READING ROOM
Great Writing - Home
Read and review others' work
Articles on writing
Advice from the community
COMMUNITY
Talk to others in the forums
Events and Competitions
GW News
ABOUT GREAT WRITING
All About Us
Contact Us
WORK AWAITING REVIEW
GW IS...
Great Writing creative writing community is designed to prompt ideas and provide inspiration and motivation within aspiring and amateur authors. Whatever your topic; from love poetry to Doctor Who or Harry Potter fan fiction, Great Writing's online writing group is where you can make new friends and improve your creative writing.
WHO'S ONLINE
We have 1408 guests online and 5 members online
Shorts
Tangerines
By EmilyKevil
03 May 2007
slightly revised on 5/3/07

Gramma told a lot of stories. She always had since I was just a little girl. I always wondered if they were true or not. Could these strange experiences she recalled actually be reality? Or just stories she'd once heard -- stories that, in her old age, she mixed up with her past. But I do know that each one of these stories meant something to her, something she wanted me to understand as well. She did live a long ninety six years, so surely she knew what life smelled like. She knew its scent of passion, of love, of joy, of innocence, of insanity, of freedom. She wanted to share these scents with me.


It was on my thirteenth birthday that she told me about the town.

"It smelled of tangerines and deception, mostly," Gramma had said. "But I could only smell the tangerines at the time. The locals told me that the tangerines didn't grow on trees, that they fell from the sunlit sky as if by magic. Their breath had a scent of craze to it, however. It was a scent that was detectable by anyone sane enough to smell it."

At the age of thirteen, I did not fully understand what my grandmother was telling me through this story. I had trouble imagining how the town could smell so strongly of tangerine without any tangerine trees. They had to grow on trees.

"At the time, I was not sane enough to smell the craze on their breaths." Gramma continued. "I was a mixed up girl back then. I was eighteen years old. I smelled newly discovered freedom and passion, but I could not smell lies or craze. I could not smell a warning. I did not want to. When they told me that tangerines fell from the sky, I believed them. They smelled so truthful. They smelled so kind. But this was all just perfume. Tangerine perfume."

I still could not understand this at the time. How could Gramma smell truth? How could she smell kindness? And how did she now know that it was not genuine kindness, but a perfume?

"So what I want you to promise me, my little angel," Gramma held my hands in hers and looked me straight in the eye at this point. "is to do something I didn't realize one could do for a long, long time. Peel the tangerine and taste it. How does it taste? See the faces of the locals. How do they look? Feel their skin. Is it soft? Do not trust your nose."

Reviews

Written by Snodlander (501 comments posted) 3rd May 2007
What an unusual and original premise. Grans can appear to be crazy, can't they. My Nan would tell me how flowers would fight, so you had to be careful which flowers you allowed together in a vase. Some were so aggressive they couldn't share a room with others. 
 
This was a short story, but it could be made even tighter. Some of your phrases are a tad wordy. E.g. 'Whether they were all true experiences or over exaggerated tales is still a mystery to me.' could be written 'Whether they were all true or not is still a mystery to me.' 
 
Paras 4 and 6 contain some repetition. I would end para 4 after 'They had to grow on trees.'. Then add a little to para 6 along the lines of 'How could Gramma smell truth? How could she not smell deception?' 
 
Also watch your grammar (as well as your gramma). E.g. 'it's' should be 'its'. 
 
I'm picking this story to pieces only because it is such an original piece that I want you to make it shine like gold. At the risk of sounding patronising I would never have guessed that you were 15. This is a great story that I enjoyed reading.
Hello Emily
Written by stevetroster (1549 comments posted) 3rd May 2007
You have plenty of time ahead of you in which to polish your writing skills, the important thing is that you have started to write (some people wait 'til they're a ripe old age before they start!) 
Take on board what Snodlander has already said, and have a look through your work with the intention of removing and tweeking. 
E.G. "I, at the time however, was not sane enough to smell..." Would you actually talk like this? 
'However at the time I was not sane enough...'  
 
I wouldn't recommend cutting too much out (if anything I would suggest that you extend it - i'm sure that gran would have had so much more to say during her long life!) So with that in mind, I would not agree with Snodlanders succinct version of 'experiences and tales'. 
'Tales', to me, always suggests a fib, whereas 'Story' does what it says on the tin. So rather than cut the line down (and reduce your word count!) just reword it.  
This is my version of how you could have started, and it only a suggestion, because at the end of the day the work is yours. 
'Ever since I had been a little girl gramma had always loved telling me stories, and to this day I still can't be certain if they were all her own experiences or just stories that she herself had been told when she was my age.' etc 
Enjoy your writing, enjoy your future. 
Best wishes 
steve. 
 

Written by Janie (265 comments posted) 3rd May 2007
hi emily, this was a really lovely piece full of metaphors and very sensory too. i love the image of tangerines, very pretty, and they smell delicious too, unlike cheese & onion crisps, so a great choice of sensory image, along with the others, i bet they all smell nice, apart from deception... kindness, i have that down as channel #5 (ish)... grans are weird sometimes, aren't they? but very wise. i hope i got the message correctly at the end, look deeper and you see the real person underneath..that's what i took from this story anyway...if not, i would really love to know what gran was telling her grandaughter. 
 
enjoyed reading, it had a lovely restful atmosphere, i liked the narrator's voice and i love what gran says at the end and how she speaks to her g'daughter. 
 
look forward to reading more of your work. 8)

Written by Phil (6645 comments posted) 7th May 2007
Already thoroughly reviewed, so not much to add. You created a believable voice in a short space - good going. I liked the poetic lilt this had. It does need tidying up a little, but excellent considering your age. Many more mature writers on this site do not write as well as this. 
 
Good stuff. 
 
Phil.
Hello
Written by Josie (2732 comments posted) 22nd December 2007
Hello Emily. I go along with what people have already said, and if anything really annoys me it is when people post work on Great Writing without having checked the spelling and grammar. This is so important if you want to be a writer. It's = it is. When you use it to show possession, it doesn't follow the usual rules. Make sure you go over "apostrophes" and understand them well. I liked your story, but felt it was a prelude to something more. I am a grandma and, although my grandchildren are small, I am making a point of spending as much time with them as I can and letting them know how much I love them. Talking will follow, but they have a granny who h as written a lot of poems for children. ha ha.

   Only registered users can rate and write comments.
   Please login or register.

Powered by AkoComment 2.0!

 Previous item   Next item