No sooner have I started writing down my stories, I find myself wondering - why? Why am I writing them? It is not that I think I will be rich or famous from them. It's not like it isn't a lot of work. Yet I am compelled to. In my head they are fuzzy ideas and notions. But on paper they become something clearer, something more meaningful. I don't fully understand it.
Yesterday I finished reading a book where the main character spent years writing the story of her life. As well as meticulously detailing all her heartbreaks and mistakes, the pages explained to her now fifteen year old son why she abandoned him when he was four. Towards the end of the book, a stranger arrives to inform her of her imminent death. She hands him the manuscript and asks him to promise to burn every word. Then she dies. The stranger takes the manuscript to a beach and, without reading a word, builds a bonfire and burns it to ashes. The son lives on. He has to come to terms with the abandonment without reading why. This made me wonder: what purpose did it serve the woman to write everything down and then burn it without showing anyone? I think I understand. I had my own similar experience. When I was a little girl my parents drank a lot. My father was a violent alcoholic and a dictator. Excessive consumption of vodka was one way my mother rebelled against him. It may have empowered her, but it nearly destroyed me. Together, the two of them stole my childhood in ways too evil to tell. When I grew up I escaped to University as soon as I was legally able. I spent the next six or seven years working through my early traumas by writing them down. I scribbled on paper with pen or printed from word processor. The volume of my life grew into hundreds of pages of musings, flashbacks and memories. It was crudely lashed together with staples and Sellotape. Every time I moved house, I carried this weighty document around like a dark, guilty secret. It contained every sordid little detail, every embarrassing moment, every humiliating scene and every darkest revenge fantasy. I daren't throw it in the bin in case someone found and read it. When I moved in with my boyfriend I bought a box to seal the document inside. The box went in the garage. Every time someone went in there I froze. If someone were to discover and read the document, they would discover and read my soul. They would know everything. I read a poem once about a boy who killed a cat. He hid the cat's body in the cupboard under the stairs in his house. In his mind the cat grew and grew inside the cupboard. Inevitably one day the cupboard would burst open and an enormous black cat would come striding out. The day his horrific secret was revealed... This is what my guilty document was like. My awareness of it grew every day. One night I confessed to my boyfriend that this terrible secret lay in the garage. He nodded, understanding. Together we made a fire in the back garden, ignoring the neighbours' twitching curtains. And we burned it all. No one ever read it except me, not even my boyfriend as he tore pages from it to feed the hungry flames. The words became black smoke and swirled and vanished into the air. That writing was not for reading. The words were not even for me to read. What was important was the act of writing, a confession. Burning the pages lifted the weight of the guilt from my shoulders. I was free. Just like the woman in the book. Why do we write I wonder? What is an unread work? It is a one-sided conversation, a monologue that no one hears. Is that a waste? I have stories in my head. Storied that I want to write down, that I need to write down. But does anyone else need to read them? I wonder about trying to get published. Is that important? Maybe it is not. Maybe we write because we need to. Maybe it is not a career move or a search for fame or riches. Maybe it is simply an expression of what is deep within ourselves. Maybe that is all. Maybe that is enough... |
Written by Bottleblondesurfer (3362 comments posted) 24th April 2007 | I think it was Somerset-Maugham who said "The biggest set back for a writer is a happy childhood" Most stories are about drama and drama is based on conflict and a happy childhood wouldn't provide that experience,I suppose. I think there are two types of writing :- Writing for you own benefit, as a sort of therapy or catharsis which is not meant for an audience Writing to entertain or engage others and is structured for an audience They can both be inspired by the same incidents and experiece but they will be very different pieces "I have stories in my head. Storied that I want to write down, that I need to write down. But does anyone else need to read them?" ----You will never know unless you present them to the public but you have to stand back and make them coherent and with a unversal appeal. I don't think a simple expression of what is deep within ourselves is enough, not for a mass audience. Just one reation others may disagree. I hope you find your own way Jane | Hi Signa Written by jean.day (2283 comments posted) 24th April 2007 | I read this with great interest, and was sorry that you decided to burn your memories. But of course they are all still in your head and you could rewrite them again if you wanted to. You write so well, and I have very much enjoyed reading what you have posted so far. I am hoping you will share a lot more of your experiences with us, in some form or other. A lot of the stuff I write on this site is based on my personal memories, and I was so scared to get reactions from the group when I first posted these things. And then when I found that not only did they appreciate them, but they seemed to understand, it gave me an enormous amount of confidence. So bit by bit, I translated my boxes of memories up in the attic into stories - some that I posted and some that I didn't - but I feel better for having them in a proper format and for sharing them. I have also written up memories of my children's childhood experiences, (before they were old enough to remember for themselves) and have put these into book form - which I hope they will be very pleased to have one day. | Written by Witzl (1585 comments posted) 24th April 2007 | I also read this with great interest. and thought this was a very thought-provoking and well-expressed piece of writing. I like what Jane wrote about happy childhoods and how they do not help to further the career of a writer. Reading your essay, I was thinking of this very quote myself (though I didn't know it was Somerset Maugham who'd said it), and reflecting a little enviously that you are bound for greatness having had such a difficult childhood. And no wonder you already write so well. As for the journal you kept and then burned, I think you were definitely using writing as therapy when you made your entries, but I also think you were also doing something else: you were trying to make sense of your own childhood. What Jean says is right; you have your own memories in your head even though you burned your journal, and I cannot help but think that because you have written everything down, you have a better understanding of what happened to you and can sort through your memories the more easily and work to find some sort of closure. Personally, I write because I find that it helps me to organize my thoughts. I'm not as good at speaking as I hope that I am at writing; I get bogged down in details and have a circuitous conversational style that drives a lot of people wild. So writing, for me, is one way of making sure I can martial my thoughts and say what I want to say. | Bluntly , Written by patterjack (1196 comments posted) 24th April 2007 | Whether you are writing therapeutically for yourself or writing to engage others -- the main thing for you is to write , and if you feel like it , then get it out into public gaze. There will be plenty who will condemn ,or give good or bad advice -- as that is the nature of this game -- possibly fewer who will praise, so enjoy them -- but the important person to please is you yourself . Never forget that . patterjack | Written by Signa (66 comments posted) 24th April 2007 | Thanks Jane, I think you are right that the writing I burned in the back garden was not exactly the same kind of writing I am currently attempting, with my stories. There are different kinds. I don't know why I didn't think of that while I was writing this. I think I will write for my audience as if it were me alone. I'll see where that gets me and change if necessary. Hi Jean, don't feel bad that I burned the memories. They are clearer in my mind now because I wrote them down in the first place. What always worried me is if I died unexpectedly and my mother were ever to read it, it would hurt her greatly to read how much I hated her at times. She is not an evil woman but she went through a very dark period which, unfortunately for me, was my childhood. Burning the document was also an act of forgiveness. It was drawing a line under it and saying "it's all in the past now - lets move forward". I still have the experiences to draw on. There was a lot of rage and anger in those pages. Some truly shocking revenge fantasies that I think are better off destroyed. They do no good now to anyone. I think it's a wonderful idea to write your children's childhood experiences down. What a thoughtful gift. We all love hearing stories of our own childhood - having it in a book would be something very special. They are very lucky. Thank you for your encouraging comments. | Written by Signa (66 comments posted) 24th April 2007 | Hi Mary, Thank you for your kind comments. I think you are right about writing things down to make sense of them. It's true, once you make sense of things (or at least get them in some sort of order), you remember them more easily. A bit like filling them away in your mind. Instead of having huge messy piles of memories, it's all cross references and colour coded. (OK maybe I took that too far. ) patterjack - that's great advice - thank you. I won't forget Jane - I should have said that I never thought of my childhood as being any kind of advantage so thank you for that quote. I think it's another one for the wall! | Written by Lizzy (800 comments posted) 24th April 2007 | What an interesting response to your writing. Both what you wrote and others contributions give me a reason to continue writing. Thanks Signa Lizzy | Hi Signa Written by Clifftown (620 comments posted) 25th April 2007 | Your piece really spoke to me in lots of ways. I have diaries and unsent letters hidden in my house from my own childhood years, which were not the best to say the least. You expressed perfectly the feeling of dread at the idea of someone else "reading your soul". It must have taken so much courage to burn your memories, I still can't bring myself to get rid of mine - even though I'm sometimes kept awake at night by the thought of someone reading them! Thanks for sharing this, it was a really interesting and thought-provoking read.
| Written by Glossa (18 comments posted) 26th April 2007 | | I have written and rewritten my story many times over the years. Each time I destroy it afterwards but each time I learn a little more and become more forgiving and less revengeful. Things that kept me awake at night before now sometimes make me laugh. It is therapy but sometimes while either writing, or even more satisfying in a strange way, ripping it up into tiny pieces, an idea comes to me for a story that is not about me but inspired by my experiences. It's a kind of visitation from a muse that is buried in there and can only come out if I free up some other memories that I've chained up with resentment. Keep writing. Sometimes it's just for you and sometimes it will demand to be shared! | Written by Gill21 (566 comments posted) 26th April 2007 | A thought provoking piece and very well written. I understand what you mean. My teenagers years were difficult and i kept many diaries. Not for any purpose except to get all my thoughts out of my head. Before i went away to University i threw them away as a way of 'moving on'. I think some things happen in your life that you never really 'get over' but you can put it behind you every step you make. Going through difficult times in a way is a small blessing, especially as a writer. I think if you can't feel, you can't write, you can't speak to people, so having painful memories can help others too. Many times i have been given comfort from a total stranger, in the form of a novel. Like Jane said there are different kinds of writing; for yourself and for others. It's either in your blood, and you'll do it until you die because you need to, like a primal force. Or you do it for money. I don't care about the money so much as i'd like to share what i write with others, but even if i never get published, i'll always get some kind of enjoyment and relief from my writing. A feeling that makes me feel almost more 'whole'. I think that's enough And at least we can share it with each other on here! | Written by Signa (66 comments posted) 26th April 2007 | Thank you Lizzy, Clifftown, Glossa and Gill for your comments. Lizzy: I agree - the responses have been very interesting and helpful. I've enjoyed reading them Clifftown, I'm happy that this spoke to you. Thank you for your encouragement. Glossa, what a great image about releasing the muse by destroying the writing. I may use that in a future story! Gill, I like your attitude. I agree. This forum is marvelous. I'm glad I came here. Signa xx | Written by ellipinnock (1753 comments posted) 26th April 2007 | Touching piece. Not much to add to the above really. Just to say, good for you. Get writing - chuck a few stories out here and you'll get some honest opinions back. It doesn't matter whether you write for yourself or for an audience as long as you are happy with what you write and you can separate the two. Look forward to reading some fiction from you! Elli | Written by Fledermaus (3306 comments posted) 28th April 2007 | This is very interesting... I wonder how you felt when you burnt it. Was it a pity because of all this work you had put into it, or was it a relief, because you could literally throw away your past? I can imagine it's a bit like why people confess. They have a problem they can't talk about, they confess it and it's off their chest. Whether the priest forgets about it or not isn't their problem anymore. This was certainly tought-provoking and I bet I'll still be thinking about it tomorrow...
| Written by Phil (6730 comments posted) 28th April 2007 | You've been well reviewed and I've nothing new to add really. I thought it was well written - touching without being mawkish or overly sentimental. Good stuff. Phil. |
Only registered users can rate and write comments. Please login or register. Powered by AkoComment 2.0! |