Here's my third attempt to get something on a Talking Heads theme for my U3A assignment. Thanks to those of you who read my last attempt. I took it off because I thought it wasn't all that appropriate. It was mostly a true story as is this one. I've gone over the 1000 word maximum, but I can shave a few of the details off if I decide to submit it. I haven’t thought about you for ages. It was a word in a blog that I read yesterday that brought you to my mind. I wonder where you are now, and if you are alive, and if you are happy - if you ever were happy.
I met you back in 1964 when you were doing your master’s at North Dakota State University - and I was working on my degree. And not only was I studying, but I was doing odd jobs to make enough money to pay my way. That’s where you came into it. You were my employer.
When I think back to what you looked like, it is quite clear in my mind. You were fairly short, and quite plump, and you always wore white blouses and patterned skirts and a cardigan - almost like a uniform You had blond hair, I think, and I have the feeling it was curly - but you wore it in a very simple style - perhaps you wore a barette to keep it out of your eyes. I think maybe your eyes were blue, but the main thing one noticed about them was that they didn’t work together. One was looking to the right and one to the left, because, of course, they weren't looking at all. You were blind.
I don’t think you had been blind from birth, but as a side effect of your diabetes. You had primary diabetes which required you to give yourself insulin injections every morning. How you did it, being blind, I am not sure - but I think you injected into muscle rather than a vein, so maybe you just aimed for your thigh and hoped for the best. Perhaps the amount of the injection was pre-established in some way - like the insulin coming in a guaranteed right size packet for your type of problem. But I rather doubt it, after all this was long before things became so convenient and disposable.
You employed me, and many other girls like me, to read to you. I remember when you interviewed me, you asked me to read as fast as I could - which was no problem as I speak rapidly anyway. But when I put expression into the words, you stopped me and said, “Don’t do that. This is not a play you are reading. It’s philosophy, and I can decide myself what importance to put on words. Just read flatly and fast.”
I was disappointed, as I knew I had a pleasant, low voice, and had taken many parts in plays over the years. But you were the one who was paying me $3 an hour to read to you, so if I wanted the job, I had to do as you asked.
We hardly ever spoke of other matters. I would arrive at 3 p.m., you would indicate which book to read, and I would start and only stop when the hour was up. I don’t know how you made any sense of it at all. I probably read six chapters an hour, and I didn’t remember a word of it after I had left. But you didn’t take notes. I don’t know how you translated what I read into what you were then going to write in your thesis. I didn’t ask if you hired a typist or even if you could type yourself. I’ll bet you dictated into a microphone attached to a tape recorder. Mostly it was Spinoza I read, and sometimes when you needed a specific book, we would spend part of the time with me helping you find the right book in the basement archives of the campus library.
You managed to get around the campus on your own. with the help of your white cane. You took your meals at the student union, so you managed to get there, and to the lectures in other departments that you wanted to get to. So one day, when it was my job to serve a Hostess Meal for my advanced nutrition class, and needed to invite a guest, I asked you and you seemed very pleased and happy about the idea.
“The home ec department is just across the campus from our dorm,” I said. “The cookery room is on the third floor, and the lab we are using is the first on the left.”
“I shall be able to find that easily,” you said, and I believed you.
I prepared grilled chicken, squash rings with peas in the middle, cooked dandelion greens, and strawberries. I had planned the meal to be low in carbohydrate, knowing that you were a severe diabetic. The meal was due to be served at 12 sharp, and I had set the table, and had all the food ready and waiting, but you didn’t show up. We waited ten minutes, but then my teacher said we would have to go ahead without you.
I was marked down for the meal, despite the food being good and well prepared, as I hadn’t been a very good hostess and didn't make much of an effort to keep the conversation going. But all during the meal, all I could think of was, where are you? Why hadn’t you come? I should have sent someone to help you. I should have realised that it was too much for you to do, when you didn’t know the way or any of the people in the department except for me.
As soon as the class was over, I went to see you. “I’m sorry,” you said, “but I just couldn’t face it.”
And so things went on, and I read and you learned and progressed, and then came the morning when I was walking down the corridor and I could hear a moaning coming from your room. I was going to knock but just then our dorm mother came out of your room, saying that you was desperately ill and that the ambulance was on the way.
It transpired that early that morning, you had injected yourself and then gone back to bed. No food. You were having a insulin reaction - and you nearly died.
When you came back to the dorm, the reading continued, and I asked you about the accident. “I was so tired, I went back to sleep and when I woke up I was in the hospital,” you explained. But I never really did believe you. I think you knew well what you was doing and what you intended the result to be.
When the year finished, and I had had my last reading session for you, we said good-bye, without much emotion. You didn’t come back the next year - maybe you had finished your studies, maybe you had gone to another University, maybe you had had more success on your next attempt.
But one thing I will always wonder about is whether if I had been a friend to you - rather than just your employee; if I had cared enough to have thought through your problems and knocked on your door when you weren’t paying me; if I had arranged for you to come and eat my dandelion greens with a bit more forethought, then perhaps I wouldn’t now be crying now when I think of you.
|
Written by ellipinnock (1753 comments posted) 27th April 2007 | Jean, I thought this was a really good piece. Very moving and simply told which made it all the more powerful. I think we all look back sometimes and think that maybe if we had treated a particular person with a bit more kindness and consideration that things might have gone better for them - I do anyway. I liked the other talking heads piece you posted but this one is better I think: the first person works really well in this case and the directness. It wil stay with me for a while I think. Elli | Written by Bottleblondesurfer (3133 comments posted) 27th April 2007 | It might be over the 1000 word limit but I don't think they will notice,it was such an easy and addictive read. I think this is one of your best pieces. It is written so simply and honestly, almost journalistically but you can sense the emotion underneath and at the end when you actually express it, it is very moving. Like all good writing it has a universal message. How we look back on the people we were then and wish we had been different but the young just don't have the life experience or confidence to act in the best way. You couldn't do anything else then being the person you were. There's a lot of meaning here Jane | Written by Livinginanattic (454 comments posted) 27th April 2007 | Like the above I thought this was a very powerful, moving story. I liked the way the story unfolded. It's funny how we remember things that happened such a long time ago and wonder what would happen if we had acted differently. Cheers | Written by Witzl (1585 comments posted) 27th April 2007 | | Everyone else has said everything already, Jean, but I too was drawn in by this piece and moved by it. I think about things like this all the time, too -- people I should have made more of an attempt to understand, or been kinder and/or more grateful to. Powerful writing. | Thanks Elli,Jane,Mary and LIA Written by jean.day (2190 comments posted) 28th April 2007 | | I'm pleased that you liked this piece, and hope the creative writing group will too. | Written by Janie (265 comments posted) 28th April 2007 | Hello Jean, what a lovely and touching story. Life's full of 'if onlies' isn't it. How sad she felt like that, but reading this she came across as the kind of person who wouldn't let others get close, so you musn't feel like you could have done more. She wouldn't allow you to. Anyway, since this is your assignment for your U3A I thought 'd give it a thorough dissecting. Please remember what I have written is only my opinion and the suggestions are for you to take or leave..and most importantly please don't hate me! I wonder where you are now, and if you are alive, and if you are happy - if you ever were happy. This sentence is a little clunky..how about turning it around and making them into questions, like alan bennett did. I wonder where you are now. Are you alive? Are you happy? Were you ever happy? quite plump quite plump? she was either plump or not...‘quite’ is a non descript word, it adds to the word count and tells us nothing..same thing could apply to fairly short too. and you always wore white blouses and patterned skirts and a cardigan Too many ‘ands’ in one sentence You could start a new sentence here to elminate one and use a ‘with’ to eliminate another. You always wore white blouses with patterned skirts and a cardigan. uniform You... Missing full stop. Blond is male blonde is the female perhaps you wore a barette to keep it out of your eyes. I think maybe your eyes were blue, but the main thing one noticed about them was that they didn’t work together. One was looking to the right and one to the left, because, of course, they weren't looking at all. You were blind. All this is too vague and dithery ‘perhaps’ and ‘I think maybe’… it slows the pace, my attention wandered at this point. You could say something like ‘I remember your eyes. They didn’t work together, with one looking to the left and the other to the right. I could never tell if you were looking at me, but you couldn’t have been. (there’s no need to say ‘you were blind‘, cos in the very next sentence you let us know that anyway) You had primary diabetes which required you to give yourself insulin injections every morning. How you did it, being blind, I am not sure - but I think you injected into muscle rather than a vein, so maybe you just aimed for your thigh and hoped for the best. Perhaps the amount of the injection was pre-established in some way - like the insulin coming in a guaranteed right size packet for your type of problem. But I rather doubt it, after all this was long before things became so convenient and disposable. Here again, the pace slows as we’re bogged down with detail. Something like… I don’t think you had been blind from birth, but as a side effect of your diabetes. How you managed to inject the insulin each day, getting it in the right place, was feat in itself and one that I marvelled at. (I’m sure you could re-phrase this much better than I but you get the idea…straight to the point and gets to it without uninteresting details in half the words.) And so things went on, and I read and you learned and progressed, and then came the morning when I was walking down the corridor and I could hear a moaning coming from your room. Too many ‘ands’ five a insulin an insulin I'm not trying to re-write this for you and please feel free to ignore my suggestions as that's all they are. I did struggle with the flow of this piece and think some minor adjustments would aid the flow...the thing that stopped the flow for me more than anything was the amount of 'ands' you've used throughout...often they can be cut out and a phrase or clause used without a conjunction makes the writing flow better. Also a couple of parts i've pointed out where there's too much superfluous information that is neither interesting or adds to the piece and slows the pace (imo) the content of the actual story is wonderful though and i enjoyed it very much. the end i found very poignant.
| Written by Lizzy (781 comments posted) 29th April 2007 | Agree with what others have said. Obviously written from the heart. Have read Janie's review which was very good, she certainly reads things very carefully and thoughtfully and I do think she makes some good points. You've now set me thinking about my'what ifs'. Lizzy | thanks Janie and Lizzy Written by jean.day (2190 comments posted) 29th April 2007 | What a wonderful help you are, Janie, with your detailed review. Thank you very much. I agree that I have a problem with too many ands, buts and of courses. I tend to write very quickly - and more or less type things just as they come out of my head - and then do a quick edit and it's done. I know that careful editing would benefit all my work - but I have the sort of personality that wants things to be finished so that is my justification for my sloppiness.
| Written by Fledermaus (3159 comments posted) 30th April 2007 | An interesting piece. Yet I doubt if she'd appreciated it if you just became her friend out of pity. It's interesting that a blind person would use the phrase "I couldn't face it". I remember a blind freshman at our departement who had to laugh when someone forgot she was blind and said 'there', while pointing at something. 'There' didn't have much meaning to her. I wonder how she reads her books, as I don't think they've all been translated into braille... | It's all been said! Written by Clifftown (619 comments posted) 30th April 2007 | But I will leave my mark anyway. This is a wonderfully touching piece, which I enjoyed reading. Like most of the others, it has made me think.
| Thanks Fledermaus and Nina Written by jean.day (2190 comments posted) 30th April 2007 | | I have various relatives and friends in stages of blindness due to macular degeneration - and it is interesting how often the world "see" comes up in conversations - and then we try to change it but just make the situation worse. | Written by Phil (6383 comments posted) 30th April 2007 | Hi Jean. Just about all been said. I've read a lot of your work and I think this is the best of it. It's direct, honest, clear - yet for all that, it's still emotional. Somehow, I think, you touched her life Jean. The likelyhood is that you'll never know how. There's a great quote from Zen and the Art of Motorcycle Maintenance (I think). Something like: 'We pass unnoticed through other people's lives.' But I always thought we have some impact. Thanks for the great read, Phil. | Thanks Phil Written by jean.day (2190 comments posted) 1st May 2007 | | I'm always pleased to have a review from you. I read Zen and the Art of Motorcycle Maintenance. In fact a quoted a chunk of it in the first big piece of writing I did - many years ago - because the guy drove across North Dakota and gave one of the most wonderful descriptions of the state (which is pretty flat) that I have ever read. | Written by coosh (822 comments posted) 1st May 2007 | | The strength of the emotional impact in this piece is by effect, rather than in the actual telling.... which works extremely well because of the (deceptive) simplicity in the way you recount so many of your stories. Phil's comment is interesting... there was a guy I knew as a student, we had a fairly healthy, albeit sometimes rather fiery relationship, and several years after uni and going our separate ways, I got a call from his mother inviting me to his funeral (he'd been murdered) - she'd managed to trace me, and for some reason, he'd wanted me to have his watch... I've never fathomed out why. Fascinating read, Jean. | Thanks Coosh Written by jean.day (2190 comments posted) 2nd May 2007 | | I'm not quite sure what you mean by effect - but I will take it as something positive anyway. | Written by coosh (822 comments posted) 2nd May 2007 | | Impact through understatement, I suppose. Sometimes your pieces are deceptively gentle in style, in proportion to what is gained from reading between the lines vis-a-vis the subject matter. Yes, it was intended to be positive, I really enjoy it. Thank you for pointing out my departure into pseudo-intellectual nonsense, perhaps it was "too early for gin"! |
Only registered users can rate and write comments. Please login or register. Powered by AkoComment 2.0! |