READING ROOM
Great Writing - Home
Read and review others' work
Articles on writing
Advice from the community
COMMUNITY
Talk to others in the forums
Events and Competitions
GW News
ABOUT GREAT WRITING
All About Us
Contact Us
WORK AWAITING REVIEW
GW IS...
Great Writing creative writing community is designed to prompt ideas and provide inspiration and motivation within aspiring and amateur authors. Whatever your topic; from love poetry to Doctor Who or Harry Potter fan fiction, Great Writing's online writing group is where you can make new friends and improve your creative writing.
WHO'S ONLINE
We have 915 guests online and 10 members online
Poetry
yesno
By aleatoric_rhetoric
03 June 2007
i hold my words to be equivocalident.

like the pretty girl
who gets told she's
beautiful (too
much)

or the clever kid
who gets mistaken
for intelligent (all
the
time)

"if i'm so pretty then
&
"if i'm so smart then


why

--something that isn't
necessarily as smart
or as pretty as they
feel you want them to
be--

ask if there is a god and
see something beautiful
and
think
*yeah!
hey,
why
not?*

'maybe!'

loose leaf definitions of
big time descriptions
make for a all-inclusive
night club filled with the
uglies and weirdos and
old time hair-dos:
the types that come to
walmart
at
night--the types of creatures
that you find at
the bottom of the
ocean with their self-sufficient
light
things

"are not we all
philosophers?"

yeah: sure; uh
yesno

and

is there a god?

yeah: uh; sure
yesno

these addages--
i spread them over my toast
in order to make a more per
fect breakfast, never realizing
that this is a sometimes
world and
the sometimes make little ruts
and grooves in our vinyl and when
you play it back
fuck
sure
yeah you can come up with
some kind of description
"that
sounds like god"

we are all
speculative
philosophers contemplating
meanings--but the thing is

one man is the sayer of
shit and men are the affirmers
and if you listen
its just a big bad chain of
yesnoyesnoyesnoyesnoyesno
yesnoyesnoyesnoyesnoyesno
and when the clock strikes
nine everyone laughs and says

'maybe!'

and

'see you tomorrow!'

and

'maybe!'

Reviews

Written by Josie (2847 comments posted) 3rd June 2007
I don't think that you can call this poetry - just a load of words punctuated by a line end - and it isn't necessary to use foul language to give it a lift. I'm sorry to have to say this, but this is my opinion.

Written by Phil (6997 comments posted) 3rd June 2007
Oh dear. I don't object to the strong language in the least, but there's plenty of other stuff to object to here. 
 
I confess I'm no poet, but I do have very broad tastes. This however, reads as if you've written down he first thing that came to mind after waking up from a (confused) dream. There are moments of lucidity, but on the whole, and taken as a whole, it is a jumble of words. It needs a very thorough edit - spelling, punctuation and grammar is poor. Just because you think you are writing poetry doesn't mean you can abandon the conventions of written English. I say 'think' you've written poetry. I don't think you have. Words don't become poetry because the writer says they are - they become poetry when they comunicate meaning and challenge the reader - usually in a structure that at least provides a bit of a pulse. 
 
I'll happily take it on the chin if some poetic reviews and says what a wonderful piece - though I doubt that will happen. I've been wrong before - but I don't think I am this time. 
 
I do feel guilty being quite so negative. However, it's in a public forum awaiting public review...Sorry. 
 
Phil 
 

Written by fellpony (1749 comments posted) 3rd June 2007
I applaud your attempt to make sense of societal norms, but I consider the form of this to be wrong for the subject. I'm afraid it isn't poetry.  
 
"loose leaf definitions of 
big time descriptions" is quite fun, but it would hit harder if you focused down onto specifics, rather than abstractions. 
 
You might make something of it as prose, but you need to think it through a bit more, don't you, when you can't call it a poem.

Written by aleatoric_rhetoric (1 comments posted) 3rd June 2007
i was going to reply and say "you guys are wild--thank you" but instead i'll just say thank you--i mean if i object to any of this i'd just come off as a bitter sailor: but I will say 
 
"semantic antics"

Written by clochard (2 comments posted) 3rd June 2007
Well, not wanting to sound like the big devil's advocate here, I have to say I think this IS poetry.  
 
There is something of Corso or Bukowski to this, in it's lyrical, spoken beat, the fluid, running thought-processes. 
 
It's a broad church is poetry. 
 
 
 
 
 
 

   Only registered users can rate and write comments.
   Please login or register.

Powered by AkoComment 2.0!

 Previous item   Next item