed to make Enriched Irony and thus far only has a gaggle of expectant spectators watching unsuspecting pedestrians as they walk up to a deceptively deep puddle.
The official also stated that there have been calls for Joke War amendments to the Geneva Convention. It is understood the French have categorically condemned these amendments as they list Jerry Lewis as a hazardous substance.
|
???? Written by stevetroster (1555 comments posted) 25th March 2007 |
Of course Americans don't understand Irany, they don't understand any middle-eastern languages. IRONY:Socratic method of discussion by professing ignorance: conveyence of meaning by words whose literal meaning is the opposite = E.G. "There 'are' weapons of mass destruction in Iraq." The literal opposite being - 'aren't'. I would suggest that you remove the words in brackets from this passage to make it accurate. "and while the rest of the world ((thought the crazy bastards)) were learning to survive nuclear attacks by hiding under their school desks" |
Written by Phil (6738 comments posted) 25th March 2007 |
While I'm certainly not a fan of all things American, I do feel they get a bad press at times. Lets face it, if you presented a chav gang to represent te UK it would hardly make a good impression - stupid, opinionated, ignorant, violent gits. Mind, look who the Americans have leading them. Understand irony, of course they do. Aren't they the ones who want to bring democracy to the world? Enjoyable piece. Phil Just read this, and it still sounds more anti US than I intended. |
Written by Witzl (1585 comments posted) 25th March 2007 |
Who says we don't do irony? Just because some of us choose to wear polyester. . . Phil, Americans really do get bad press. I'm still convinced the BBC prefers to interview American louts instead of thinkers. During the early stages of the war we still had a TV and I watched while the interviewers worked an American crowd. The minute they got some fellow who said 'No, sir, I don't support this war,' they quickly whisked the mike away from him and found some big-bellied redneck in a cowboy hat and interviewed him instead. There's irony for you. Thank you, cheapthrill, for telling GW about this. I was one of those kids crouching underneath my desk, bored out of my mind. No irony there that I could see, though. |
Written by Bottleblondesurfer (3370 comments posted) 25th March 2007 |
I love the idea that you can 'catch' irony by an extended stay in blighty. We have to keep telling ourselves this; it's the only way we can still feel superior to them. And in a few years when the English Language has been officially re-designated as the Amercian language I'm sure they will have it outlawed. A very clever and witty piece.Well structured and about the right length for not news Hope to see more J |
Written by givitsum (651 comments posted) 25th March 2007 |
As our friends across the pond have a leader that wasn't really elected, a secret service that asassinated there own president, and have eves-dropping powers that even the Stasi would have been proud of, I reckon the fact they took Iraq to topple a 'dictator who limits the freedom and rights of his people' proves that they understand irony very well indeed. Well done, enjoyed. G. |
Now you've gone and ruined our fun... Written by anorwegianwood (278 comments posted) 25th March 2007 |
You all had no idea how much we'd giggle about this to ourselves. So much for that inside joke... I enjoyed this piece (as an American). I was raised by two dry-witted liberals, and I've read a lot of British literature and much prefer British humor to American humor. I wouldn't claim to be on par with you Brits for irony, but I can at least do a credible immitation. There have been many times when I've said something ironic to some of my fellow Americans and been met with blank stares. Bush named Iraq, Iran, and N. Korea as the Axis of Evil. Two of those countries have activiely tested WMDs recently. Bush attacked the third. Thank you, Mr. President. You've made us all feel much safer. (2008 can't come soon enough. I'm getting sick of protesting.) ~Claire |
Thanks Written by cheapthrill (30 comments posted) 25th March 2007 |
Thanks for the comments guys. Steve I removed the "crazy bastards" part as you suggested, but I'm not 100% sure what you are getting at in regards to the Socratic irony part. "Sheesh guys we have been dropping hints for awhile now, you know saying things like 'We think Saddam may have WMDs' after we sold him most of the ones he did have." If its questioning the validity of the irony in that quote, I was going for a dramatic irony there, where a double audience is suggested. One audience only understands the Facts given to them while the other audience gets both the Fact and comprehends more than the original audience due to being privy to some information the first is lacking. Right? Wrong? Any constructive criticism welcome. Glad to see some of you enjoyed the piece. |
Written by coosh (870 comments posted) 26th March 2007 |
| Nice idea, and you played it out well - particularly when you moved into the areas of WMDs and enriched irony. Good stuff. |
'Confusion' he say... Written by stevetroster (1555 comments posted) 26th March 2007 |
Sorry, I obviously confused the matter by being too literal with the meaning of irony, so I will abridge. IRONY: Words whose literal meaning is the opposite... E.G. "There (are) weapons of mass destruction in Iraq." The literal opposite being - 'aren't'. Best Wishes again.
|
Written by Fledermaus (3325 comments posted) 26th March 2007 |
They elected George W Bush twice, who says they have no irony? Yet if they consider irony a secret weapon, Iraq did have at least one WMD: Muhammad al Shahhaf. I never forget that he claimed there were no Americans in Iraq, while in the background one could see Abrams' rolling through Baghdad's streets. This reminded me of a Monty Python sketch, where the British use a joke to make Germans laugh themselves to death. Enjoyable bit of nonsense. |
Written by wltshr (317 comments posted) 18th April 2007 |
Nice piece. Sorry I missed it earlier. It's unfair to suggest the Americans don't understand irony. It is scientifically proven that all nations were granted the same per capita level of understanding of, and abilty to use, irony in equal measure. Unfortunately, in the US, Randy Newman got it all. |
Only registered users can rate and write comments.
Please login or register.