Great Writing - Home > Short S. > If ifs and ands.......
READING ROOM
Great Writing - Home
Read and review others' work
Articles on writing
Advice from the community
COMMUNITY
Talk to others in the forums
Events and Competitions
GW News
ABOUT GREAT WRITING
All About Us
Contact Us
WORK AWAITING REVIEW
GW IS...
Great Writing creative writing community is designed to prompt ideas and provide inspiration and motivation within aspiring and amateur authors. Whatever your topic; from love poetry to Doctor Who or Harry Potter fan fiction, Great Writing's online writing group is where you can make new friends and improve your creative writing.
WHO'S ONLINE
We have 1902 guests online and 5 members online
Shorts
If ifs and ands.......
By Lizzy
07 April 2007
I'm not too sure about this. I have written more but I want to reread before I post.

If ‘Ifs and Ands….’


Why do I do this every year? I hate it and it’s just become a chore. It was great fun at the beginning. I spent ages planning and organising. Choosing foods that would appeal to everyone. Even down to the slop that old Bert had to eat because he refused to wear his teeth. Now it’s ready prepared buffet meals from Tesco!


Hannah put the last dish of sandwiches on the table and sighed. She looked at her watch. Half an hour left before SHE arrived.


A large gin might help the proceedings to move along at a more agreeable pace.


Hannah had been married for twenty years. The gatherings had started in the first year of their marriage. They’d not been able to afford a wedding reception and so had invited family to a buffet meal on Easter bank holiday to celebrate their marriage and also their new home. And so the tradition had begun. Less of the family seemed to visit these days though.
 

I loved that house. Small but cosy. Not in the best part of town but it was ours. There was even a little vegetable patch in the garden. The rabbits ate all of the lettuce! SHE didn’t think it was good enough.


Hannah’s eyes lit up as she remembered the house but soon clouded over as she remembered their leaving.


Another drink won’t do any harm will it?


She slouched in a chair and rubbed in a halfhearted way at a stain on her blouse; she couldn’t be bothered to change again. She continued drinking thoughtfully from her glass.


Why had he started that argument this morning? She was resigned to the gathering, glad that his mother wasn’t able to come and then he’d dropped the bombshell.


"There’s been a change of plan love. Mum can make it after all."


Why did he call her ‘love’? He didn’t mean it. He didn’t love her. It was habit and so predictable.


"She’s not going to stay with Diane. She’s had a phone call to say Diane’s got the flu. We can’t take the chance of her catching it. She’s coming to us instead."


It was the smile. That triumphant sort of smile he’s got that did it."

"The only thing that was going to make this bearable was the fact that SHE wasn’t coming. Oh God! I’ve got to put up with all her snide sarcastic remarks." She’d said.

"Mother only wants what’s best for us you know that. We wouldn’t have this house if it weren’t for her. She didn’t have to lend us the money. We’d still be in that poky little house with the damp and the smells if she hadn’t helped us."


Why did he have to smile that smile? The argument just took off from there. His mother hates me. Never thought I was good enough for him. Her son, her handsome, intelligent son who could have chosen anyone but chose me. I’ll never forgive her for what she did, or him for letting her. We would have managed if it hadn’t been for her.


Hannah got up and went to check that the Quiche Bites were OK in the oven. She didn’t really care whether they were or not. She absentmindedly poured herself another drink, beginning now to feel more relaxed.


I did love him in the early days, before we came to live so near to HER.


She went and turned on the CD player. Soft, gentle music filled the room and calmed her thoughts for a few seconds.


It was such a fun thing to do in the old days, before I got to know HER properly, before I realised he was such a wimp and a mummy’s boy. I spent the whole week preparing and baking. Even thinking up party games and buying everyone a silly little present. I did it for him as much as for anyone. I wanted him to be proud of his wife and I suppose I wanted to impress his family. When did love become contempt?


"You know she’s not well," he’d said, "She has a weak heart and any upset gives her palpitations."

"She’s as strong as a horse and it’s strange how she only gets palpitations when things don’t go her way. She’s got you just where she wants you. Ready to run round and solve any problems she might have. What about giving me a bit of attention sometimes?"


Maybe if the old witch had had more kids it would have been better or if his dad hadn’t run off with the barmaid. Only children are often spoiled rotten. I’m glad I’ve got Sophe as a sister.

Hannah looked at the gin bottle. Half empty! I don’t remember drinking all of that. Mothers’ ruin, that’s a laugh. Well I suppose it’s really half full. Just one more will calm me enough to face HER.


She walked around the room with her glass, half-heartedly plumping cushions and rearranging ornaments. She sat down again and looked at her watch.
 

Why had he kept on? And that infuriating smile!


"At least I know she cares for me. Would do anything for me. Is always there when I need her. You’re never here. Care more about your friends and that flighty sister of yours than you do about me," he’d said with that knowing smile.

"Why didn’t you marry her instead of me," she’d said and sat reading a magazine. End of conversation. He sat and read his newspaper.


Things would have been different if we’d had the kids we’d planned. We’d had such plans. Three children, didn’t matter what as long as they were well and happy, a house in the country. Just us, that’s all we wanted. We waited thinking ‘there’s time’. Time has a way of disappearing and then it was too late and nothing could be done. Was it then that things turned sour? No! We still had each other then. We still loved each other. It was HER fault that love died. She wanted, needed him back.


"I hope you’ve got some of that tea that Ma likes. You know she won’t drink coffee." He’d said looking up from his newspaper.

"I don’t know. You know I never drink it. Go and look if you’re that bothered." She’d said, never taking her eyes from the magazine.


Why does he pander to her every whim? She has a slight pain, indigestion most likely, and he’s round there calling the doctor. They must need a fork lift truck to carry her medical notes!


Hannah noticed another mark, this time on her skirt. She spat on her handkerchief and tried to remove it with little success.


She’ll regard me as the slut she thinks I am. I remember that time I overheard her talking to Lucy, ‘He should have married Jackie when he had the chance. She’s got two children now and a grandchild on the way. It would have been something to comfort my old age.’


"There’s none of that tea," he’d said. "You know she won’t drink anything else. You could at least have checked. But then you don’t care about her feelings, or mine for that matter. You’ve always been selfish, only caring about what you want."


Why didn’t I just ignore it then? Carry on with the magazine. It was the smile again that did it. Did he have that smile in the early days? I don’t think he did, or it was different. It was a real smile, one with some warmth in it. This one is a mocking, sneering smile. I think it was that nice smile that first attracted me to him. It was down at the pub, I’d gone with the girls and he was there. All smiles and laughter. He’d bought me a drink and asked me out and that was it. On our next date he took me to meet his mother. That should have made me suspicious. We sat and talked to her all evening. I suppose I was blinded by love and didn’t notice.


Hannah got up and walked over to the mirror above the fire. She looked at her reflection and ran her fingers through her hair.


A bit of lipstick would help I suppose. But I can’t be bothered. SHE won’t think any better of me

I know what she’ll do when she’s here. She’ll smile and she’ll hold Lucy’s baby. Tell her how lucky she is. She’ll dive into her bag and take out an expensive present that she’s bought, looking at me as if to say ‘it could have been you’. Rubbing salt into the wound. Why is it my fault we didn’t have children. It could just as easily have been him. But then who would inflict that grandmother from hell on any poor child?


She turned off the oven, emptied the dregs of the bottle into her glass and sat down again.


Sophe tried to warn me, but they do say that love is blind. It was certainly true in my case. Why did he keep on about the tea? I’d got a bottle of that cheap sherry she drinks for ‘medicinal purposes’. She does mellow a little when she’s had a couple of those. Why did he say it? And say it with that smile.


"You are completely self-centred," he’d said. "Mother was right. We should never have got married. I should have listened to her. She always knows what’s best for me. You only know what’s best for you. A good job we never had any kids. You would have made a lousy mother!" He’d said.


Why?


The doorbell rang.


That’ll be HER. Always likes to be first.


Hannah stood up and looked at herself once again in the mirror, rubbing at the red stain on her blouse and noticing yet more on her skirt.


To be cont.

Reviews
Hi Lizzy
Written by jean.day (2283 comments posted) 7th April 2007
I really could almost have written half of this story myself - you got the relationship between me and my mother-in-law down so well. Luckily, there was a long way between where we lived and they did - and luckily my husband only sometimes took her point of view over mine. And I usually stopped at 3 gins.  
 
Looking forward to reading more.

Written by Bondvillain2k (15 comments posted) 7th April 2007
I really like this. It has really dark undertones, especially the woman's implied alcoholism - not changing her stained clothes is a really good device.  
 
Both the mother-in-law and son are pretty horrendous, and I have every sympathy with your main character. Great stuff.

Written by teddy (240 comments posted) 8th April 2007
Hi Lizzy, 
 
I really enjoyed this. I sympathise with poor Hannah, you describe her pain and frustration very well, and give a very good insight into her relationship with her husband and mother-in-law. They do sound like a quite mean pair.  
 
looking forward to the next part.  
 
Teddy  

Written by Phil (6730 comments posted) 8th April 2007
Well written and interestingly structured piece. At first I thought the short paragraphs might grate, but they didn't. It worked very well. 
 
Enjoyed this very much. When you say: to be continued, I wonder if you'll give another point of view. 
 
Good stuff. 
 
Phil.

Written by Lizzy (800 comments posted) 8th April 2007
Thanks Jean,BV2K, Teddy and Phil for reviews. 
I have written the next bit but I do like your idea Phil of another point of view. I'm giving that a lot of thought. Thanks. 
Lizzy

Written by Tusk (53 comments posted) 8th April 2007
The switching of the paragraphs is superb.

Written by ellipinnock (1753 comments posted) 9th April 2007
Yep, I liked this too. Not sure you'd want to read the whole thing in this style but the alternating paragraphs worked well over a short piece. One suggestion - I found reading HER in capitals got a bit wearing after a while - felt a bit like I was being shouted at! I don't think you'd lose the emphasis by dropping the capitals... 
 
Anyway, I enjoyed this, nice piece, you got a lot of background into this without it sounding like a mini-biograpphy. 
 
Good stuff 
 
Elli

Written by Bottleblondesurfer (3362 comments posted) 10th April 2007
I thought this was a smart new take on an old situation. Hinting at the wife's shortcomings [like alcoholism, dirty clothes] was a nice touch. There's always two sides. What she didn't say told us as much as what she did. It was a well structured piece, slowly building and adding context. 
I did find the dialogue didn't ring true in places,they seemed to be saying some things more for our benefit than theirs. The alternating paragraphs would have been an ideal way to reveal the subtext rather than the obvious dialogue. 
But a powerful piece 
Jane

Written by Gill21 (566 comments posted) 13th April 2007
Only just gotten around to reading this....a lot has been said already so i'll just move onto the next part and comment there. Only thing i will say is i agree with Elli on the capitals front.  
Enjoyed it though!

Written by Witzl (1585 comments posted) 15th April 2007
I really like this, Lizzy, and I too sympathize with Hannah. My own mother-in-law (stepmother-in-law, I suppose) does not understand me, so I can certainly identify with Hannah's plight. On the other hand, I would love to hear the mother-in-law's point of view too, particularly if she might have legitimate reasons for feeling hurt. And although the husband comes across as a wimp, his position is difficult and I can't help feeling sorry for him. He's between a rock and a hard place and he can't win here.  
 
Of course I know that I am playing the devil's advocate. Part of me wonders why Hannah is sticking with this guy -- surely she still feels some love for him or she would have left by now? Whatever the case, I am intrigued and I will be coming back for more.
Interesting
Written by Asferthecat (834 comments posted) 18th April 2007
I like the style, I like the layout. I think you should stick to her point of view because you are cleverly revealing alot about her. I am still curious about why they are still together, what role her sister might have had, how it is going to end

   Only registered users can rate and write comments.
   Please login or register.

Powered by AkoComment 2.0!

 Previous item   Next item