READING ROOM
Great Writing - Home
Read and review others' work
Articles on writing
Advice from the community
COMMUNITY
Talk to others in the forums
Events and Competitions
GW News
ABOUT GREAT WRITING
All About Us
Contact Us
WORK AWAITING REVIEW
GW IS...
Great Writing creative writing community is designed to prompt ideas and provide inspiration and motivation within aspiring and amateur authors. Whatever your topic; from love poetry to Doctor Who or Harry Potter fan fiction, Great Writing's online writing group is where you can make new friends and improve your creative writing.
WHO'S ONLINE
We have 1153 guests online and 9 members online
Shorts
No Foam
By Falken
23 April 2007
I'm quite pleased with this. So I need to be shown where it needs changing, editing and improving. 
And it's all true

True story this. There’s this family friend – let’s call him Bob – who’s a butler. Yep, that’s right, a genuine, wait-on-another-person,     be-looked-down-upon butler. I bet you don’t know one. He’s certainly the only one I know. Anyway, he’s a friend of the family because eons ago his father proposed to my late Grandmother. She turned him down, but they stayed friends and when both met other people, got married and had kids, Grandma became Godmother to his son, and the son became the aforementioned butler.

So, how did he become a butler you ask? Well, like the people he served, Bob was born into it. Y’see, his father was a butler, had been all his life, and when he passed away, Bob, then aged 14, took his place. He was never given a choice, but never thought of doing anything else. It was simply what was going to happen. Like being an heir to something, although not something wonderful.

Oh, the life that Bob leads. Sometimes he’s at the stately home in the country, but mostly he’s at the 5 storey town house in Mayfair. Sounds grand, doesn’t it? Well, it’s not, let me tell you.

Bob lets his guard down when he’s had a few whiskeys, and divulges little stories of the privileged and the great that his sober self never would. I visited him one night in Mayfair and persuaded him to crack open a bottle of the bosses best single malt. (I knew he wouldn’t get into trouble for this. He’s in charge of the household budget and does all the shopping, so a bottle of whiskey is nothing. Hell, you should see me wolf down his bosses smoked salmon, caviar and fine wines when offered.). My favourite story, and I’ve heard it countless times now, is the foam story. Bob swears it’s true. I believe him, for he’s not one to lie, and nothing about the people above him would surprise me anyway. They literally are above him by the way, and not just in their own hierarchical class system. Bob lives in the basement at the Mayfair place in a humble little flat.


So, the story goes like this. There’s a big shooting weekend at some toff’s large country pile. About fifty of this country’s landed gentry have converged on the estate, including Bob’s boss and thus Bob himself as well. Built 200 years before on the backs and toil of the local populace, the place was amazing, the grounds run into hundreds of acres and the shooting was, apparently, “spectacular”.

Let me translate for you here. Spectacular means that hundreds of pheasant and grouse have been bred especially to be shot out of the air. Spectacular means that hundreds are indeed shot. Spectacular means that a few are eaten and a few hung for later consumption. But spectacular also means that most are simply buried in the ground, in the grounds. Spectacular simply means lots and lots and lots of dead little birds, whose life existed solely for the purpose of being blasted out of the air by a braying man smothered in tweed and Barbour called Tristan, or Sebastian, or, I kid you not, Peregrine, which is the equivalent, I think, of me being called Magpie or Chaffinch.

Anyway, amongst these gathered toffs, snobs and work-shy inheritors was a Lord, who we’ll call Charles. Lord Charles was twenty seven at the time, an Oxbridge and Army reject (too lazy for study and too ‘much of a girl’ for the army, to quote his Major) who ‘worked’ for Daddy on Daddy’s estate, but actually did bugger all, truth be told, and was merely biding his time before Daddy died and he could inherit everything, including the title of Duke and the respect he believed would follow it. Well, Lord Charles was in a bit of a sulk at the end of the shooting. He’d shot only one thing (on account of him being quite scared of guns and unable to shoot without closing his eyes). Or, to be more precise, he’d shot nothing with wings and only one thing without – his valet. You heard me. He’d shot the man who’d looked after him since he was five, his ever-suffering valet, called Peter (although since the age twelve he’d pompously referred to Peter as his “Bagman” after hearing that’s what the President of the United States called his valet). Don’t start getting all worried. Peter the valet was fine and just needed the pellets removed from his backside and an overnight stay at the local hospital. And Peter never complained. Not once. A good valet shouldn’t, of course. Not like the beater the year before, who Lord Charles had also accidentally shot, this time in the arm, and who would never beat again, if you follow me. He’d yelled and cussed and had the temerity to insult the Lord, specifically questioning his eyesight. He was, of course, roundly removed from the shoot, the grounds, his cottage on the estate, and thus his life.


Anyway, following dinner, and in the middle of port and cigars with the other men, Lord Charles had feigned tiredness and gone to bed. Of course, all the Peregrines knew that he was acting like a petulant child, but no-one said anything because he was, after all, going to be Duke one day soon and a Duke is top of the toffs and commands respect, as Charles well knew. So, Lord Charles had been gone upstairs for just five minutes when he starts yelling and screaming and, I promise you, actually stamping his feet. The Peregrines put down their port and cigars, their Fenellas and Fionas and Beatrices looked up from their sherry and then in burst Charles, resplendent in blue and white striped pyjamas, holding his toothbrush and looking very distressed.

“It’s not foaming! It’s not foaming!”, he was yelling, “It’s not bloody foaming!!!”

“Calm down now Charles, what’s the problem?” asked a Peregrine.

“It’s not foaming!!” He’s quite distressed by this stage. It’s a high point of the story in my view. “There’s no foam!!!”. The poor man is almost at the point of tears.

“Your toothbrush?”, inquired a Beatrice.

“Yes, Yes", replied Charles rudely, "there’s no foam!!!”.


The Perigrines and Beatrices subtly exchanged looks that the unsubtle would not catch. They are quite amused, but cannot let it be seen. Lord Charles sees nothing.

“Charles, come with me and we’ll fix this, ok?”. A Peregrine took him gently by the arm and lead him back upstairs.

“It’s always foamed. It’s always foamed!” Lord Charles wailed as he climbed the steps.

The peregrine returned downstairs some minutes later and informed the group that he had, indeed, got Lord Charles’ toothbrush foaming very nicely, much to their amusement.

“I can’t believe the Duke makes his staff follow the old ways quite so rigorously”, states a fellow guest, another Lord who had bagged thirty pheasant and one fox that day. “I mean, the valet still putting toothpaste on his brush? You don’t suppose he still wipes his ar…”

“Really!”, squeals his Beatrice, acting disgusted at the thought but actually finding the whole thing very amusing.

Gravely, the Peregrine who had taken Lord Charles upstairs intoned, “Actually, I know for a fact he does. I know that valets are born to serve us, but one can’t help but feel sorry for that poor Peter”.

And that’s the story. Now, I know what you’re thinking. That can’t be true, can it? A grown man who has had toothpaste squeezed for him his whole life and doesn’t know how to do it for himself? Surely not? And having a man wipe his own bottom? No! It can’t be true. Can it?

Well, I’m sorry to say, but yes, it is. It’s all true. Bob doesn’t lie. Especially when he’s full of single malt.

Think about that next time you pick up your toothbrush.


 

Reviews

Written by wltshr (352 comments posted) 23rd April 2007
Ok. Nice story. Kind of thing told in pubs, and written in the same manner. 
 
Heard it before, of course, but with different character names. 
 
One little question, when the following was said, in company, by one of the Dukes friends: “I can’t believe the Duke makes his staff follow the old ways quite so rigorously. I mean, the valet still putting toothpaste on his brush? You don’t suppose he still wipes his ar…” Are you seriously suggesting that this exchange took place in front of Bob?  
 
Seemed more of a classist rant than a short story. 
 
Wltshr
Whoops.
Written by wltshr (352 comments posted) 23rd April 2007
Sorry, Falken. 
 
Just re-read your intro and I'm feelin a little guilty. 
 
Your story would have more impact if told either as a straight narrative or from a character's point of view. 
 
You cannot realistically include opinion or invective unless from the viewpoint of the character acting as narrator or in dialogue. 
 
I expect that this opinion may well differ from some of extremely competent short story writers on this site.  
 
Personally, I suggest you study the genre more closely, look closely at the actual skeleton of the story, and re-write if you feel you should.
OUCH
Written by Falken (14 comments posted) 23rd April 2007
OUCH

Written by Janie (265 comments posted) 23rd April 2007
Hi falken...i thought this quite funny in parts..the perigrines, tristrans sebastians etc...i bet they are called that too and married to fionas.:grin  
 
i hope bob gets paid well...hmmm living in mayfair huh, sounds terribly glamorous. You had a good hook at the beginning telling the reader you wereabout to divulge a secret but then the pace slowed somewhat...i think it could speeded up a bit...less digressing away from the main subject would help do this. 
 
 
i was also horrified that no one eats the birds...what a dreadful waste that they died for nothing more than a bit of enjoyment for some spoilt brat 'tim nice but dim' character. 
 
anyway, an enlightening read..in more ways than one..thanks
Wasted life Lord Charles
Written by swapnet (3 comments posted) 23rd April 2007
You've raised some pretty good questions in this work. Indeed, who are these rich people and who gives them the authority to keep human beings as slaves? They are these brats who hardly know a world exists outside their "palaces," and people sleep starving with nothing to eat. 
 
And you talk about this fellow called Charles who doesn't know how to squeeze toothpaste. There are hundreds of such people who need their shoelaces to be tied, walked to bedroom and spoon fed. Yes, what a waste of life. See, told you money can't buy everything!
Hi, Falken!
Written by Bagheera (685 comments posted) 23rd April 2007
See, I told you we don't bite! :grin - sometimes! - be more 
Others have picked up on points I would have made, and generally the only thing to remember is that "less can - sometimes! - be more". 
 
I think I can appreciate where wltshr is coming from re: "invective and opinion" in the mouth of a character - it's very difficult to do convincingly, you might want to edit some of this away (which is what I'm trying to say with my "less is more" comment, I think! :eek
 
Welcome aboard!
Amusing
Written by Asferthecat (859 comments posted) 25th April 2007
Amusingly written but a long run up to a weak ending. I do not agree that the birds are buried. They are given to the assembled company and the excess birds are sold to butchers etc. I bought some pheasant in Waitrose and it still had shot in it. 
There is nothing wrong with servants, indeed a rich person was always expected to have servants to spread the money around a bit. 
A bit too much of the snarl of the underdog coming from the storyteller 
Fair points, but.....
Written by Falken (14 comments posted) 26th April 2007
Fair points, well made. It can't be a surprise that I am a staunch republican, and I knew it read as much as a rant as everything else. But I do know for a fact that huge numbers of game are just buried on estates such as the one described.

Written by Signa (66 comments posted) 26th April 2007
Well I thought this was really well written. I enjoyed reading it, from beginning to end. I was a little slow to realise he hadn't put toothpaste on his toothbrush - I couldn't figure out what he was ranting about and even thought he instead put pile cream on or something. I eventually got it. Slow Signa.  
 
It felt to me as if it should have been a dialogue. I mean - as Wiltshr said - one character could have been telling this in a pub. But I don't see this as a bad thing. I thought the whole piece was really vivid.  
 
Who cares about the 'snarl' - that made it all the more interesting to read.  
 
I think it's OK that the narrator is projecting his own opinions and feelings on to Bob as he tells the story. If Bob had told the story himself he would have told have been more diplomatic and guarded. That's what we do when we re-tell stories. We add our own details and exaggerate (a bit).
Thanks Signa
Written by Falken (14 comments posted) 26th April 2007
Wow. Thanks.
No Foam
Written by CameronS (20 comments posted) 6th June 2007
I agree with quite a few of the above comments but rather than read stories and then just disappear I do try to leave a comment or two. 
 
A predictable story and there are many more in a similar vein. I agree it could be viewed as merely a classist rant. Bear in mind that some people on these estates earn a good living from 'toffs'. I thought the pace was ok and the voice quite strong, in a blokey, telling a joke kind of way, although it would probably be difficult to retain interest in a longer story. 
 
You are quite right that a huge number of birds are disposed of without ever reaching the shops. I don't shoot but I can pick up pheasant locally for just 50p. It's largely due to the fact that the majority of people seem to prefer burgers, ready meals or chicken nuggets. 
 
I liked the line about peregrine being the equivalent of magpie or chaffinch. Interesting point when written by someone using the name Falken. 
 
Best wishes.

   Only registered users can rate and write comments.
   Please login or register.

Powered by AkoComment 2.0!

 Previous item   Next item