READING ROOM
Great Writing - Home
Read and review others' work
Articles on writing
Advice from the community
COMMUNITY
Talk to others in the forums
Events and Competitions
GW News
ABOUT GREAT WRITING
All About Us
Contact Us
WORK AWAITING REVIEW
GW IS...
Great Writing creative writing community is designed to prompt ideas and provide inspiration and motivation within aspiring and amateur authors. Whatever your topic; from love poetry to Doctor Who or Harry Potter fan fiction, Great Writing's online writing group is where you can make new friends and improve your creative writing.
WHO'S ONLINE
We have 1499 guests online and 20 members online
Poetry
Alchemy
By no1butClo
11 April 2007
I feel like I've just done the same thing twice. Anyone who's read 'Eurydice II', please tell me if my hunch is correct. It would be so nice to find out I'm just being paranoid...

- do you think I should cut it down?
- is the title totally irrelevant?
- will someone pedantic PLEASE correct my punctuation mistakes, 'cause I can't proof-read for toffee =)

oh, and you may find it makes no sense =)

Reviews welcome as always, and a belated Happy Easter, Joyeux Paques, or appropriate equivalent.

Five years ago, I was thinking
like a kid, and you were thinking
like I am now, letting instinct
guide what reason couldn't judge.

Twelve months ago, you were pushing
for an answer; I was scared,
and far too stubborn to reply.

I kept you guessing, made you think 
and pushed you back behind the curtain
you had opened for a moment.

Ten minutes ago, I understood
why you were frightened, by the way
I made my contradictions plain. And now

I watch your eyes as you are
telling me a secret, flicking back
through pages of the past I've never seen.

I can tell, between the kisses,
you've been listening to my breathing,
holding yours and leaving me to
search the air for what I can't tease
out of you.

Through my guesswork, you can
feel me losing poise, and concentration.
'cause the scent of you
catches in my ribcage.

Your words grow fingers,
that slide over skin, beneath
a tight-fit shirt, and through
holes that my soul forgot to mention.

And we taste each other's lips
like wine, sampling this alchemy
of bated breath, and whispered words.

Reviews

Written by fellpony (1575 comments posted) 11th April 2007
Hi Clo 
 
I enjoyed this - you made me think, and teased me with possible meanings (some of which still elude me - no bad thing though). 
 
I'm a pedant/proof reader (you asked) so:  
 
each others' lips = each other's lips 
baited breath = bated breath 
 
Other than that, no problems. 
 
I do think it would benefit from a little pruning (again, since you ask). I'm not sure of the reference to dreams, for instance; is it helpful to the poem as a whole? 
 
Is the stanza "Through my guesswork..." important to the whole? At the moment I'm uncertain what you mean. You might be able to lose it without spoiling the development. Or if it's important, should it be made a bit less cryptic? 
 
I very much liked "holes that my soul forgot to to mention" and "flicking back 
through pages of the past I've never seen." 
 
Enjoyed; there's a good deal of quality here. 

Written by Witzl (1585 comments posted) 11th April 2007
I liked this very much, and Sue has already caught the only two things I might have pointed out to you -- 'baited' vs 'bated' and 'others' vs 'other's.' I'm not quite sure about 'holes that my soul forgot to mention;' though I did like the part about words growing fingers -- and much more, such as 'this alchemy of bated breath.'

Written by Fledermaus (3238 comments posted) 11th April 2007
The title isn't irrelevant, but it could have been better. This one gives away too much and doesn't share the atmosphere the poem has (as if I know anything about titles ;)
I liked it, but I'm not sure why. Perhaps it's the balance between the descriptive parts and the thoughts.
Interesting
Written by gutterkitty (362 comments posted) 15th April 2007
To me this is a very personal piece that will only ever reveal its true meaning to the writer.  
I love the way you step through time with each stanza to get closer to the now, but I feel the end (namely the last 3 stanzas) lags a bit and is too cluttered with metaphors. It's all good stuff but I think it would make for a better poem if you select a few choice ideas and focus on those. In fact the first five stanzas on their own would make a great piece! 

Written by ellipinnock (1753 comments posted) 17th April 2007
I liked this very much clo. Minor point - I'd change the two you're 's close together to you are - reads better i reckon. 
 
But really nice - lots to think about here - one of your better pieces i reckon. enjoyed. 
 
Elli

   Only registered users can rate and write comments.
   Please login or register.

Powered by AkoComment 2.0!

 Previous item   Next item